vantage point companions
| | | | | | | | | | |

[Vantage Point] Companions in power: When Ramon Ang goes up against Ramon Ang

There is nothing inherently wrong with Ramon S. Ang investing his own money. But his 25.68% stake in Lopez Inc. creates a corporate-governance question that has attracted surprisingly little attention: where does Ramon Ang, the independent private investor, leave off and Ramon Ang, the chairman and chief executive of San Miguel Corp. (SMC), step in?

His personal investment is not necessarily a conflict of interest. But there are enough red lights to make the longer answer important.

Ang acquired the stake through his wholly owned investment vehicle Illumina Investment Holdings Inc. SMC did not buy the shares, and even clarified in an official disclosure to the Philippine Stock Exchange (PSE) that Ang had acted in his personal capacity.

That is an important distinction, but it does not resolve potential conflicts.

Consider the numbers.

Lopez Inc. owns 54.74% of Lopez Holdings, which owns 60.67% of First Philippine Holdings (FPH). FPH, in turn, owns 67.84% of First Gen Corporation (First Gen)’s common shares. Trace Ang’s 25.68% through those ownership layers and you will see that he has roughly 5.79% look-through economic exposure to First Gen.

That is not a direct holding or voting right. But Ang now has a personal economic interest in one of the biggest power groups in the Philippines, while continuing to head another conglomerate that dominates much of the same industry.

The Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC)’s numbers make that overlap difficult to brush aside. At end-2024, SMC accounted for 6,079.6 megawatts (MW) of attributable installed generating capacity, or 22.44% of the national total — the country’s largest share. First Gen ranked third with 3,583 MW, or 13.22%.

These are not two companies that may eventually collide in the same line of business. They already inhabit the same electricity market. They may compete for power plants, renewable-energy projects, liquefied natural gas (LNG) and other fuel contracts, electricity customers, financing, and government-awarded energy opportunities.

This is where the conflict becomes real. (READ: ERC scrutiny adds a new wrinkle to Ramon Ang’s Lopez, Inc investment)

The many what ifs

What if an attractive generating asset is offered for sale and First Gen wants it as badly as San Miguel? Suppose they pursue the same hydropower project or power-supply contract. Imagine commercially sensitive information obtained from one side potentially giving an advantage to the other.

Which Ramon Ang would then show up?

Philippine corporation law anticipated this problem.

Section 30 of the Revised Corporation Code addresses directors who acquire personal or pecuniary interests that conflict with their duties. 

Section 33 goes further: when a director, by virtue of his office, takes for himself a business opportunity that should belong to the corporation and profits at its expense, he must account for those profits, unless stockholders representing at least two-thirds of outstanding capital stock ratify the act.

The law contains an especially relevant qualification: the corporate-opportunity rule applies even when the director risked his own funds.

Caveat: this does not mean that Ang breached either provision by buying into Lopez Inc.

There is no evidence that SMC wanted Crème Investment Corp.’s 25.68% stake, that the opportunity was first offered to San Miguel, or that Ang diverted an SMC opportunity into Illumina. It would be a step too far to call the acquisition itself unlawful.

Ang’s Lopez stake carries an implied value of roughly P11.56 billion based on his P45-billion valuation of Lopez Inc. Piki Lopez has described him not merely as an investor but as a “partner” whose expertise could help grow Lopez businesses.

Why governance matters

The corporate relationships are meanwhile becoming more intertwined. ABS-CBN is raising P6 billion in fresh equity, including P3.5 billion from I&C Holdings Corp., a newly incorporated investment company formed by senior bankers associated with Fortman Cline Capital Markets.

Must Read

[Vantage Point] Whose P3.5 billion is I&C investing in ABS-CBN?


[Vantage Point] Whose P3.5 billion is I&C investing in ABS-CBN?

Fortman Cline is hardly a stranger to San Miguel. Its published transaction history shows it advised SMC on acquisitions that helped transform the conglomerate into a major power and infrastructure player, including transactions involving Meralco, Sual, San Roque, Ilijan and, more recently, the NAIA concession.

None of this establishes that Ang owns, finances or controls I&C. There is presently no documentary evidence that he does. But it illustrates how closely Philippine corporate circles can intersect — and why governance matters as personal investments, advisory relationships and corporate partnerships overlap.

Does that mean Lopez companies should now avoid businesses where San Miguel operates?

No.

That would effectively create a private non-compete zone around SMC. First Gen should not abandon a project merely because San Miguel wants it. The governance burden falls principally on Ang and the decision-making process.

Disclosure and recusal

When interests collide, disclosure and recusal become essential. Confidential information cannot travel from one side to benefit another, and an opportunity properly belonging to SMC cannot be redirected toward an enterprise in which Ang has a personal financial interest.

The problem could also run in reverse. We still do not know what governance rights accompany Illumina’s 25.68% Lopez Inc. stake. If Ang or his nominees obtain board seats, veto rights or direct participation in strategic decisions, fiduciary obligations could arise on both sides.

That is why the next crucial disclosure is not another percentage.

It is governance.

And there is one coincidence worth putting on the table.

On August 3, before I&C emerged publicly, the market was abuzz with speculations that an Ang-led investor group was preparing to inject P3.5 billion into ABS-CBN for a 39% economic interest. ABS-CBN subsequently denied that Ang and Manuel V. Pangilinan were negotiating to take over management.

Eleven days later, the disclosed transaction involves I&C investing exactly P3.5 billion for what our calculations suggest could become roughly 38% of enlarged ABS-CBN.

The numbers are remarkably close.

But coincidence is not evidence. Nothing disclosed so far establishes that Ang owns, finances or controls I&C. The parallel is nevertheless difficult enough to ignore — and important enough for investors to keep watching.

None of this presumes wrongdoing. Good governance exists precisely because legitimate business interests sometimes collide.

The scale makes complacency difficult. SMC held 22.44% of attributable national installed generating capacity at end-2024; First Gen had 13.22%. Between them sits Ramon Ang—SMC chairman and CEO on one side and, through Illumina, owner of 25.68% of the holding company above the other.

Those interests can coexist.

The test comes when they want the same thing.

And when that day arrives, the question will no longer be whether Ramon Ang bought his Lopez stake with his own money.

It will be which Ramon Ang has the fiduciary duty to step away.

I welcome your views on these and other issues where decisions made in power shape the country’s economic future.

Below are some Vantage Point pieces you might have missed:

Click here for more Vantage Point articles.

Similar Posts

  • |

    SBP to maintain focus on price stability, reforms and sustainable economic growth

    KARACHI: State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) Governor Jameel Ahmad has said the central bank will continue to prioritise price stability, structural reforms and the creation of a business-friendly economic environment aimed at boosting productivity, exports and employment. Addressing a flag-hoisting ceremony held at the SBP headquarters in Karachi to mark Pakistan’s 79th Independence Day, Governor Ahmad said the country had made notable progress towards macroeconomic stability over the past year. He attributed the improvement to disciplined fiscal and monetary policies, better economic management and continued efforts to strengthen financial and economic institutions. Inflation remains within medium-term range Speaking about the inflation outlook, the SBP governor said average inflation during fiscal year 2025-26 stood at 7.1 percent. He said the central bank believed that the prevailing monetary policy stance was appropriate for keeping inflation within its medium-term target range of 5 to 7 percent. According to Ahmad, the current policy framework also provides sufficient space for economic activity to continue, while supporting investment and employment generation. The governor said maintaining price stability would remain a central objective of the SBP as Pakistan seeks to move from short-term stabilisation towards sustained economic expansion. Growth expected to strengthen Ahmad said Pakistan’s economy recorded growth of 3.7 percent in FY26, reflecting the impact of improved macroeconomic conditions and greater fiscal and monetary discipline. Looking ahead, he projected economic growth in the range of 3.5 to 4.5 percent during FY27. He described the outlook as encouraging, saying the economy was gradually moving towards a more sustainable growth path after going through a difficult period of economic stabilisation. The governor stressed that maintaining policy discipline would be important to ensure that the gains achieved in recent years translate into durable economic development. Remittances strengthen external position The SBP chief also highlighted improvements in Pakistan’s external sector, particularly the performance of workers’ remittances. He said overseas Pakistanis had demonstrated confidence in the country by sending record amounts of money home, with remittances surpassing $41 billion during FY26. The inflow is expected to increase further, with remittances projected to reach around $44 billion in FY27, according to the governor. Ahmad said stronger remittance inflows, combined with a relatively low current account deficit, had helped improve Pakistan’s foreign exchange position. The country’s foreign exchange reserves reached $18.4 billion by the end of FY26, while the SBP expects reserves to rise above $21 billion during FY27. He said strengthening the external position would help improve economic resilience and provide greater capacity to withstand external shocks. SBP pushes digital transformation The governor also outlined measures taken by the central bank to modernise Pakistan’s financial infrastructure and expand the use of digital payment channels. He pointed to the successful launch of PRISM+, saying the upgraded payment and settlement infrastructure had brought Pakistan’s large-value payment system closer to international standards. The system has improved the speed, security and efficiency of large-value payments and settlements, he said. Ahmad added that SBP initiatives aimed at encouraging digital payments had resulted in a substantial increase in the use of electronic channels. Retail digital transactions increased from approximately 10 billion to 12 billion over the past year, reflecting growing adoption of technology across the financial system. According to the governor, the shift towards digital payments is more than a technological development. It is also contributing to greater documentation, transparency and efficiency within the economy. Self-reliance and institutions vital for progress Governor Ahmad said Pakistan’s long-term economic success would depend not only on financial and monetary policies but also on stronger institutions, economic self-reliance, respect for the rule of law and national unity. He emphasised that the country’s journey towards sustainable development required continued commitment and collective efforts from institutions, businesses and citizens. While acknowledging the progress achieved during the past year, he cautioned that Pakistan continued to face economic challenges that required sustained attention, policy consistency and determination. He said the objective should now be to convert the gains from economic stabilisation into a durable foundation for investment, productivity, exports and employment. The governor reaffirmed that the SBP would continue playing its role in supporting monetary and financial stability while contributing to broader efforts aimed at improving the welfare of the Pakistani people.

  • |

    Diesel price rises as government increases petroleum levy

    ISLAMABAD: The federal government has increased the price of high-speed diesel after raising the Petroleum Development Levy (PDL) on the fuel by Rs1 per litre, adding further pressure on consumers and transport-related costs. Following the latest adjustment, the price of high-speed diesel has gone up by 54 paisas per litre, reaching Rs382.89 per litre. The increase comes despite a decline in the ex-refinery price of diesel, with the higher petroleum levy pushing up the final price paid by consumers. The government has raised the diesel levy by Rs1 per litre as part of the latest petroleum price adjustment. The PDL on high-speed diesel now stands at Rs76.28 per litre. The latest increase follows another adjustment made on August 12, when the government raised the petroleum levy on diesel by Rs2 per litre. The successive increases have resulted in a significant rise in the levy component of the retail price. Petrol price reduced In contrast to diesel, the government has reduced the price of petrol by 94 paisas per litre. The price of petrol has now been fixed at Rs324.98 per litre. The Petroleum Development Levy on petrol, however, has remained unchanged at Rs80 per litre. The differing price movements for petrol and diesel are largely linked to changes in their respective pricing components. While the ex-refinery price of diesel declined, the increase in the government levy more than offset the reduction, resulting in a higher retail price. The latest adjustment is expected to have an impact on transportation and logistics costs because diesel is widely used by commercial vehicles, buses, trucks, agricultural machinery and other heavy transport. Higher diesel prices can also influence the cost of goods and services by increasing transportation expenses across supply chains. Meanwhile, the reduction in petrol prices provides limited relief to motorists using petrol-powered vehicles. The government periodically reviews petroleum prices based on international oil prices, exchange-rate movements, taxation and other components of the domestic pricing mechanism. The latest changes reflect the impact of adjustments in the petroleum levy and ex-refinery prices on consumers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *