this economy notes
| | | | |

[In This Economy] Notes from Cambodia

As all eyes were on Manila for the Philippines’ hosting of the ASEAN Summit, I got to explore Cambodia again for the first time in almost a decade.

My jaw positively dropped when I went through Phnom Penh’s new airport.

Techo International Airport opened in September 2025. Its terminal is huge, with a roof inspired by Cambodia’s national flower and a ceiling patterned after traditional Khmer fishing equipment. 

Immediately I thought about how lamentable the Ninoy Aquino International Airport (NAIA) is by comparison. 

Sure, there are questions about how Techo was built. A Chinese state-owned company built the passenger terminal, and the first phase alone cost a whopping US$2.3 billion. Critics assail how the contracts were awarded and who will end up bearing the financial risks. 

At any rate, it cannot be denied that Techo is a first-class airport. If the main international gateway of a country is any indication, I’m sad to report that Cambodia beat us in this aspect.

I would even venture to say Cambodians are much more ready to receive guests for the annual ASEAN Summit than we are. (In the past few days, they actually received delegates for the Francophonie Summit, which they are hosting for the first time ever.)

Techo International Airport, JC Punongbayan, Phnom Penh, Cambodia
FLOWER PATTERN. The author at the new Techo International Airport, about 40 minutes away from central Phnom Penh.
Cambodia FDI

An airport, of course, signals only so much, and it can’t hide the fact that in 2026 Cambodia is in dire straits like us.

For this year, the World Bank expects Cambodia’s economy to grow by just 3.5%, down from an estimated 5.3% in 2025. Meanwhile, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) expects growth of just 3%, with inflation averaging 5.6%. Expensive energy and weaker tourism are among the reasons for the slowdown.

Sounds familiar? In my last column, I argued that the Philippines had entered stagflation territory. We’d had two quarters in a row of unusually weak growth and high inflation, even after I changed how I accounted for the pandemic in my growth benchmark. 

Still, Cambodia is faring a bit better than us, and the data show that plainly.

What also stood out to me was how much foreign direct investment (FDI) Cambodia already gets. In 2025, it took in $5.1 billion or about a tenth of its gross domestic product.

Foreign investment is also spreading beyond garments to areas like electronics and renewable energy. But the IMF says Cambodia needs to attract higher-quality investment and spur more investment by Cambodian firms.

Cambodia teaches us that foreign investments are necessary but not sufficient for sustained growth. A lot of work remains after foreign money comes in. 

For instance, a foreign factory can hire a lot of workers and export a lot of goods while buying its sophisticated inputs overseas and keeping its engineering work at headquarters. The gains get bigger when local suppliers can win contracts and local engineers get to solve problems they used to send back to headquarters.

That brings me back to Pax Silica, discussions of which heated up in the past couple of days in the run-up to our ASEAN hosting. Hundreds of protesters were arrested, bringing back images of how protests were stifled by the old Marcos regime.

We don’t know quite yet how much money will come into New Clark City. But it’s important to ask: What will Filipino engineers actually get to do there? Will they run the tests or develop them, too? Will Philippine firms have a shot at supplying the factory? And if we’re offering tax breaks or paying for infrastructure, what commitments are we getting in return? 

Many questions linger in the air as the Pax Silica framework is set to be formalized by December, after the ASEAN Summit and the quick visit of US President Donald Trump.

Must Read

Sorry, Marcos can’t keep his ‘very, very important guest’ waiting


Sorry, Marcos can’t keep his ‘very, very important guest’ waiting

Budget reforms in Cambodia

I also learned that Cambodia has spearheaded reforms in public financial management or PFM. It refers to how the government plans, spends, and accounts for public money.

This fact I picked up from the 21st International Convention of the East Asian Economic Association held in Siem Reap on November 14 and 15. 

In a session on the Cambodian economy, I learned that public financial management has been the subject of a sustained reform program there since 2004. (The finance ministry’s own reform steering committee helped host the conference.)

Think about that for a moment. They’ve been at it for more than 20 years.

