Doc who helped convict Letby with vital evidence was BANNED from treating patients during trial – but jury never told

A SENIOR doctor who gave vital evidence in baby killer Lucy Letby’s trial was banned — but the jury was not told.

Prof Peter Hindmarsh was removed from clinical practice after it was ruled he appeared to pose a “risk” to children and young people.

Professor Peter Hindmarsh smiling in a suit and tie.
Insulin expert Prof Peter Hindmarsh gave pivotal evidence at Lucy Letby’s trial despite being barred from clinical practice before it began Source: Murray Sanders
Headshot of child serial killer Lucy Letby.
Lucy Letby is serving 15 whole-life sentences at HMP Bronzefield Source: PA

He was removed by University College London Hospitals seven months before the case even began.

An independent tribunal ruled he could continue working under supervision, but at this point a UCLH medical director had already barred him.

While Letby was on trial for murdering seven babies, prosecutor Nick Johnson KC introduced children’s hormone specialist Prof Hindmarsh as “the pre-eminent expert” on insulin.

He helped convince jurors that Letby had injected insulin into intravenous fluid bags to poison two babies.

Still from body-worn camera footage showing Lucy Letby during her arrest, with a blurred officer visible behind her.
Letby, 36, was convicted in 2023 and 2024 of the murder of seven babies Source: Cheshire Constabulary/PA Wire
Neonatal nurse Lucy Letby in blue scrubs holds up a small, floral infant bodysuit.
The deaths occurred at the Countess of Chester Hospital between 2015 and 2016 Source: SWNS:South West News Service

There was no direct or forensic evidence anyone had done so.

Her solicitor Mark McDonald called his ­evidence “pivotal”.

He said the insulin claims were “the cornerstone” of the prosecution’s case.

He said: “It shaped the jury’s perception of Lucy.

“It provided the lens through which they were invited to view every other ­allegation.”

The CPS said it had met its “disclosure obligations”.

Prof Hindmarsh’s representative declined to comment.

Former neonatal nurse Letby, 36, is currently serving 15 whole-life sentences for the murder of seven babies and trying to murder seven others at Countess of Chester Hospital.

Lucy Letby at Hereford Police Station.
Letby continues to claim her innocence
Lucy Letby court case
The former nurse has twice had appeals rejected Source: PA

Letby, of Hereford, maintains her innocence but has lost two bids to challenge her convictions.

An ex-fellow inmate told The Sun Letby is a movie buff who enjoys trading DVDs with her fellow prisoners, and even has her own plush ensuite bathroom inside her HMP Bronzefield cell.

The source said rumours of her acting like the Queen Bee due to the level of privileges she’s afforded are not quite true and she’s actually very “quiet” and keeps to herself – with officers guarding her.

“She has to stay on her wing, and be with staff all the time,” they said.

“Everyone knows who she is in there.”

Locked up at the UK’s largest women’s prison, it was also revealed the killer was allowed to binge on chocolate and watch reality shows after the death of her boyfriend.

The 36-year-old was dating consultant Mark Deakin, 53, who worked with her at the Countess of Chester Hospital in 2016 at the time of her arrest.

Letby called him her “best friend” and “love” in hand-written notes found at her home, and the pair swapped more than 1,300 Facebook messages over three months in 2016.

The dad of two applied for anonymity and was referred to as Doctor A during the case.

But he was named after an order protecting his identity was lifted earlier this month at the Appeal Court.

The doctor was later sacked from his work at a Liverpool hospital over messages between him and Letby.

He was found slumped in his car at a retail park the day after his dismissal and died nine days later.

This comes after a doctor who originally accused the former nurse of murder called for a retrial as he is uncertain of her guilt.

Dr John Gibbs also fears no crime was actually committed — despite the nurse being convicted at two trials.

Retired paediatrician Dr Gibbs says a retrial could be “the most appropriate thing for everyone”.

He concedes: “If it is the case that Lucy Letby is behind bars for crimes she had not committed, then that’s clearly appalling.”

Dr Gibbs, one of three consultants whose evidence helped convict her, told The Sun: “If it wasn’t Letby, do I think someone else was harming them? No, I don’t.”

Sun documentary Lucy Letby: Scapegoat?, available on My5, raised ­serious questions over the original investigation.

Leave a Comment