trumps iran campaign
|

Trump’s Iran campaign echoes the post-9/11 ‘forever wars’

WASHINGTON, USA – When Donald Trump campaigned for a second term in the White House, he promised to be a “president of peace” who would stop foreign wars, not start them.

Now, a quarter-century after the September 11, 2001, attacks that triggered America’s global “war on terror,” he is entangled in an unpopular conflict of his own making that analysts say risks becoming his version of a “forever war.”

With the 9/11 anniversary at hand, Trump’s war against Iran is drawing comparisons in foreign policy circles to the long, divisive conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq that preceded it.

It is also prompting questions about whether the US has again failed to learn the lessons of past conflicts or prepare a clear exit strategy.

“Trump has broken an important post-Iraq and Afghanistan constraint in Washington against launching another major, open-ended war in the Middle East,” said Sina Toossi of the Center for International Policy, a Washington think tank. “That could leave his successor inheriting … an entrenched US-Iran confrontation.”

Administration officials have said the war against Iran is nothing like the protracted post-9/11 engagements.
During the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan, the US removed hostile governments, committed thousands of ground troops who took and held territory, suffered and inflicted much higher casualties and struggled to instill Western-style governance.

This time, the US is relying mainly on air and naval power, operations that have damaged Iran militarily and economically but have not defeated it or spurred Iranians to overthrow their rulers as Trump initially urged.

But after six months of war, the United States is mired in a battle of attrition punctuated by bursts of hostilities – exemplified by this week’s exchange of attacks on oil tankers – while Trump tries to tighten the economic noose around Tehran.

Analysts warn it is likely to drag on well past the US midterm elections in November, when voters’ opposition to the war could threaten Trump’s Republican Party’s chances of keeping control of Congress.

And, much like those earlier conflicts, there is no obvious exit even as the economic costs weigh on US consumers.

Tehran’s disruption of oil shipments through the Strait of Hormuz has pushed US gasoline prices higher. The war has weakened Trump’s approval ratings and undermined Washington’s international standing, which was also one of the repercussions from the Iraq and Afghan wars.

White House spokeswoman Anna Kelly said Trump alone had “possessed the courage” to confront Iran over its nuclear program, that he had achieved all of his objectives and Iran’s economy was being crippled by stepped-up sanctions and a US maritime blockade.

She did not respond directly to Reuters’ questions on how the Iran conflict fits into America’s legacy of post-9/11 wars.

Lessons ignored?

Analysts say Trump has failed to heed the central lessons of the post-9/11 era, which began after al Qaeda militants crashed planes into New York’s World Trade Center and the Pentagon outside Washington, killing nearly 3,000 people.

Those include the steep political downsides of long wars and the dangers posed by an entrenched foe fighting for its survival.

The attacks led to decades of conflict, starting with the invasion of Afghanistan, where al Qaeda leaders were sheltering, and followed by the 2003 invasion of Iraq, based on what turned out to be faulty intelligence that it was developing weapons of mass destruction.

The twin wars undertaken by President George W. Bush overstretched the US military and destabilized the Middle East.

The resulting US public backlash helped fuel Trump’s rise a decade ago, and he won a second term in 2024 vowing to avoid military adventurism and focus on Americans’ economic concerns.

But similar to how the Bush administration underestimated the insurgencies the US would face in Iraq and Afghanistan, Trump and his aides have miscalculated Iran’s resiliency and ability to throttle a fifth of the world’s energy shipments, analysts say.

Notably, Trump’s “Operation Epic Fury” launched alongside Israel on February 28 was not precipitated by a 9/11-type national trauma but was deemed by critics to be a war of choice.

Experts have disputed Trump’s claims that Tehran’s nuclear program posed an imminent threat to the US.

Iran may be taking a page from Afghanistan’s Taliban, who returned to power five years ago after a chaotic US withdrawal, that a determined foe can outlast Washington’s superior firepower while domestic pressure erodes its resolve.

The Iran conflict has also illustrated the cost of going to war with few allies on board.

Bush secured significant international support before launching his Iraq and Afghan campaigns, though that backing waned over time.

By contrast, Trump attacked Iran with little prior consultation or explanation and has found European and Asian leaders mostly resistant to his demands for assistance.

Relations with Trump had already been strained by his threat to seize Greenland, his questioning of NATO’s utility, his reduction of weapons supplies to Ukraine and his sweeping tariffs on trade partners.

High cost for allies

The conflict has also mirrored the Iraq invasion in terms of a regional spillover that seemed to catch Washington off-guard, in this case Tehran’s retaliation against US Gulf allies.

With Iran’s neighbors quietly seeking to de-escalate a conflict they never wanted, a Gulf official lamented that the administration might be making some of the same errors of the post-9/11 wars.

“What was the (US) strategy here?” asked the official, speaking on condition of anonymity.

Saudi analyst Aziz Alghashian described “a sense of limitation and helplessness in the Gulf about the wars that are taking place due to the whims of the United States.”

The war’s shockwaves expanded on Thursday, September 10, with Yemeni government military sources saying Iran-aligned Houthis had seized control of the Yemeni port city of Mocha and gained further leverage over an important Red Sea oil-shipping route.

While the Iraq and Afghan wars ended as unpopular conflicts, both started with solid support at home.

Trump’s war enjoyed no such honeymoon in public opinion.

Most Americans were against it from the outset, and he has even drawn criticism from prominent figures associated with his “America First” movement.

Trump had initially expected to replicate his quick win from a January 3 raid that captured Venezuelan leader Nicolas Maduro.

But the Iran campaign instead has hardened into an uneasy stalemate that has not achieved most of Trump’s shifting objectives, including shutting down its nuclear program, and has depleted the Pentagon’s missile stockpiles.

Still, Trump is not without defenders.
Mark Dubowitz, head of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a Washington think tank that takes a hard line against Iran’s rulers, denied Trump had plunged the US into an endless war and insisted he had scored successes that would eventually bring victory.

“It’s been a 47-year war waged by the Islamic Republic against America,” Dubowitz said. “And now we’ve struck back.” – Rappler.com

Similar Posts

  • | |

    Beyond faith and defense

    The historical partnership between Pakistan and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia stands as one of the most enduring bilateral relationships in the contemporary Muslim world. This history is anchored in shared Islamic values and a profound spiritual connection to the holy sanctuaries of Makkah and Medina. This alliance predates the modern era of Saudi oil wealth. The bond was formalized through the landmark Treaty of Friendship in 1951. It established an early blueprint for solidarity, ideological alignment and mutual support during crisis. Over the past seven decades, this connection has expanded from religious affinity into strategic collaboration. The Art of Strategic Neutrality Defense cooperation forms a central pivot of the bilateral relationship. Since the 1960s, the Pakistani military has played an instrumental role in advising, training, and building the infrastructure of the Saudi armed forces. Contingents of Pakistani troops have historically been deployed inside the Kingdom for defensive purposes, notably safeguarding the Holy Mosques during regional upheavals such as Operation Desert Storm. Moreover, thousands of Saudi defense personnel have undergone advanced training in Pakistani military institutions over the decades. However, the military relationship has also required careful navigation.  When conflict erupted in Yemen (2015), Pakistan’s parliament adopted a stance of strict neutrality to avoid inter-state Middle Eastern disputes, particularly while its domestic forces were actively engaged in counter-terrorism campaigns like Operation Zarb-e-Azb. Despite initial friction, Riyadh acknowledged Islamabad’s geopolitical constraints. This mature understanding was demonstrated when former Pakistani Army Chief General Raheel Sharif was appointed to lead the Islamic Military Counter Terrorism Coalition (IMCTC), focusing strictly on combating global extremism rather than taking sides in regional power struggles. Economic Interdependence and Human Capital Beyond defense, economic cooperation has provided crucial stability to Pakistan’s financial landscape. Saudi Arabia has repeatedly acted as a financial cushion. The country delivered multi-billion-dollar bailout packages, balance-of-payment assistance and deferred-payment oil supplies during economic hardship. Historically, this financial dynamic was complemented by administrative leadership. Pakistani economist Anwar Ali served as the Governor of the Saudi Arabian Monetary Agency from 1958 to 1974. He played a pivotal role in organizing the Kingdom’s modern financial infrastructure. Human capital remains another essential driver of this relationship. Over 2.7 million Pakistani expatriates reside and work within Saudi Arabia. Spanning critical sectors such as healthcare, engineering, construction, and information technology, these workers contribute directly to Saudi Arabia’s physical and economic development while generating vital remittance flows that sustain Pakistan’s domestic economy. Furthermore, administrative initiatives like the “Road to Makkah” project and reductions in visa fees have significantly streamlined pilgrimage procedures for millions of Pakistani citizens traveling for Hajj and Umrah. Geo-Economics, Vision 2030, and the Future of CPEC As both nations adjust to global realities, the bilateral partnership is changing into modern geo-economic framework. Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s Vision 2030. The Kingdom aims to diversify its economy away from oil dependency by investing in global supply chains. A key element of this transformation includes multi-billion-dollar investment commitments in Pakistan. Furthermore, a proposed mega-oil refinery at the deep-sea port of Gwadar.   Ultimately, geopolitical challenges occasionally test bilateral diplomatic alignment. However, the strategic, economic and institutional ties between Islamabad and Riyadh continue to adapt. After all, it’s a dynamic future built on mutual survival and shared prosperity.

  • | |

    Lilli Tagger wins first WTA singles title with impressive Prague Open Triumph

      Eighteen-year-old Austrian tennis star Lilli Tagger has achieved a major milestone in her young career by winning her first-ever WTA singles title at the Prague Open. The rising talent delivered an outstanding performance in the final, defeating Ukraine’s Daria Snigur in straight sets, 7-6(3), 6-2, to secure the championship. The victory also earned Tagger a place in Austrian tennis history, as she became the first player from Austria to win the singles title at the Prague Open. Her remarkable achievement marks a significant breakthrough and highlights her growing reputation as one of the sport’s most promising young players. The championship match began with a difficult challenge for Tagger. Daria Snigur started strongly and quickly established a commanding 5-2 lead in the opening set, putting the Austrian teenager under considerable pressure. Despite facing a set point, Tagger remained calm and composed, refusing to let the match slip away. Showing impressive mental strength, she fought back by winning three consecutive games to level the score and force a tiebreak. Once the tiebreak began, Tagger took control with confident shot-making and consistent play, winning it 7-3 to claim the opening set. The momentum from the dramatic comeback carried into the second set, where Tagger displayed complete control over the match. She served exceptionally well, producing nine aces throughout the contest while combining powerful groundstrokes with aggressive baseline play. Her attacking style kept Snigur under constant pressure, allowing Tagger to comfortably win the second set 6-2 and seal the biggest victory of her career. Tagger’s journey to the Prague Open title featured several impressive performances against strong opponents. In the semifinals, she overcame Czech favorite Barbora Krejcikova in a hard-fought three-set match, demonstrating resilience, determination, and the ability to perform under pressure. Throughout the tournament, Tagger showcased an aggressive playing style built around powerful groundstrokes, confident serving, and relentless attacking tennis. Her performances reflected the guidance of her coach, former French Open champion Francesca Schiavone, whose experience has played an important role in the young Austrian’s development. Following her victory, Tagger addressed the crowd during the trophy presentation and expressed her appreciation for the support she received throughout the tournament. She described the week as unforgettable and thanked the fans for creating an incredible atmosphere that motivated all the players during the competition. The Austrian teenager also shared an emotional message for her family, who were present to witness her historic triumph. She explained that her parents usually watch her matches from home but had traveled to support her in Prague. Tagger credited them for their constant encouragement and sacrifices, saying that her achievements would not have been possible without their unwavering support. Winning the Prague Open has also had a significant impact on Tagger’s world ranking. Following her breakthrough success, she is expected to climb nearly 30 places in the WTA rankings, allowing her to enter the world’s top 50 for the first time in her career. The achievement represents another major milestone and reflects her rapid progress on the professional tennis circuit. At just 18 years of age, Lilli Tagger has already demonstrated the qualities of a future star. Her composure under pressure, powerful playing style, and determination throughout the Prague Open suggest she has the potential to compete regularly at the highest level. As she continues her professional journey, tennis fans around the world will be watching closely to see what the talented Austrian can accomplish next.

