islamabad8217s carriage ride

Islamabad’s carriage ride

I have lived long enough, and travelled enough, to know that a buggy ride is royal. This week, a buggy ride was held in Islamabad and that ride has become a centre of all drawing room discussions.

Let me start with what I have seen with my own eyes, many times over, on the streets of London. I walk those streets often, and I see mounted police there almost every week. Big handsome horses, officers sitting tall in the saddle, moving through crowds at football matches, at protests, at royal parades. But here is the thing I want you to notice. Those horses are working. The officer on that horse is doing a job. He is controlling a crowd, keeping an eye on trouble, making sure that thousands of people move safely through narrow streets. Nobody in London looks at a mounted police officer and thinks of him as a king. They think of him as a policeman who happens to have four legs helping him do his job better than two legs could.

Then there is the other side of the horse story in London, the royal family. Once or twice a year, you will see the King or a prince ride out in a grand carriage, gold trim, footmen in uniform, the whole show. And it is exactly that, a show. It is theatre, built on centuries of tradition, and everybody watching knows exactly what it is. Royalty is a different breed. Nobody expects the King to explain why he has running water or why the country’s roads have potholes. He was born into that role, and the carriage is part of a costume that comes with the job. People do not confuse that costume with the daily business of government.

Now bring me back home, to Islamabad, on our own Independence Day. I watched the video like everybody else did. The chairman of the Capital Development Authority and the inspector general riding in a horse drawn carriage, arriving grandly at the ceremony. And I felt they were not kings. This was not centuries of tradition. This was a serving civil servant and a serving police officer, the very same officers who are supposed to answer to the public every single day, arriving like they were opening a coronation.

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi explains the story behind that ride. He said what happened was not appropriate, but insisted it was not the fault of the IG or the chief commissioner. He says that he and the chief guest were delayed because of the president’s meeting with the prime minister, and that the crowd had been waiting since five in the evening. Around six, when it was clear they would be late, he says he told the officers to start the programme so the public would not have to wait any longer. The buggy, he said, had been arranged for the chief guest, and the officers were only supposed to ride with him, but due to unavoidable circumstances they ended up using it alone. He added that both officers had initially resisted starting the program without him, and that he personally instructed them to proceed, for the convenience of the public.

I keep thinking about that journalist who asked a simple, honest question. Have you ever seen the police commissioner of London ride around in a royal buggy? The answer, of course, is no. Because he knows his job is to serve, not to be served. That is the whole difference in one sentence.

A horse carriage is a fine thing, in the right hands, for the right reason. In London, it either works, or it performs. In Islamabad this week, it did neither. It simply left a bad taste in everybody’s mouth.

Similar Posts

  • Man: The Cruelest Animal?

    “Remember your humanity, and forget the rest”— Bertrand Russell and Albert Einstein, The Russell–Einstein Manifesto, 1955   On the morning of August 6, 1945, Hiroshima was a living city. Children were preparing for school, workers were beginning another day, meals were being eaten, conversations remained unfinished and countless ordinary plans had been made for an evening many would never see. At 8:15 am, a single atomic bomb changed all that. In seconds, a city became an inferno and human ingenuity demonstrated what it was capable of when divorced from human conscience. Three days later, Nagasaki suffered the same fate.   More than eight decades have passed, yet the mind still struggles to comprehend what happened. Not merely the scale of destruction, but the extraordinary contradiction it represented. Human beings had acquired sufficient knowledge of physics to split the atom but apparently insufficient wisdom to prevent that knowledge from being used to incinerate fellow human beings. This raises an uncomfortable question: is man the cruellest animal?   Animals kill. Nature is certainly not a sentimental place. Predators hunt for food, animals fight over territory, mates and dominance, and some species occasionally kill for reasons other than immediate survival. Yet no creature other than Homo sapiens has transformed killing into an organised industry. No animal constructs factories to manufacture weapons capable of destroying entire cities. None develops elaborate ideologies to justify mass slaughter, calculates acceptable casualties or decorates members of its species for becoming exceptionally efficient at killing others. Only the supposedly “wise man” has achieved such sophistication.   The atomic bombings cannot, of course, be examined outside the horrors of the Second World War. Nazi Germany had perpetrated the holocaust. Imperial Japan had committed horrific atrocities across Asia. Cities had already been devastated by conventional and incendiary bombing. Millions of soldiers and civilians were dead. Defenders of the decision to use atomic weapons maintain that the bombs accelerated Japan’s surrender and avoided an invasion that could have caused enormous casualties on both sides. Critics have long questioned whether alternatives existed and whether the second bombing, in particular, was necessary.   Historians may continue debating these questions. Humanity must confront another. At what point does military necessity cease to provide moral shelter for the deliberate infliction of unimaginable suffering upon civilians? Perhaps the most disturbing legacy of Hiroshima and Nagasaki is not simply that atomic bombs were used. It is that humanity had reached a stage where the destruction of enormous number of ordinary people could be incorporated into strategic calculation. Human beings had become numbers. Therein lies the first requirement of organised cruelty: dehumanisation.   Before we can inflict unbearable suffering upon others, we must somehow stop seeing them as ourselves. They become the enemy, an alien race, religion, nationality, sect or ideology. Children become unfortunate collateral damage. Dead bodies become casualty figures. Destroyed neighbourhoods become strategic targets. Language performs the anaesthesia that conscience might otherwise refuse. Once human beings are converted into categories, almost anything becomes possible.   History is littered with evidence. Colonial atrocities required subject populations to be regarded as inferior. Ethnic cleansing requires neighbours to become enemies. Genocide requires individual faces to disappear behind collective labels. Modern warfare similarly becomes easier to tolerate when suffering is viewed through satellite images rather than through the eyes of a mother holding her dead child. Perhaps that explains one of the strangest contradictions of our species. The same human hand that tenderly caresses a newborn can press the button that launches a missile towards somebody else’s newborn.   The same species that produces Mozart and Rumi, builds hospitals, writes poetry, explores distant planets and risks lives rescuing strangers from disasters also constructs concentration camps, torture chambers, chemical weapons and nuclear warheads. How can such tenderness and such barbarity inhabit the same creature?   We proudly call ourselves civilised. Yet civilisation cannot merely mean technological advancement. If anything, technology without corresponding moral advancement makes human beings more dangerous, not less. A primitive weapon can kill one person. Human intelligence created weapons capable of killing millions. Science gives us power. It does not necessarily give us wisdom. That distinction should haunt us.   The scientists who unlocked the secrets of the atom demonstrated one of humanity’s greatest intellectual achievements. But when knowledge becomes separated from ethics, achievement can become catastrophe. Ten years after Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Bertrand Russell and Albert Einstein, together with other distinguished scientists, issued their famous manifesto warning humanity about nuclear war. Their appeal was breathtakingly simple: “Remember your humanity, and forget the rest.”   What an extraordinary plea to have to make to human beings. Remember that the person across the border is human. Remember that the child beneath the rubble is human. Remember that the mother screaming outside a hospital is human. Remember that beneath uniforms, flags, religions, ethnicities and nationalities beats essentially the same vulnerable human heart.   Yet eighty-one years after Hiroshima, humanity still maintains nuclear arsenals capable of inflicting destruction on a scale those who witnessed 1945 could scarcely have imagined. Governments speak comfortably of deterrence, strategic balance, tactical nuclear weapons and acceptable responses. Behind this sophisticated vocabulary lies an elementary reality: we have created instruments capable of annihilating ourselves and entrusted their possible use to human beings subject to anger, ambition, miscalculation and fear. What could be more absurd?   Perhaps the problem lies in our understanding of civilisation itself. We measure progress through economic growth, scientific discovery, technological innovation and military capability. We celebrate artificial intelligence, space exploration and machines capable of performing tasks once thought impossible but are we becoming better human beings? Can technological advancement truly be called progress if our moral consciousness remains primitive?   The jungle may be brutal, but it possesses no Hiroshima, no Nagasaki, no Bosnia, no Rwanda and no Gaza. Animals do not convene conferences to plan genocide. They do not manufacture propaganda to persuade millions to hate strangers. They do not teach generations to inherit ancient hostilities. Above all, they have never developed

  • Fundamental Right No. 12: Protection Against Retro…

    By Muhammad Imran, Staff Member, SAHSOL-LUMS and Asma Rahmat, Final Year Law Student, SLC, Superior University and Muhammad Ameer Hamza, Final Year Law Student, SLC, Superior University Article 12 of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973, enshrines one of the oldest and most celebrated principles of criminal jurisprudence, namely nullum crimen, nulla poena sine lege, which means there can be neither a crime nor a punishment without prior law. This constitutional guarantee embodies the rule of law by prohibiting retrospective criminal legislation and protecting every individual from arbitrary prosecution or punishment. It ensures that a person may be held criminally liable only for conduct that constituted an offence under the law at the time it was committed, and that no punishment more severe than that then prescribed may subsequently be imposed. The first part of Article 12 prohibits the retrospective creation of criminal offences. A person cannot be convicted for an act or omission which was lawful when committed merely because the legislature subsequently criminalises that conduct. The second part prohibits the retrospective enhancement of punishment. Accordingly, where the law prescribes a maximum sentence of six months’ imprisonment or two years’ imprisonment at the time of the offence, neither the judiciary nor the legislature may subsequently impose or authorise a more severe penalty for that completed act. The constitutional guarantee thus preserves legal certainty, protects legitimate expectations, and prevents arbitrary exercises of legislative and executive power. Article 12 is founded upon the universally accepted doctrine of legal certainty, which requires that criminal laws be clear, prospective, and predictable. Individuals must be capable of regulating their conduct according to existing law without fear that future legislation will retrospectively criminalise their past actions or increase their punishment. The principle therefore operates as an indispensable safeguard against governmental arbitrariness and political persecution and constitutes a cornerstone of every constitutional democracy governed by the rule of law. The constitutional philosophy embodied in Article 12 is consistent with internationally recognised human rights norms. Article 11(2) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948, provides that no person shall be held guilty of any penal offence on account of any act or omission that did not constitute a penal offence under national or international law at the time it was committed, nor shall a heavier penalty be imposed than that applicable at the time of the commission of the offence. Likewise, Article 15 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), to which Pakistan is a State Party, reiterates the same prohibition against retrospective criminal liability while recognising only the limited exception relating to offences recognised under the general principles of international law. Comparable constitutional protection is also found in the United States Constitution, where Article I, Sections 9 and 10 expressly prohibit Congress and the States from enacting ex post facto laws. This prohibition has long been regarded as a fundamental limitation upon legislative authority and reflects a universal constitutional commitment to fairness in criminal justice. The superior courts of Pakistan have consistently treated Article 12 as an indispensable constitutional safeguard. In Mian Muhammad Nawaz Sharif v. The State, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that Article 12 embodies the constitutional prohibition against retrospective penal legislation and protects individuals from being subjected to criminal liability or enhanced punishment under laws enacted after the commission of the alleged offence. The Court emphasised that retrospective penal laws offend the rule of law because criminal consequences must always be determined according to the law in force at the relevant time. Similarly, in Benazir Bhutto v. Federation of Pakistan, the Supreme Court underscored that fundamental rights must receive a liberal and purposive interpretation so as to prevent arbitrary governmental action and preserve constitutional liberties. Although that case did not directly concern Article 12, its interpretative philosophy has significantly influenced the constitutional protection afforded to penal safeguards. A significant constitutional question concerns the offence of high treason under Article 6 of the Constitution. High treason, comprising the abrogation, subversion, suspension, or holding in abeyance of the Constitution, represents the gravest constitutional offence. Through the Constitution (Eighteenth Amendment) Act, 2010, Parliament expanded Article 6 to include persons who aid, abet, collaborate with, or validate such unconstitutional acts. Nevertheless, Article 12 continues to apply with full constitutional force. Even in prosecutions for high treason, criminal liability and punishment cannot be imposed retrospectively. Any legislative amendment increasing punishment or enlarging criminal liability can operate only prospectively and cannot constitutionally affect acts committed before its enactment. The historical experience of constitutional development further demonstrates the importance of this principle. Following the restoration of the English monarchy, the remains of Oliver Cromwell were exhumed in 1661 upon the orders of Charles II, symbolically hanged, beheaded, and publicly displayed. Although this episode belonged to a different constitutional era, it illustrates the dangers of political vengeance unconstrained by constitutional guarantees. Modern constitutional democracies reject such practices and instead insist that criminal justice must always be governed by legality, due process, and prospective application of penal laws. Article 12, therefore, is not merely a procedural safeguard but a substantive manifestation of constitutionalism itself. It preserves the supremacy of law over arbitrary power, protects individual liberty against retrospective criminal legislation, and strengthens public confidence in the fairness and integrity of the criminal justice system. Together with Articles 4, 9, and 10A of the Constitution, it forms an integral part of Pakistan’s constitutional architecture for the protection of human dignity, legal certainty, and the rule of law. Article 12 of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973, is a cornerstone of constitutionalism and the rule of law. By prohibiting retrospective criminal legislation and the retrospective enhancement of punishment, it embodies the fundamental principle of nullum crimen, nulla poena sine lege, ensuring that no person is punished except in accordance with the law in force at the time of the alleged offence. In conjunction with Articles 4, 9, and 10A, Article 12 protects legal certainty, due process, and individual liberty while preventing arbitrary or politically

  • A Soldier, a Mechanic, and the Cold Arithmetic of …

    By General Ghulam Mustafa (Served in different staff and command assignments, commanded a Corps, raised and commanded Army Strategic Force Command) & Engineer Arshad H Abbasi, Co-founder, Energy Excellence Centres at NUST and Engineering University Peshawar, International Transboundary Water Expert We are not screenwriters, and this is not the plot of some Hollywood picture about killer robots. We write this together as two men who came to the same conclusion from two different directions — one of us a soldier who has stood post and commanded troops, the other a mechanic and engineer who has spent his life with his hands inside machines, the kind who can tell you what’s wrong with an engine by the sound it makes before it ever fails. Between us, we have spent the last two years doing the same thing every serious military professional on earth has been doing: watching. Watching Russia and Ukraine grind through the third year of a war that has quietly buried the twentieth century. Watching the United States and Israel fight Iran through the spring and summer of 2026 in a conflict that opened with a strike on a supreme leader and closed, for now, with tankers stacked outside a blockaded Strait of Hormuz. We have not been watching for drama. We have been watching for the future, because the future is what these two wars have been showing us, in plain daylight, for anyone willing to look. In these two wars, our role has not been that of commentators cheering for one flag or another. It has been closer to that of historians standing over wreckage — the unglamorous, unsleeping work of the crash investigator rather than the war correspondent. Every video of an intercepted missile over the Gulf, every geolocated frame of a naval drone striking a Russian hull, every leaked spec sheet of a downed quadcopter over the Black Sea or a jammed loitering munition over the Iranian coast, has to be logged, timestamped, and cross-checked against the next one. That is what wreckage analysis actually is: not excitement, but discipline — recording what a piece of equipment was asked to do, and what it actually did, until the pattern becomes undeniable. Two years of that discipline, applied to two very different wars fought six thousand kilometres apart, keeps returning the same verdict. Here is what we have seen. The age of the tank column, the massed infantry advance, the fighter squadron duel, and even the aircraft carrier as the ultimate expression of national power — that age is closing. Not because these machines have become useless overnight, but because a battlefield now watched by satellites, saturated with cheap sensors, and swarmed by thousands of low-cost drones has no room left for anything large, slow, or expensive to hide in. Ukraine, a country with no serious blue-water navy, used naval drones costing a fraction of a warship to cripple roughly 40 percent of Russia’s Black Sea Fleet and force the rest to retreat from Crimea’s shores. In the Iran war, American carrier strike groups sat further offshore than doctrine once assumed necessary, and the campaign’s real damage was done by long-range strike, electronic warfare, and a naval blockade — not by tank divisions crossing a border, because there was no border to cross. The lesson repeats itself in both theatres: mass a large, valuable, human-crewed asset in the open, and you have built an expensive target. The war has moved to the phone in a soldier’s hand and the joystick on a folding table a hundred kilometres from the front. That is the second thing the two of us keep coming back to, and we believe it is right: future wars will be fought on mobile phones, controlling drones and robots. A robotic aircraft or ground vehicle can turn harder, dive faster, and sit still for longer than any pilot or driver, because it carries no pulse, no fear, no fatigue, and no family waiting at home. It needs no food. It needs no rest. It bleeds nothing when it dies except budget. Robots are already taking on the jobs that used to cost human lives — clearing minefields, hauling ammunition across exposed ground, flying reconnaissance into airspace too dangerous for a manned cockpit, making split-second targeting decisions with artificial intelligence faster than any human crew ever could. Armed drones and robotic ground vehicles now engage targets without risking a single pilot or driver. And because production, not stockpiling, decides who wins a prolonged war, the country that can build the most machines the fastest — not the country with the largest inherited arsenal — will hold the advantage. That is why the truest weapon in this new age is not a missile or a jet. It is the strength of a nation’s economy: its factories, its chip supply, its ability to iterate a drone design in weeks instead of years. Nowhere is this arithmetic more urgent than on the roof of the world, along the disputed frontier between India and China. China is not merely testing drones there; it is one of the most important production engines in the world for both, and it has been pouring resources into robotic ground systems, sensors, and autonomous platforms specifically postured along the Line of Actual Control, at altitudes where a human soldier struggles simply to breathe, let alone fight. Every one of those machines can be commanded from a warm room in Beijing, thousands of kilometres from the mountain. It needs no oxygen tent, no field ration, no medical evacuation. It can occupy a ridge and simply wait there, indefinitely, with a precision no human sentry can match, and it costs Beijing nothing but electricity and silicon when it is destroyed. Against that, India fields one of the largest land armies on the planet — an active strength of roughly 1.25 million soldiers, organized into seven operational commands and fourteen corps of holding and strike formations, built on a tradition of sacrifice, discipline, and sheer human

  • Guardians of Mind in the digital deluge

    A meticulous examination of human civilization reveals a fundamental, unrelenting truth: the ultimate destiny, rise, and moral endurance of nations are never dictated solely by the expansion of their treasuries, the volume of their industrial output, or the brute dominance of their military might. Rather, they hinge upon their intellectual sovereignty, their engagement with the zeitgeist, and the preservation of their scholarly legacy. Knowledge constitutes the living soul of any dignified society—an indispensable force that enables a people to safeguard their intellectual frontiers, foster collective evolution, and claim a distinguished standing in the global council of minds. The sturdiest, most ancient, and most sacred citadel dedicated to preserving this intellectual momentum, organizing it within modern scientific frameworks, and transmitting it across generations remains the library. Yet, it is a poignant and deeply troubling irony that our prevailing socio-educational attitudes routinely reduce the library to a sterile edifice of stone and mortar—a mere repository of silent shelves and dust-laden volumes. Through this narrow, utilitarian lens, the profession of the librarian is similarly diminished, cast as little more than a routine counter clerk or a custodian issuing loans. Such apathy betrays a profound collective negligence toward the very architects of our intellectual heritage and the true sentinels of wisdom. In an era ensnared by algorithmic echo chambers, sensationalist digital flows, and an unrelenting deluge of Artificial Intelligence—where the sheer abundance of information has blurred the boundaries between verified truth and superficial noise—the librarian’s vocation has acquired a heightened, almost sacred imperative. The modern librarian is no longer a passive guardian of books; they serve as an authoritative, discerning Information Navigator amidst a tempestuous ocean of data. They erect the scientific and critical filters that protect researchers, scholars, and students from sinking into the quagmires of misinformation. Ensuring the equitable, uninterrupted, and rigorous transmission of knowledge is the ultimate guarantee of a society’s intellectual sovereignty, and the librarian stands as the quiet architect fortifying that foundation behind the scenes. Throughout the subcontinent’s intellectual history, libraries served as the vital organs of the body politic—its heart and mind. In tracing the evolutionary arc of library science across South Asia, August 12 emerges as a watershed moment. This date marks the birth anniversary of Professor Dr. S.R. Ranganathan (1892–1972), the towering polymath and founding father of modern library science in the region. Ranganathan revolutionized traditional custodial practices, elevating library management into a structured, universally recognized scientific discipline. His seminal Five Laws of Library Science remain the universal constitution of bibliothecal organization. He catalyzed an epistemological shift by asserting that books are not meant to be locked away in archival isolation but are living tools for active inquiry; bridging the gap between every reader and their required text lies at the very core of a library’s purpose. Celebrating August 12 as Librarians’ Day across South Asia is, therefore, a public tribute to this intellectual legacy and an unequivocal affirmation of the nobility of the profession. It was against this rich historical backdrop that the Quaid-e-Azam Central Library at the University of Gujrat recently hosted a distinguished academic symposium to commemorate Librarians’ Day. Chaired by the Chief Librarian, A.R. Sheikh, the gathering transcended routine ceremonial formality. It served as a rigorous reaffirmation of the historical contributions of libraries in South Asia and an exploration of the evolving mandates of librarianship within contemporary higher education and research. The professional staff of the Quaid-e-Azam Central Library used the occasion not merely to celebrate history, but to renew their solemn pledge: to reignite the culture of deep reading and to transform the library into the region’s most dynamic, responsive, and technologically adept sanctuary for scholarly inquiry. The panel discussion opened with compelling insights from Senior Librarian Mrs. Rameeza Mushtaq, who underscored that no institution of higher learning can claim completeness without a fully realized library—the true intellectual heart of any university. Senior Librarian Mr. Liaquat Ali emphasized that while the digital age and e-books have fundamentally reshaped reading habits, the enduring value of physical texts and historical archival materials remains absolute; librarians serve as the indispensable bridge sustaining the bond between students, faculty, and authentic scholarship. Expanding on the technological horizon, Librarian Mrs. Khadija Munawar highlighted how modern information technology has expanded the librarian’s scope, transforming them into high-level information navigators capable of guiding researchers through vast digital landscapes. The capstone of the symposium was the presidential address delivered by Chief Librarian A.R. Sheikh—a masterclass in scholarly vision and professional reflection. In his keynote address, A.R. Sheikh articulated a powerful thesis: > “A library is not merely an inert structure built of brick and mortar, nor is it a quiet sanctuary of passive bookshelves; it is the ultimate fountainhead of a nation’s intellectual and ideological sovereignty. The true academic stature of any university or nation resides in its capacity for original research and the rigorous processing of information. In this era of chaotic digital overabundance, discerning signal from noise and quality from triviality is the defining professional test of the modern librarian. August 12 reminds us that safeguarding knowledge and ensuring its unimpeded flow is a sacred trust.” > This presidential manifesto resonates as a clarion call for our broader educational landscape. A close institutional assessment of the Quaid-e-Azam Central Library at the University of Gujrat demonstrates how a modern library can effectively anchor the research and pedagogical needs of a region. Beyond housing an extensive collection of print literature and rare manuscripts, the library’s staff has actively integrated state-of-the-art digital infrastructure. Through seamless access to the HEC Digital Library, international peer-reviewed journals, Online Public Access Catalogs (OPAC), specialized research bays for MPhil and PhD scholars, and robust plagiarism detection frameworks, the library stands as a vibrant, operational engine of advanced inquiry. Yet, while acknowledging such institutional achievements, we must confront a starker, systemic reality across our broader society: the guardians of books—our librarians and library staff—remain deeply underappreciated despite their quiet, indispensable contributions. This pervasive social blind spot reflects a broader intellectual stagnation. The time has come to

  • Europe experiences what Pakistan has been facing f…

    For decades, Pakistan has been living with extreme heat. Every summer, temperatures rise above 50°C in parts of Sindh and Balochistan, and cities across Punjab and southern Pakistan face prolonged heatwaves that make daily life a struggle for survival. Agricultural workers, construction labourers, sanitation staff and traffic police continue working under the blazing sun, often without adequate rest, shade, drinking water or legal protection. Heat has long been an occupational hazard in Pakistan, but, unfortunately, it has rarely received the policy attention it deserves. Now, Europe is confronting an extreme heat that Pakistan has experienced for years recorded above 50°C. The recent heatwave across Europe has pushed temperatures above 40°C in Germany, France, Italy, Spain and several other countries. Heat warnings have become routine, hospitals have reported sharp increases in heatstroke cases, schools have closed, transport systems have been disrupted, and governments have activated emergency response plans. The crisis has revealed that no country, regardless of its wealth or technological advancement, is immune to the accelerating consequences of climate change. The difference is that Europe’s heat emergency is still treated as an exceptional event, whereas in Pakistan extreme heat has become almost routine. Every year, millions face dangerous temperatures with little expectation of institutional support. When temperatures exceed 50°C in Jacobabad, Dadu, Sibi and surrounding districts, headlines fade within days even though the suffering continues for months. Pakistan has already paid a heavy price for climate inaction. The 2015 Karachi heatwave claimed well over a thousand lives within a few days, overwhelming hospitals and exposing serious weaknesses in disaster preparedness. Later investigations identified prolonged power outages, water shortages and the absence of coordinated emergency planning as major contributors to the tragedy. The disaster should have transformed national preparedness for future heatwaves. Instead, progress has been uneven and largely confined to a few urban centres. The devastating floods of 2022 offered another painful lesson. Although Pakistan contributes less than one percent of global greenhouse gas emissions, it suffered one of the worst climate disasters in its history, affecting more than 33 million people, destroying homes, schools, hospitals and agricultural land, and causing economic losses worth billions of dollars. The catastrophe exposed Pakistan’s vulnerability to climate extremes, ranging from floods to droughts and heatwaves. A long-term climate adaptation has failed to keep pace with rapidly increasing climate risks. Yes, climate change is not an environmental issue. It is a public health crisis, to be very clear, it is an economic challenge and a labour rights issue. Thousands of outdoor workers continue to perform physically demanding jobs during the hottest hours of the day without mandatory heat safety standards. Lost productivity, rising healthcare costs, declining crop yields, and growing pressure on electricity and water systems are becoming defining features of Pakistan’s summers. Europe’s current experience should be seen as a lesson that climate friendly cannot be built only after disasters occur. Infrastructure must be redesigned for rising temperatures, cities need more trees and green spaces instead of endless concrete, early warning systems must reach vulnerable communities, and labour laws should guarantee rest breaks, access to drinking water and protection for outdoor workers during extreme heat. Schools, hospitals and public buildings should also be adapted to withstand prolonged periods of extreme temperatures. For developed countries, the heatwave exposes the limits of relying solely on emissions reduction without making sufficient investments in climate adaptation. For Pakistan, it is another warning against repeating the cycle of learning lessons only after each catastrophe. The country’s climate history from Karachi’s deadly heatwave to the unprecedented floods of 2022 offers painful experiences of the cost of delayed action. The climate crisis no longer belongs to the future or to any single region. It is unfolding across continents, exposing both rich and poor nations to unprecedented risks. Europe is now discovering what Pakistan has known for years: extreme heat is not merely uncomfortable. It is deadly, economically destructive and socially unequal. The real question is no longer whether another climate disaster will arrive, but whether governments will finally learn from the ones that have already occurred.

  • |

    Does your native language control how you think?

    With over 7,000 distinct human languages spoken across the globe today, humanity communicates through fascinating sentence structures. A compelling debate has captivated thinkers for decades. Does the language you grow up speaking dictate the limits of what your mind can comprehend? This captivating idea lies at the heart of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis. A theory that continues to provoke vibrant discussions across linguistics, philosophy, and cognitive science. The Power of Vocabulary and Perception The hypothesis was formulated in the early 20th century by linguists Edward Sapir and Benjamin Lee Whorf. It’s often referred to as linguistic relativity or linguistic determinism. They propose that the structure of a native language fundamentally shapes its speakers’ worldview and cognitive capacity. If a concept or object lacks a dedicated word in a person’s language, that person cannot truly perceive, categorize or conceptualize it. Consider how different cultures classify colors. Some languages possess dozens of specific terms for distinct shades. Whereas,  others operate with only a couple of basic terms distinguishing between light and dark tones. According to strong linguistic determinism, a speaker whose native tongue lacks a dedicated word for green would struggle to perceive a green leaf as distinct from yellow. Similarly, emotional vocabularies vary widely across cultures. German famously uses the word Schadenfreude to describe taking pleasure in someone else’s misfortune. According to Sapir-Whorf theory, an English speaker whose language lacks an exact single-word equivalent would supposedly find it difficult to recognize or isolate that specific emotional state within themselves. Why the Concept Fascinates Us? It is easy to see why the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis captured public imagination. The notion that our mother tongue acts as a unique way through which we view reality is deeply romantic. Philosophically, the theory suggests that the world contains thousands of distinct cognitive universes. If language entirely dictated thought, cross-cultural understanding would face profound barriers. It is so as the speakers of different languages would operate inside fundamentally incompatible mental frameworks. In semantic studies, labeling objects and experiences allows humans to organize chaotic sensory input efficiently. Giving a name to a precise group such as distinguishing toddlers, teenagers and senior citizens helps us categorize society into recognizable stages. The hypothesis demonstrated that naming things provides cognitive shortcuts. Such a naming method makes specific distinctions far easier to reference and discuss in daily life. Why Modern Science Rejects Strong Determinism Despite its initial popularity, modern linguistics and cognitive scientists reject strong linguistic determinism. The fundamental flaw in the hypothesis rests on a misunderstanding of the relationship between mind and speech. Language does not produce thought. Rather, human thought drives the creation and evolution of language. When people encounter new experiences, foods or technologies, they do not remain silent simply because they lack pre-existing terminology. Instead, humans spontaneously create new phrases. They adapt existing terms or borrow words from other cultures to describe what they have experienced. An English speaker can easily understand and feel pleasure at a rival’s failure without ever having heard the German word Schadenfreude. While English uses blue for both dark and light shades. Whereas Italian maintains separate primary words (blu and azzurro). English speakers are fully capable of seeing the difference between a midday sky and the deep ocean. Human cognition precedes language. Speech serves as a flexible tool designed to communicate human experiences, not a rigid cage that imprisons cognitive ability. The Lasting Value of Sapir-Whorf   The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis retains great value even if its most radical claim has been disproven. It paved the way for weak linguistic relativity. The claim further explores how language subtly influences cognition, memory and visual attention without imposing hard limits on intellect. Ultimately, Sapir and Whorf inspired generations of researchers to explore the mysterious connection between human culture, language and the mind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *