Cheating husband claimed wife died after freak laundry accident — now chilling Google searches have led to murder charge

A HUSBAND who claimed his wife was involved in a bizarre basement laundry mishap has been charged over her death after cops uncovered chilling Google searches and evidence of an alleged affair.

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was arrested on November 17, more than two years after his wife Erica, 40, was injured at their home in Wisconsin.

NINTCHDBPICT001124190646
Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was taken into custody on Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide over the death of his wife Source: Wisconsin Department of Corrections
NINTCHDBPICT001124190723
Benjamin and Erica Carpenter had two sons together, according to local outlet TMJ4. Source: GoFundMe

Carpenter initially told police his wife of 17 years had suddenly collapsed while they were doing laundry in their basement on October 13, 2024.

He claimed she hit her head on the carpeted floor and that he tried to carry her upstairs to get help.

But he said he slipped, sending them both tumbling down the stairs, where Erica struck her head against a cinder block wall.

Emergency responders arrived to find Carpenter performing CPR on his wife, whose face was described as “very blue,” according to the criminal complaint.

Erica was rushed to hospital but died at 5.14am the following morning.

But following a lengthy investigation into Erica’s death, police have now arrested Carpenter, with a 17-page criminal complaint revealing disturbing evidence uncovered by detectives.

Prosecutors allege Carpenter searched “can I crush pills and take them in water” on the same day his wife suffered her fatal injuries.

Text messages also showed Erica had confronted her husband weeks before her death over a mysterious powdery substance she claimed to have found in her drinking water.

NINTCHDBPICT001124190721
Benjamin Carpenter seen with his wife Erica who died two years ago after suffering serious injuries at their home Source: GoFundMe
NINTCHDBPICT001124190722
Carpenter appeared before Milwaukee County Intake Court this week after being charged Source: Milwaukee County Intake Court

An autopsy revealed blunt-force injuries to her neck and signs that raised concerns she may have died from asphyxia.

Investigators also discovered the powerful painkiller hydrocodone in her system, despite Erica having no prescription for the drug.

The medical examiner could not rule out the medication as a possible contributor to her death, which was officially classified as undetermined.

As detectives investigated, they uncovered a series of disturbing messages between the couple in the weeks leading up to the tragedy.

On September 18, Erica demanded to know what her husband had been putting in her drinking water, writing, “There’s been powdery s*** in it at least twice now.”

Carpenter reportedly insisted he had added Liquid I.V., a powdered hydration supplement, to water intended for himself.

The following day, he allegedly Googled the phrase “Watching someone you love die,” investigators claimed.

And on the night Erica collapsed, his internet history allegedly showed the search about crushing pills and putting them in water.

Detectives also discovered deleted text messages on his phones, despite Carpenter previously insisting he had not wiped his device.

Meanwhile, investigators learned that Carpenter had allegedly been having an affair with another woman in the months before his wife’s death.

A witness told police the woman believed Carpenter was planning to leave Erica and had promised to ask for a divorce the weekend she ended up dead.

Just days after Erica’s death, Carpenter allegedly spent the night at the woman’s home and discussed introducing her to his son.

Around a month later, surveillance footage from a pub-crawl fundraiser held in Erica’s memory reportedly showed Carpenter and the woman acting like a couple, leaving other attendees upset.

Police also learned Carpenter had received approximately $220,000 to $230,000 from one of Erica’s life insurance policies, while another joint policy worth $350,000 remained unpaid.

In October 2025, the couple’s son, whose age is unknown, told detectives he had heard a scream followed by a loud thud on the night his mother was fatally injured.

He also claimed his father removed photographs of Erica from their home around four weeks after her death, with the other woman moving in months later.

In a further disturbing development, the same woman, identified in court documents only as A.M.V., allegedly accused Carpenter of strangling her during a separate incident in May 2025.

According to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Carpenter later pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge in a case involving the woman, and subsequently pleaded guilty in another case involving a violation of a no-contact order.

It is not known whether or not he was jailed and The U.S. Sun has reached out to the court for clarification.

Erica’s devastated parents said they were blindsided by the murder charge after their daughter’s death.

Her father Michael Clarenbach told local outlet CBS 58, “It seemed like Ben had a dark side that we didn’t know about.”

Her mother Debby also told TMJ4, “Just utter shock,” adding: “My body has just completely shut down like it did when we learned she died.”

Carpenter appeared in court on November 18, when his bond was set at $500,000.

He is due back in court in December and faces life in prison if convicted of first-degree intentional homicide.

Any individuals with information related to the death of Erica Carpenter are asked to contact the West Allis Police Department at 414-302-8000.

Leave a Comment