  • | |

    Iran says US violated Islamabad MoU

    Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi has accused the United States of violating the Islamabad Memorandum of Understanding, saying the agreement called for an end to the war, rather than a 60-day ceasefire that would require an extension. In an interview with ISNA, Araghchi said the memorandum declared an end to hostilities and blamed Washington for the subsequent resumption of fighting. He clarified that the 60-day period mentioned in the agreement referred to negotiations aimed at reaching a final settlement, not a temporary ceasefire. Araghchi said Qatar and Pakistan, which acted as mediators, continue to exchange messages with Tehran and remain in contact with Iranian officials. However, he stressed that Iran has not yet decided to resume negotiations with Washington. On the Strait of Hormuz, Araghchi said Iran and Oman were continuing discussions on its management. He described the issue as separate from the Islamabad MoU and said Iran was working on a temporary route that could eventually become permanent. Meanwhile, Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister for Legal and International Affairs Kazem Gharibabadi rejected US President Donald Trump’s claims about the Strait of Hormuz. Writing on X, Gharibabadi said Iran would not surrender control of the strategic waterway because of threats, military displays or political statements. He stressed that Iran does not fear US pressure and retains authority over the Strait.

  • |

    Use of Pellet guns in Delhi protests revive Kashmi…

    Cockroach Janta Party protests in Delhi has sparked a nationwide debate while reopening old wounds in occupied Kashmir, where the weapon has been used extensively against peaceful protesters for years. The incidents in the capital have drawn attention to the long-standing suffering of Kashmiris, who have borne the brunt of pellet gun injuries, with many left blinded or permanently disabled. The Delhi protests, led by students demanding education reforms, ended successfully with the resignation of Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan. However, the use of pellet guns against demonstrators has overshadowed the victory, raising concerns about the government’s approach to handling dissent. Critics have questioned why such force was used against peaceful protesters in the capital, drawing parallels to the devastation caused in occupied Jammu and Kashmir. Rahul Gandhi, a prominent opposition leader, expressed deep sorrow over the use of pellet guns, highlighting the tragic toll they have taken in Kashmir. Human rights organizations have repeatedly condemned pellet guns as a “cruel weapon” that causes disproportionate harm, and the international community has raised concerns about their use in the region. The Delhi incident has reignited calls for a ban on pellet guns, with activists urging the Indian government to adopt less lethal methods of crowd control. The controversy has also drawn attention to the broader issue of human rights violations in occupied Kashmir, where the use of such weapons has been a persistent concern. Hospital records from the region highlight the devastating impact of pellet gun injuries, with countless young Kashmiris left with permanent disabilities. The use of pellet guns in Delhi has not only sparked outrage but has also brought the Kashmir issue back to the forefront of national and international discourse. Human rights groups have called for a thorough investigation into the incidents and for the government to ensure that such weapons are no longer used against citizens exercising their fundamental rights. As the debate continues, the victims of pellet gun injuries in both Delhi and Kashmir await justice and accountability. The incident serves as a reminder of the urgent need for reforms in crowd control measures and the importance of protecting the rights of all citizens. The international community continues to monitor the situation closely, urging India to uphold its human rights obligations. The time for change is now. The government must act decisively to ensure that the rights of all citizens are protected and that such incidents are never repeated. The victims of pellet gun injuries, both in Delhi and Kashmir, deserve justice, and the government must take concrete steps to ensure that their voices are heard and their grievances addressed. The fight for justice continues, and the nation must stand united in its commitment to upholding the rights and dignity of all citizens. The use of pellet guns in Delhi has once again exposed the harsh realities of India’s approach to law and order, and the need for meaningful reform has never been more urgent.

  • | | |

    Iran warns Ukraine of response after reported Casp…

    Tensions between Iran and Ukraine have increased after Tehran accused Kyiv of carrying out an attack on a vessel in the Caspian Sea and warned that the incident would not go unanswered. According to Iranian state media reports, Iran’s Parliament Deputy Speaker Ali Nikzad said the country would respond to what he described as an irresponsible action by Ukraine. He stated that Iran reserves the right to defend its territorial sovereignty and considers any attack on its territory or interests a matter requiring a response. The controversy emerged after Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy reportedly claimed that Ukrainian forces had targeted a Russian military vessel and also struck an Iranian vessel in the Caspian Sea. Iran’s Foreign Ministry later confirmed that an Iranian ship had been affected by the incident. Following the report, Iran summoned Ukraine’s chargé d’affaires and lodged a formal protest, describing the action as hostile and unacceptable. Tehran said the incident could increase regional tensions and accused Ukraine of violating international principles. Iran’s Foreign Ministry stated that the country would take measures to protect its security and interests within the framework of international law. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi also condemned the reported attack and called on the United Nations, the European Union, and the international community to take action. During a phone conversation with EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas, Araghchi urged international bodies to hold those responsible for the incident accountable. The reported confrontation has added another layer of complexity to ongoing international tensions, with both sides facing calls to clarify the circumstances surrounding the incident.

  • | |

    Over 60,000 Gaza children lose parents amid ongoing war

    More than 60,000 children in Gaza have lost at least one parent since the conflict began in October 2023, according to figures released by the Palestinian health ministry on Wednesday. The ministry reported that 60,737 children had either been orphaned or left with only one surviving parent. Of these, 52,095 children lost their fathers, while 5,929 lost their mothers. Another 2,713 children lost both parents during the conflict. The figures highlight the devastating impact of prolonged violence on children across the Gaza Strip. The ministry also reported that thousands of families had been completely erased from Gaza’s civil registry. According to its figures, 2,276 families comprising 8,858 people have been wiped out during the conflict. The overall death toll in Gaza has also exceeded 73,000 since the start of the war, the ministry said. A ceasefire reached in October has failed to end all violence in the territory. Palestinian authorities say Israeli forces have continued carrying out strikes, with more than 1,100 people reportedly killed since the truce began. The latest figures have renewed concerns over the humanitarian consequences of the conflict. Thousands of children have been left without one or both parents, while many families have lost multiple members. The United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry has also documented serious violations involving Palestinian children. In a report released in June, the commission said Israeli authorities and security forces had deliberately targeted Palestinian children. It alleged that violations amounted to genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes in Gaza, as well as war crimes in the occupied West Bank. The commission examined alleged violations against Palestinian children since the conflict began on October 7, 2023. It found that children accounted for around 30 per cent of those killed in the Gaza war. In an earlier report released in September, the commission concluded that Israel had committed genocide in Gaza and said senior Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, had contributed to incitement. Israel has rejected the accusations, describing them as unfounded and deeply offensive. The latest Palestinian figures underline the long-term consequences of the conflict for Gaza’s youngest population. Beyond the immediate loss of life, thousands of children are now facing life without parents, while entire families have disappeared from official records.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *