The troubling ‘curse’ hanging over Maya Jama’s latest project – but she has the ultimate weapon to beat it

WITH 325million subscribers across 190 countries, Netflix has the power to take Maya Jama’s career stratospheric.

This week the Bristol-born host left ITV behind for a seven-figure golden handcuffs deal with the streamer.

NINTCHDBPICT001122575123
Maya Jama has signed a seven-figure deal with Netflix Source: ITV
Celebrity Bear Hunt
After quitting This Morning, Holly Willoughby hosted ‘Celebrity Bear Hunt’ with Bear Grylls Source: PA

But away from the fanfare there’s a more worrying whisper – what if the move curbs her career altogether?

Right now it feels outlandish, nay, impossible.

But Maya wouldn’t be the first British face to be lured by the glossy global brand only to see their efforts bomb.

Just ask Holly Willoughby. Or Amanda Holden. Or even Ricky Gervais.

A source said: “For every Bridgerton, Adolescence and Stranger Things, there’s at least ten formats that failed to catch fire.

“Right now, everything Maya touches turns to gold but those handcuffs could quickly start to feel like shackles if the curse of Netflix lives on.”

Announcing the deal last Monday, Netflix’s vice president of UK content Anne Mensah – rightly – extolled Maya’s “infectious energy” and “ability to captivate audiences”.

She, for one, seems convinced the streamer is on to a winner in signing up the ex-Love Island host to front their new dating show Will You Marry Me?

Celebrity Bear Hunt Launches on Netflix
Holly said hosting ‘Celebrity Bear Hunt’ was out of her comfort zone Source: Getty
Amanda Holden, Paul C Bronson, and other contestants pose outdoors by a pool.
Amanda Holden headed to Netflix to host ‘Cheat: Unfinished Business’ with Paul C Brunson Source: Netflix

But everyone involved will have to hope history does not repeat itself.

Holly Willoughby joined Netflix in February 2025 to co-host much-hyped new adventure format Celebrity Bear Hunt alongside Bear Grylls.

She had been the toast of British TV until she quit This Morning in 2023 amid a plot to kidnap, rape and murder her.

Holly was elated to land her big gig with the streamer, filming in Costa Rica, and there was talk of her cracking America.


She said: “It [Celebrity Bear Hunt] did feel different, there’s no two ways about it.

“Normally I’m in the UK, I’m in a studio, it’s live TV. This was completely out of my comfort zone.

“But I think it’s really good to keep testing yourself and changing things.

“Sometimes it’s good to throw everything up in the air and see where it lands. I really enjoyed it.”

But the series failed to take off globally and did not get a second season — leaving Holly to lick her wounds back home in Blighty.

It was reported that, internally, the show was considered a flop, with one source at the time saying: “The blame is being laid at the decision to use Holly Willoughby as the host.

“Holly is a great presenter, but Americans don’t know her.

NINTCHDBPICT000987853132
Amanda Holden’s Netflix show wasn’t renewed for a second series Source: PA
Ricky Gervais smiling and holding an illustrated chubby orange cat against a white background.
Ricky Gervais swapped stand-up comedy specials for ‘Alley Cats’ on Netflix

“Neither do most Europeans, and you can forget about the lucrative Latin market.”

Amanda Holden is another huge British name who was thrilled to be tapped up by Netflix after years on terrestrial.

In April 2025 she launched dating series Cheat: Unfinished Business alongside Channel 4 dating expert Paul C Brunson.

She called the job a “dream come true” after “always” wanting to host a show about love and relationships.

But Amanda suffered the same fate as Holly, failing to captivate a global audience the way she grips fans at home on ITV’s Britain’s Got Talent.

The Netflix show did not return for a second season.

Even Ricky Gervais could not seem to escape the curse when he broke away from his hit stand-up comedy specials to launched adult animation Alley Cats on the streamer in August.

It followed a gang of foul-mouthed, feral moggies squatting in a derelict London house and featured voice talent including Diane Morgan and David Earl alongside The Office legend.

But in the same way, reviewers panned the six-part show, with a brutally low score of 20 per cent on Rotten Tomatoes.

It did reach the global Top Ten, but there has yet to be news of a second run.

Darts ace Luke Littler is another UK star who suffered an embarrassing bust with a competition show.

Airing last month, Beat Luke Litter challenged players to take on the arrows icon for a £501,000 prize pot — but only 230,000 viewers tuned in.

NINTCHDBPICT001097846370
Diane Morgan was also involved in ‘Alley Cats’ and played a character called Olive Source: PA
Maya Jama attends the Nespresso x Swarovski festive event.
Maya’s first Netflix job will be hosting a live reality series called ‘Will You Marry Me?’ Source: Getty

So why can’t the biggest of our Brit names seem to sustain a Netflix hit?

An industry insider said: “In the UK Amanda and Holly’s names hold real value and both came with major fan bases.

“But neither woman cut through with global audiences so it was down to the format to win over viewers – and Celebrity Bear Hunt and Cheat just didn’t.

“Ricky’s name holds collateral because of the weight of his back catalogue and so Alley Cats fared better on intrigue but there’s question marks over whether that will return.

“It all comes down to the fact that the talent isn’t enough. There has to be a cracking format too.

“Dramas perform well and [telly social experiment] Love Is Blind has delivered astronomically well in the reality sector but there’s very few lifestyle formats that have flourished.”

So does Maya carry enough clout to beat the curse of Netflix?

NINTCHDBPICT001118616746
Competition show ‘Beat Luke Littler’ was a bust for the darts pro Source: PA
NINTCHDBPICT001122575034
Maya Jama has said goodbye to Love Island, after taking over from Laura Whitmore in 2023 Source: Shutterstock

Ironically, it’s the show she has left behind that could be the ultimate weapon in her arsenal.

Maya’s first job will be hosting Will You Marry Me?, which the streamer has revealed is a “live reality series” that spans four weeks.

It will follow one man on a quest to find his future wife, with viewers voting live on which dates happen, who stays in the running, and who gets sent home.

The finale will see him making a live, televised proposal to one woman.

Aside from the end goal being far more elevated than Love Island’s ‘will you be exclusive?’ it sounds achingly similar.

That’s in Netflix – and Maya’s – advantage.

Love Island has a passionate, locked-in audience and the UK version in particular is watched worldwide – most Americans even prefer it to their own, homegrown version.

That puts her one step ahead of the pack, for starters.

A source said: “Netflix bosses have made a smart call kicking off Maya’s stint with a dating show as that’s where she has a ready-made launch pad.”

But the likeness will feel like a stab in the back for ITV, who were the first to take Maya from obscure but trendy series including rap panel show Don’t Hate The Playaz into the mainstream.

When she became host of Love Island in 2023, it sealed her place among the UK showbiz elite and boosted her capital tenfold.

She went from brand deals with Freya, Pretty Little Thing and JD Sports to Dolce & Gabbana and the cover of Vogue.

Her screen career was transformed when this year she landed the role of a gangster’s moll in The Gentlemen, and won new fans with The Celebrity Traitors.

But among all that, the one thing Maya has not lost is the rare alchemy of down-the-pub relatability and supermodel looks.

A source said: “Maya is like lightning in a bottle. She is unlike anyone else on telly.

“When she took over from Laura Whitmore on Love Island in 2023 she boosted viewers in the 16 to 24 age group immeasurably and that is why Netflix wants her, too.”

The potent mix could mean she bucks the trend of British names who have flopped on ’Fix.

But time will tell whether she can add surviving the curse of Netflix to her many wins.

Leave a Comment