Pixel 11 Pro XL launch: Why I won’t ditch my 10 Pro XL — Explained
The Pixel 11 series is here! And with it comes a successor to my favourite phone of 2025.
Last year’s Pixel 10 Pro XL surpassed all my expectations. It’s a superb handset with basically no weaknesses. A year later, it’s holding up extremely well, as evidenced by the fact that it’s still number one in our in-depth best phones guide.
However, there’s a new top-of-the-line Google flagship in town, and it has its sights set on the top spot. However, the Pixel 11 Pro XL isn’t as clear-cut an upgrade as you might think. I see no reason to upgrade from my 10 Pro XL, and I doubt you will, either.
Near-identical hardware…
I’ve been poring over the Pixel 11 Pro XL and 10 Pro XL spec sheets, and I really can’t understand what all the fuss is about.
The new phone is essentially the same as last year: a huge, 6.8-inch slab of glass and metal with an imposing yet durable build and signature rear camera bar.
While the 50Mp wide and 48Mp 5x telephoto are new, larger sensors, I don’t expect them to be a significant improvement on what’s already the best point-and-shoot phone camera around. Moving from 100x to 120x AI-assisted zoom merely sounds like another gimmick.

Anyron Copeman / Foundry
Similarly, Google’s new Tensor G6 chip is a nice upgrade, but I had no issues with performance on the 10 Pro XL. Will a new MediaTek modem really make much of a difference?
Sure, there are new colours, but is that really a reason to upgrade your phone? I think not.
…with one design blemish
I was cautiously optimistic about the Pixel 11’s much-rumoured ‘Pixel Glow’, but it’s been a real letdown.
Ignoring the underwhelming ‘HiLight’ name, it’s basically just a rebranded LED notification light that doubles as a Gemini progress tracker. Was it really worth ditching the inbuilt temperature sensor for this?!

What’s more, Google has tweaked the design of the camera bar to make it even more prominent than the flash on last year’s model. Where it used to blend into the back of the phone, you now can’t ignore it.
I’ve had enough experience with Nothing phones to know that fancy lights on the back of a phone aren’t for me. Sticking with the 10 Pro XL means I can avoid the hassle while also getting a cleaner design.
A baffling battery approach
One of the most disappointing aspects of the Pixel 11 Pro XL is its battery upgrades, or lack thereof.
Google rates its capacity as 5115mAh, which is actually a slight downgrade on the 5200mAh cell in the Pixel 10 Pro XL.
I don’t expect noticeably inferior battery life, but it feels like a massive missed opportunity for Google. Even Samsung is now incorporating silicon-carbon (Si-C) batteries into its phones, which open up the possibility of much higher capacities. Why hasn’t Google followed suit?

Luke Baker
A comfortable full day of usage is likely once again, but I think ultra-premium flagships like the Pixel 11 Pro XL should be setting their sights much higher.
There are also no changes on the charging side, with 45W and 25W PixelSnap-enabled wireless. But where are the 60W speeds to match the Galaxy S26 Ultra? I’d take that over built-in Qi2 magnets any day.
A price to make you think twice
In a normal year, the Pixel 11 Pro XL’s lack of meaningful upgrades would mean it escapes a price rise. But this isn’t a normal year.
At launch, it starts (yes, starts!) at £1,279/$1,299 – that’s an £80/$100 increase compared to last year.

Sure, the base storage has been bumped from 128GB to 256GB, but it makes the 11 Pro XL one of the most expensive phones you can buy. Does RAMageddon make this inevitable? While undoubtedly a major factor, I believe Google could’ve absorbed more of the costs of such a meagre upgrade.
Even if you don’t already own the 10 Pro XL, the launch of its successor is likely to send prices tumbling. And with six more years of OS and security updates, you’re not missing out on any of Android’s new features for a long time to come.
Conclusion: a very skippable phone
It probably shouldn’t come as a surprise, but the Pixel 11 Pro XL isn’t a very exciting upgrade. The improvements are meagre at best, while HiLight, the new headline feature is a big disappointment on paper and sacrifices the temperature sensor in the process.
With a notable price rise to boot, the 11 Pro XL has an uphill task to convince people that it’s worth the upgrade. Unless it massively surpasses expectations in real-world testing, I’ll happily stick with my still-excellent Pixel 10 Pro XL, thank you very much.