BMW’s new petrol and EV 3 series are so similar even its engineers confuse them – so can you work out which is which?

SOME twins are easy to tell apart – like Arnie and Danny DeVito.
Others are identical — like Jedward. The new BMW 3 Series is more Jedward.

One of them pictured here is petrol. The other one’s electric.

A red BMW i3 50 xDrive and a silver BMW parked in a driveway in front of a modern house.
The new BMW 3 Series’ petrol and electric versions so similar that even engineers can struggle to set them apart Source: © Wolfgang Groeger-Meier
A red BMW sedan driving on a winding country road under a partly cloudy sky.
The red car has a hot 3-litre straight-six petrol engine under the hood Source: Bernhard Filser

But can you work out which is which? Even BMW engineers confuse them. OK, I’ll tell you.

The red car has a hot 3-litre straight-six petrol engine under the hood.

If you look really, really closely you might notice the bonnet is slightly lower and longer and there’s a wider gap between the front wheels and doors.

The biggest giveaway, of course, is the quad exhaust system at the back.

Electric cars don’t have poo chutes. But everything else mirrors the silver i3. Clever stuff.

BMW promised the advanced design and tech of its “Neue Klasse” (new class) EVs would be injected into petrol cars. So no one misses out. It kept its word.

Right, let’s start with the petrol “3”, the beating heart of Bavarian Motor Works for more than 50 years.

That M350 xDrive (xDrive meaning four-wheel drive) made my neck hairs all tingly dancing down some tasty mountain roads.

A red BMW M5 driving on a rural road surrounded by fields and trees.
BMW promised the advanced design and tech of its ‘Neue Klasse’ (new class) EVs would be injected into petrol cars Source: Bernhard Filser
A man drives a BMW on a sunny road, looking straight ahead, with his reflection visible in the rearview mirror.
BMW has been perfecting this car for more than 50 years Source: Bernhard Filser

Proper driver’s car. Smooth and satisfying at any speed, fine ride and handling, slick eight-speed gearbox, great soundtrack, yet super comfy.

Like I said, BMW has been perfecting this car for more than 50 years.

Also worth noting. The M350 is not even a full-fat M car — that’s still to come — but it has more oomph than an M3 from ten years ago, and drift mode.

The line-up starts from £45k with the regular 320, which is rear-wheel drive with a 2-litre four-cylinder petrol engine, 211hp and 37mpg.

Now, for the i3 50 xDrive. The numbers say this silver bullet is more potent than the M350, with 469hp under your right.

But it’s 300kg heavier at 2.2 tonnes, so it’s not as quick from the lights, not as deft in the corners, and you sit slightly higher.

M performance versions will follow later, including a wild quad-motor M3 to be unveiled in Las Vegas in January.

On the upside, i3 is hugely competent. It’s quiet, sophisticated and reassuring — and has an official WLTP range of five hundred and sixty six miles. Mic drop.

BMW M350 xDRIVE

Key facts

  • Price: £66,785
  • Engine: 3-litre inline 6cyl petrol
  • Power: 443hp
  • 0-62mph: 4.1 secs
  • Top speed: 155mph
  • Economy: 34mpg
  • CO2: 187g/km
  • Out: January

So it’s a proper long-range cruiser and can be recharged in next to no time at all.

Whichever one you go for, petrol or EV, the cabin layout is identical.

That means an oblique central screen and a slim digital display that’s highly configurable running all the way across the bottom of the windscreen. I like it.

Head-up Display projects speed and satnav on to the windscreen so the driver keeps their eyes on the road. There are lots of well-chosen materials in here, lots of handy storage, decent headroom and a decent boot.

Actually, the petrol “3” has a slightly bigger      boot, 450 litres v 420 litres.

But the EV’s frunk (front trunk) levels things up.

Need more space?

Soon we’ll be seeing double again with the petrol “3” Touring and the electric i3 Touring.

The Jedward of estate cars.

BMW i3 50 xDRIVE

Key facts

  • Price: £53,425
  • Battery: 108.7kWh
  • Power: 469hp
  • 0-62mph: 4.7 secs
  • Top speed: 124mph
  • Range: 566 miles
  • CO2: 0g/km
  • Out: Now

Leave a Comment