To be fair, the Philippines has its own PFM roadmap for 2024 to 2028. But the reforms need to level up well after 2028, in the wake of the flood control scandal of 2025 and the emerging scandal concerning the 2027 pre-election budget.

Take the multipurpose buildings, farm-to-market roads, and flood control projects that keep mushrooming in the national budget. Before any is funded, an agency should be able to tell us where it’s going, whom it will serve, and why it deserves priority. 

Then when Congress adds any project, we should be able to see who asked for it and what appraisal it went through. When the money gets disbursed, people should be able to check whether the road was actually built. 

Lawmakers have boasted of “reforms” like livestreamed budget deliberations and new online portals that supposedly enable ordinary Filipinos to scrutinize the budget. But in truth, many of these are perfunctory reforms that do nothing to fix the entrenched culture of patronage-driven budgeting. 

Bad budgeting drags growth, and if we fail to take PFM seriously, then Cambodia might beat us here, too.

Never forget

Finally, right before my flight back to Manila, I managed to squeeze in a quick visit to S-21, now the Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum in Phnom Penh. 

If you don’t have any idea about it, the Khmer Rouge took an ordinary school and turned it into a prison and torture center back in the mid-1970s. The rooms are still there, and so are the photographs and records of the people they imprisoned.

I had goosebumps the whole time. Even after I left the museum, I was still shaken. 

Even in broad daylight, I was horrified by the idea that humans can do such despicable things to fellow humans. S-21 was a factory of torture and death, and visiting the museum is not for the faint-hearted.

It made me think about what we’ve done to preserve the memory of martial law under Ferdinand Marcos Sr. Sure, we’ve had a law since 2013 that calls for a memorial, museum, and library for victims of human rights violations. 

Freedom Memorial Museum, UP Diliman, scale model
DELAYED. Scale model of the Freedom Memorial Museum. Courtesy of UP Diliman Information Office

Meanwhile, the University of the Philippines and the Human Rights Violations Victims’ Memorial Commission have committed to building the Freedom Memorial Museum in UP Diliman. It was supposed to have been opened in 2022, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the martial law declaration. But four years on, as one would expect under yet another Marcos presidency, no progress has been made.

In Phnom Penh, locals and tourists alike can visit the gruesome Tuol Sleng museum as a ghastly reminder of their past. At the end of the tour, in the central courtyard, one can pay respects to the victims of the genocide at a six-meter, non-denominational stone stupa that rises above black marble plaques. Engraved are the names of 12,272 documented S-21 prisoners.

Historical marker, Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum, Cambodia
NEVER FORGET. A marker at the Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum: “Never will we forget the crimes committed during the Democratic Kampuchea regime.” Photo by JC Punongbayan

Similarly, we need to have a stronger reckoning and memorialization of the victims of Martial Law. We have the Bantayog ng mga Bayani, sure, but it needs a lot more financial support, and the museum at UP must finally be opened after long delays.

Apart from the martial law victims, we need to seriously memorialize as well the thousands who died under the bloody war on drugs by former president Rodrigo Duterte, who will soon stand trial at the International Criminal Court.

At least 1.7 million people died under the Khmer Rouge. The UN-backed tribunal convicted just three men, including the person who ran S-21. 

I just hope the families of those killed in Duterte’s drug war see justice, too. – Rappler.com

Jan Carlo “JC” Punongbayan, PhD, is an associate professor at the University of the Philippines School of Economics. His professional experience includes the Securities and Exchange Commission, the World Bank Office in Manila, the Far Eastern University Public Policy Center, and the National Economic and Development Authority. JC writes a weekly economics column for Rappler. He is also co-founder of UsapangEcon.com and co-host of Usapang Econ Podcast.

His first book, False Nostalgia: The Marcos “Golden Age” Myths and How to Debunk Them, was published by Ateneo de Manila University Press in February 2023. His second book, Twin Plagues: How Duterte and COVID-19 Wrecked the Philippine Economy, was published by Penguin Random House SEA in June 2026. Follow him on Instagram (@jcpunongbayan).

Below are In This Economy pieces you may have missed:

Click here for other In This Economy articles.

Similar Posts

  • |

    Pakistan’s auto tax policy sparks industry divide over EV incentives

    LAHORE: Pakistan’s automobile industry is witnessing growing divisions over the government’s taxation policy for vehicles, with local manufacturers warning that the current framework unfairly benefits expensive imported and premium new energy vehicles (NEVs) while placing a heavier tax burden on affordable cars purchased by middle-income families. The controversy has intensified following the government’s decision to introduce a range of fiscal incentives for new energy vehicles, including battery electric vehicles (BEVs), plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) and range-extended electric vehicles (REEVs). While the policy is designed to accelerate Pakistan’s transition towards cleaner transportation and reduce reliance on fossil fuels, established local assemblers argue that the incentives are skewed in favour of luxury vehicle buyers instead of promoting affordable green mobility. Industry representatives say the taxation gap between conventional locally assembled vehicles and premium electric vehicles has widened considerably, raising concerns over fairness, competitiveness and the long-term sustainability of Pakistan’s domestic automobile manufacturing sector. According to industry estimates, a locally assembled Suzuki Alto—one of the country’s most affordable passenger vehicles priced at around Rs3 million—bears nearly Rs550,000 in taxes, including sales tax, federal excise duty (FED) and the recently introduced New Energy Vehicle (NEV) levy. In contrast, a premium REEV costing close to Rs10 million reportedly attracts sales tax of only around Rs100,000 while remaining exempt from both the federal excise duty and the NEV levy. The tax disparity has triggered criticism from domestic manufacturers, who argue that the current structure effectively penalises middle-income consumers while offering generous incentives to buyers of high-end imported vehicles. Local Assemblers Raise Concerns Pak Suzuki Motor Company spokesperson Ikhlaq Virk said the taxation framework has created an uneven competitive environment that disadvantages affordable vehicles widely used by Pakistani families. He said entry-level models such as the Alto and Cultus serve as essential transportation for the country’s middle class but receive no meaningful tax relief despite their affordability. Virk further noted that premium hybrid and electric vehicles, valued at nearly Rs10 million or more, continue to enjoy substantial concessions under the government’s clean mobility policy. He also pointed to reports suggesting that the sales tax on certain plug-in hybrid and hybrid electric vehicles could be reduced from 25 percent to 18 percent after changes introduced through the Finance Bill, arguing that such relief would primarily benefit affluent consumers rather than encouraging mass-market adoption. IMF Programme Adds Complexity The debate comes at a time when Pakistan remains under an International Monetary Fund (IMF) programme, which has required the government to increase tax revenues, rationalise subsidies and implement fiscal reforms to stabilise the economy. Against this backdrop, industry stakeholders argue that taxation policies should strike a balance between environmental objectives and economic realities, ensuring that clean energy initiatives do not disproportionately favour a small segment of wealthy consumers. The discussion has also reopened a broader policy debate over whether Pakistan’s green mobility strategy should focus solely on reducing emissions or also safeguard domestic manufacturing, employment and industrial investment. Analysts Call for Balanced Incentives Automobile industry experts believe Pakistan’s transition towards cleaner transportation is necessary, but they stress that government incentives should encourage widespread adoption instead of being concentrated in the luxury vehicle segment. Yousuf M. Farooq, Director Research at Chase Securities, said environmental goals should be pursued alongside industrial development and economic sustainability. He noted that while encouraging cleaner transportation is an important national objective, incentive programmes should also consider vehicle affordability, localisation, environmental benefits and the contribution of manufacturers to Pakistan’s economy. Farooq emphasised the need for a consistent taxation framework across all vehicle categories, including conventional internal combustion engine vehicles, hybrids, plug-in hybrids and range-extended electric vehicles, while maintaining adequate protection for local assembly operations and the domestic auto parts industry. He added that environmental incentives should not undermine the competitiveness of local manufacturers or threaten employment generated by Pakistan’s automotive sector. Local Industry Fears Investment Slowdown Pakistan’s automobile industry has invested billions of rupees over the past three decades in assembly plants, localisation programmes and vendor development. The sector supports hundreds of component manufacturers and provides employment to thousands of skilled workers across the country. Industry stakeholders warn that if imported premium electric vehicles continue to enjoy significantly lower taxation than locally assembled conventional vehicles, future investment in domestic manufacturing could slow, weakening Pakistan’s automotive supply chain and localisation efforts. Manufacturers believe a prolonged imbalance may discourage further expansion by existing assemblers while affecting the viability of local parts suppliers that have developed alongside the country’s automobile industry. Government’s Green Mobility Vision Supporters of the government’s policy argue that Pakistan cannot afford to lag behind the global transition towards electric mobility. Many countries are offering tax incentives, subsidies and policy support to encourage electric vehicle adoption, reduce dependence on imported petroleum products and lower carbon emissions. Pakistan, which spends billions of dollars annually on fuel imports, could also benefit from increased electrification of its transport sector by reducing its import bill and improving environmental sustainability over the long term. However, industry observers believe the core issue is not whether electric vehicles deserve policy support but how those incentives should be structured.

  • |

    Senate questions $387 million ADB water project allocation

    Islamabad: The Senate Standing Committee on Economic Affairs raised serious concerns over inequities in the allocation of foreign funded development projects across Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, revealing that flood affected districts have been largely bypassed while relatively unaffected areas received more infrastructure funding. The meeting, chaired by Senator Saifullah Abro, highlighted discrepancies in road and irrigation project implementation, questioned external pressures from international lenders, and warned that mismanagement could exacerbate Pakistan’s mounting national debt, which has soared from Rs40 trillion in 2022 to approximately Rs90 trillion today. During the session, committee members expressed alarm that districts most devastated by floods, including Upper Dir, Lower Dir, and Chitral, received fewer road reconstruction projects compared to Mardan, which saw 16 roads built despite experiencing minimal flood damage. In Dir, only 12 kilometres of road were reconstructed despite extensive damage. Similarly, nine roads were completed in Peshawar, a city that did not face flood related destruction. Senator Rubina Khalid termed this “inequitable allocation” and warned that such disparities hinder balanced regional development, while Senator Waqar Mehdi questioned whether donor agencies were being misled about project priorities. The committee also scrutinized the financial management of foreign funded schemes. Officials reported that 770 kilometres of roads were constructed at a total cost of Rs69 billion, with an additional Rs43 billion spent on bridges and related infrastructure. Each kilometre of road cost approximately Rs70 million. The Asian Development Bank supported KP Road Rehabilitation and Upgradation Project, covering 249.5 kilometres, was completed ahead of schedule at a cost of $146.2 million. Similarly, $387 million in ADB funded water projects and $295 million from the World Bank are being implemented in irrigation and flood protection schemes across Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. While project completion rates were impressive, reaching 100 percent for most schemes, the committee raised concerns about undue interference by external entities. Chairman Saifullah Abro questioned the role of the World Bank’s local representative in the Sindh Water and Agriculture Transmission Project, noting that the lender should only finance and recover loans, not dictate project execution. He estimated that resisting unnecessary external pressures could save Sindh around Rs14 billion and cited previous instances where committee intervention prevented $890 million in unwarranted costs on the Peshawar Torkham project. The committee underscored the need for transparency, calling for a clear distinction between grants and loans and insisting that provincial authorities ensure funds are spent only for their approved purposes. Senator Hidayatullah stressed that provinces receiving loans must allocate them to the intended projects to benefit local populations, while Senator Kamil Ali Agha urged planning for infrastructure that accounts for emerging climatic challenges, including improved stormwater drainage systems. Senator Abro also criticized the concentration of contracts among a few large construction firms in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, directing officials to provide detailed information on the Notice Inviting Tender process to ensure competitive bidding. While district road projects were reportedly nearing completion across Swat, Peshawar, Mardan, and Nowshera, the committee emphasized that project selection criteria and equitable distribution remained critical issues. The meeting concluded with a clear warning that Pakistan’s growing reliance on foreign loans, coupled with misallocated resources, could have serious economic repercussions. Senator Abro noted that while international assistance is vital, the country must maintain ownership and control over project execution to ensure accountability, prevent cost escalation, and deliver tangible benefits to the communities most in need.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *