vantage point system
| | | | |

[Vantage Point] System loss: The electricity consumers pay for but never receive

President Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr.’s call during his 2026 State of the Nation Address (SONA) to remove system-loss charges and the value-added tax (VAT) imposed on electricity consumers produced one of the afternoon’s loudest applause. 


[Vantage Point] System loss: The electricity consumers pay for but never receive

His argument was simple: consumers should not be punished for electricity lost because of defective equipment, inefficient networks, or theft they did not commit. 

Behind that popular declaration, however, lies a complicated regulatory system that has protected distribution utilities from costs that most businesses would normally be expected to manage.

System loss is the difference between the electricity entering a distribution network and the electricity eventually measured and billed to customers. It is calculated as:

If a utility receives one billion kilowatt-hours (kWh) but bills only 940 million, the missing 60 million kWh represents a 6%-system loss. The utility nevertheless paid generators and the transmission operator for the entire one billion kWh. 

Under existing rules, it may recover the cost of the lost electricity from paying customers, provided the loss remains within the ceiling approved by the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC).

Some electricity inevitably disappears as heat when it passes through transformers, cables, and distribution lines. These are technical losses which cannot be eliminated completely but can be reduced through better equipment, shorter lines, and sound network design. 

Nontechnical losses are another matter. They include illegal connections, meter tampering, defective meters, billing errors, and unmetered consumption. These are largely management and enforcement failures.

The math highlights why the real financial burden is heavier than it looks. For example, when a 6.5% allocation charge is distributed across every 100 kWh, but only 93.5% of power is actually delivered, it hikes up the effective rate to 6.95%:

At a combined generation and transmission cost of P7 per kWh, that could add approximately P0.49 for every delivered kWh. A household consuming 300 kWh could consequently pay around P147 for system loss, plus P17.64 in VAT. Actual charges vary monthly with the cost of purchased power and the utility’s recorded losses, but Meralco itself estimates that system loss represents roughly 5% of a typical electricity bill.

Must Read

EXPLAINER: What is system loss, and how does it affect your power bill?


EXPLAINER: What is system loss, and how does it affect your power bill?

Not EPIRA law

System-loss recovery was not created by the Electric Power Industry Reform Act, officially known as Republic Act No. 9136, (EPIRA Law) which sought to restructure the country’s electric power sector. 

It was Republic Act No. 7832 or the Anti-Electricity and Electric Transmission Lines/Materials Pilferage Act of 1994 that criminalized electricity theft and meter tampering, authorizing immediate service disconnection, penalizes offenders with 6 to 12 years of imprisonment or hefty fines. It mandated the payment of differential billings, allowing private utilities and electric cooperatives to recover losses of up to 9.5% and 14%, respectively. 

The ERC later reduced the ceiling for private distribution utilities to 6.5%. Losses above the ceiling cannot be passed on, but allowable losses remain the customer’s responsibility.

The EPIRA Law did not create the VAT on system loss, either. Electricity became subject to VAT under the expanded VAT law enacted in 2005. Because the system-loss charge forms part of the utility’s taxable receipts, the government imposes a 12% VAT on it. Legally, it is taxation on the cost of delivering electricity. Economically, consumers are being taxed on power they never received.

EPIRA was enacted in 2001 after the power shortages of the 1990s and the accumulation of roughly P900 billion in National Power Corporation  (Napocor) debt. It divided the industry into generation, transmission, distribution, and supply; ordered Napocor’s privatization; created Power Sector Assets and Liabilities Management Corporation (PSALM) and the ERC; and eventually established the wholesale electricity spot market. 

The reform also reflected conditions encouraged by international lenders, including a $300-million Asian Development Bank restructuring program approved in 1998.

Competition, however, was introduced principally in generation and supply. Distribution remained a geographic monopoly. A household in Metro Manila does not have the option to replace the Manila Electric Company (Meralco) with an alternative power provider. 

Generation and transmission costs, taxes, subsidies, and allowable system losses are largely passed through, while Meralco separately earns regulated distribution, supply and metering charges. 

It does not pocket the entire system-loss payment, but it is substantially protected from the cost of electricity disappearing inside its network.

EPIRA also permits distribution utilities to buy power from affiliated generators, subject to ownership limits and competitive-selection requirements. This creates an obvious tension when a distributor acts as electricity buyer and bidding administrator while companies connected to its corporate group compete to become suppliers. The law promised competition but tolerated substantial vertical integration.

Must Read

Meralco: Some system loss unavoidable, urges careful EPIRA reform


Meralco: Some system loss unavoidable, urges careful EPIRA reform

Look back

The Lopez family which owned large power-generating assets through First Philippine Holdings and First Gen-controlled Meralco when EPIRA was enacted. It benefited from private generation, Meralco’s protected franchise and legally permitted affiliate transactions. Yet EPIRA cannot defensibly be described simply as a Lopez-written law, and Meralco is no longer Lopez-controlled, having passed to the Manuel V. Pangilinan-led group.

Interestingly, there was a genuine payola controversy in 2000 when then-party-list representatives Etta Rosales and Rene Magtubo alleged that lawmakers received P500,000 each in connection with the Omnibus Power Bill, EPIRA’s legislative predecessor. 

The House-led investigation of that controversy stalled, and no judicial finding was established that the Lopez group provided the funds. Therefore, while we cannot say the Lopez group is definitely guilty of bribery, the EPIRA law was still passed under a cloud of unresolved corruption allegations.

In the President’s SONA, a real incentive problem was clearly identified. When losses are automatically recoverable, shareholders have less reason to eliminate them. But technical losses cannot be abolished by presidential applause. 

Congress must prohibit recovery of nontechnical losses, impose strict network-specific benchmarks, require independent audits, and make shareholders absorb inefficient performance. Otherwise, system loss may disappear as a visible charge only to return under another name.

The Philippine Rural Electric Cooperatives Association, Inc. (Philreca) which  represents electric cooperatives operating across the Philippines says it supports removing VAT on system-loss charges because consumers should not be taxed for electricity they never received.

In statement, it warned however that completely prohibiting recovery of system losses without a government subsidy could bankrupt nonprofit electric cooperatives, particularly those serving rural areas with long feeder lines and difficult terrain where technical losses are unavoidable. Instead, Philreca urged Congress to adopt feeder-specific loss ceilings, performance-based reductions, government-funded grid upgrades and stronger anti-pilferage enforcement.

Can Marcos Jr. deliver? I’ve asked a high-ranking government official. He says it must be done. – Rappler.com

This analysis draws on President Marcos’s 2026 SONA remarks, Republic Acts 7832, 9136 and 9337, the Philippine Distribution Code, and ERC rules on recoverable system losses, Meralco’s published bill breakdown, and studies by the Asian Development Bank, Philippine Institute for Development Studies, and UP Center for Integrative and Development Studies. Media reporting also documented the alleged P500,000 payments connected with EPIRA’s legislative predecessor, although no conclusive judicial or congressional finding established that the Lopez group financed them.

Below are Vantage Point pieces you might have missed: 

Click here for other Vantage Point articles.

Similar Posts

  • |

    ICCI awards in Istanbul highlight new opportunities for Pakistan-Turkiye economic partnership

    ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ICCI) has used a series of high-level engagements in Istanbul to promote Pakistan’s private sector, recognise leading entrepreneurs and strengthen commercial ties between Pakistan and Turkiye. The ICCI International Excellence Awards 2026 brought together Turkish government representatives, diplomats, business leaders and members of the Pakistani and Turkish business communities, providing a platform to highlight the contribution of Pakistani entrepreneurs while exploring opportunities for greater bilateral trade and investment. Around 40 Pakistani business leaders representing a range of sectors were honoured at the awards ceremony for their contributions to the country’s economy and private-sector development, according to a press release issued on Saturday. The event also provided an opportunity for business representatives from both countries to discuss the potential for expanded commercial cooperation, investment partnerships and joint ventures. Turkish officials stress stronger business links Addressing the ceremony, Istanbul Deputy Governor Mehmet Sulun said initiatives bringing together business communities from Pakistan and Turkiye could play an important role in expanding people-to-people and business-to-business contacts. He said stronger interaction between entrepreneurs could create fresh opportunities in trade, investment and joint ventures while contributing to deeper ties between the two countries. Sulun observed that business leaders played a role beyond commercial activity, describing them as important contributors to friendship and mutual understanding between the two nations. He expressed confidence that the longstanding relationship between Pakistan and Turkiye would continue to develop and remain strong for future generations. Pakistan’s Consul General in Istanbul Khawaja Khurram Naeem also emphasised the importance of expanding direct links between the private sectors of the two countries. He said political and fraternal relations needed to be complemented by stronger commercial engagement if Pakistan and Turkiye were to significantly increase bilateral trade and investment. Naeem assured Pakistani business representatives that Pakistan’s diplomatic mission would continue supporting initiatives aimed at improving commercial cooperation and facilitating interaction between entrepreneurs from both countries. ICCI seeks expansion in trade and investment In his opening remarks, ICCI President Sardar Tahir Mehmood highlighted the longstanding historical, cultural and fraternal relationship between Pakistan and Turkiye. He said the two countries had strong political and people-to-people relations, but the economic relationship had considerable room for further expansion. Mehmood reaffirmed the ICCI’s commitment to supporting efforts aimed at increasing bilateral trade and investment in line with the ambitions of the leadership of both countries. He said the chamber was working to establish itself as an international platform connecting Pakistani businesses with global markets and partners. According to Mehmood, the ICCI is focusing on promoting Pakistani exports, attracting investment and developing international business partnerships while coordinating with government departments and other relevant institutions to improve the business environment. He stressed that greater ease of doing business and stronger institutional support would help Pakistani companies compete more effectively in international markets. Turkish chamber backs institutional cooperation Munir Ustun, a member of the Executive Board of the Istanbul Chamber of Commerce, welcomed efforts to bring the Pakistani and Turkish business communities closer. He stressed the importance of stronger institutional relationships between chambers and private-sector organisations in both countries. Ustun said regular business delegations, business-to-business meetings and joint commercial initiatives could help identify areas where cooperation could be expanded. He noted that significant untapped potential existed in bilateral trade and investment and that closer engagement between businesses could help turn that potential into concrete commercial projects. Faisal Town Group Director Zohair Majeed said the international recognition given to Pakistani entrepreneurs demonstrated the capability and resilience of the country’s private sector. He said Pakistani companies had the potential to compete in international markets and argued that stronger partnerships with Turkish businesses could create opportunities in investment, technology transfer and exports. According to Majeed, greater cooperation between businesses could also contribute to sustainable economic growth and help Pakistani companies gain access to new markets and technologies. Pakistan-Turkiye economic ties discussed at Independence Day event The ICCI delegation also participated in a separate event in Istanbul to mark Pakistan’s 79th Independence Day, where Pakistani and Turkish business representatives reaffirmed their commitment to strengthening bilateral economic cooperation. Speaking at the gathering, Mehmood said Pakistan’s independence had been achieved after enormous sacrifices by the country’s founding generation. He called on citizens and the business community to contribute to national development by promoting economic growth, investment and entrepreneurship. Mehmood said Pakistan and Turkiye shared decades of historical, cultural and fraternal ties, adding that the longstanding relationship should increasingly be reflected in stronger economic cooperation. He called for greater participation by the private sectors of both countries in trade, investment and joint ventures. The ICCI president said the chamber would continue to provide platforms where Pakistani and Turkish entrepreneurs could meet, explore commercial opportunities and develop long-term partnerships. Turkish business representatives also reiterated their commitment to deepening the relationship with Pakistan, particularly through increased trade, investment and direct business-to-business engagement. Business conference explores investment opportunities The economic engagement was further strengthened through a Business Opportunity Conference in Istanbul, which brought together business leaders from both countries to examine potential areas for cooperation. Participants discussed opportunities for expanding bilateral trade, establishing joint ventures, attracting investment and creating stronger business-to-business connections. Pakistan’s Consul General in Istanbul Khawaja Khurram Naeem participated actively in the discussions, responding to questions from Turkish business representatives and outlining Pakistan’s trade and investment potential. He also highlighted developments in the country’s business and investment environment and encouraged Turkish companies to examine opportunities in Pakistan. A significant number of Turkish companies participated in the conference and expressed interest in exploring commercial and investment prospects in Pakistan. During an interactive session, ICCI President Sardar Tahir Mehmood, along with former ICCI presidents Aamir Waheed Sheikh and Mohammad Ejaz Abbasi, and Dr Adeel Sami, Founder and President of the Pakistan-Turkiye Investment & Development Council, responded to questions from Turkish entrepreneurs. The discussion focused on practical mechanisms for strengthening commercial links and identifying sectors where Pakistani and Turkish companies could work together. Focus shifts from friendship to economic partnership The events in Istanbul underscored a

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *