meta rejects claims
| | | |

Meta rejects claims it sought to hook children to Facebook, Instagram as landmark trial begins

Meta Platforms rejected accusations by US states that it intentionally sought to addict children to its Facebook and Instagram platforms in pursuit of profit, at the start of a trial that could reshape some of the most popular apps on the planet.

A bipartisan group of 29 US states is suing Meta, seeking potentially tens or hundreds of billions of dollars in penalties and changes to how Meta does business.


Meta rejects claims it sought to hook children to Facebook, Instagram as landmark trial begins

Four lead states — California, Colorado, Kentucky and New Jersey — accused Meta of designing Facebook and Instagram to hook young users, fueling anxiety, depression and even suicide, and misleading consumers about the platforms’ safety. All 29 states accused Meta of violating federal law by improperly collecting and using children’s personal data.

Must Read

US court rules Meta, others must face thousands of social media addiction suits


US court rules Meta, others must face thousands of social media addiction suits

Experts have called the trial in the Oakland, California, federal court, which began with opening statements on Tuesday, August 18, the biggest legal test yet of social media’s effects on young users.

Meta and other social media companies including Snap, TikTok parent ByteDance, and YouTube parent Alphabet, face thousands of lawsuits by states, municipalities, school districts and individuals over whether their products harm young users.

Megan O’Neill, a deputy attorney general for California, told the eight-person jury that Meta’s business model was to “hook the users, hold them for as long as they can, harvest their data, and then hide the truth from the public.”

“It worked especially well for kids,” O’Neill added. “Meta needed kids, and it needed to reassure the people who cared about those kids that the kids are safe.”

Meta’s lawyer Paul Schmidt said there was “no dispute” that some social media users face struggles, but that research showed no clear link between adolescents’ social media use and a lack of well-being.

He also said Mark Zuckerberg, Meta’s co-founder and CEO, shared the company’s desire to improve its services, and not make them dangerous.

“They don’t believe they’re going to do well if people don’t like their service,” Schmidt said.

Judge could order changes to Facebook, Instagram

Jurors are expected to issue an advisory verdict, but US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers will determine Meta’s liability.

If she finds Meta liable, Rogers could impose civil penalties and order changes to Facebook and Instagram.

Meta has said penalties could be as high as $1.4 trillion, close to the Menlo Park, California-based company’s market value.

Attorneys general said at a hearing last week the amount could be closer to $200 billion, or about three years of after-tax profit for Meta.

California, Colorado, Kentucky and New Jersey also want Meta to overhaul Facebook and Instagram, including by eliminating likes and the infinite scroll that encourages views of new posts, setting time limits for younger users, and enforcing restrictions to keep children under 13 offline.

After opening arguments concluded, former Meta safety engineer Arturo Bejar began testifying as the states’ first witness.

Bejar has long said Meta knew its child safety tools did not work, and has testified against the company in four trials.

Meta sought to block his testimony, allegedly for deleting Signal messages with former employees, but Rogers rejected what she considered a long-shot bid to eliminate a key witness.

Bejar told jurors that “move fast and break things” was a mantra at Meta, which took a “don’t ask, don’t tell” approach to monitoring whether children under 13 were online.

“Many products were shipped into the world,” such as Reels short-form videos, “and safety was not a consideration in how it was initially deployed,” Bejar said.

Zuckerberg and Instagram chief Adam Mosseri are also expected to testify. The trial is scheduled to last six weeks.

Meta shares traded lower most of Tuesday and closed down 4.4% at $543.67.

Critics protest outside

O’Neill said the states were not trying to put Meta out of business, saying social media “has some benefits for some people.”

But she said Meta exploited children by researching how their brains work and react to online stimuli, and tracking their interactions on its apps.

She said an internal email sent to Mosseri said “teen time spent” was the goal, and said Meta employees viewed Instagram as a “drug” and themselves as “pushers.”

“Meta found the younger a kid is when they start using the app, the better,” O’Neill said.

Schmidt acknowledged that employees might use “loose” language in private, but said Meta’s products were not addictive, and that jurors would hear what the employee who called Instagram a drug did to make it safer.

Some critics of Meta spoke outside the courthouse as the trial began.

Among them was Mary Rodee, who said her 15-year-old son Riley Basford died by suicide in 2021 after being victimized by a predator on Facebook.

“They call it spontaneous suicide,” she said. “I call it what it was, the predictable outcome of a system that protects corporations instead of children.”

The lawsuit began in 2023, two years after whistleblower Frances Haugen told a U.S. Senate committee that Meta knew its products were unsafe for children and knew how to make them safe, but did nothing in order to pursue higher profits.

In March, a Los Angeles jury ordered Meta and Google to pay $6 million to a 20-year-old woman who said she became addicted to Instagram and YouTube as a child.

Earlier this month, a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $567 million to address teenagers’ mental health after that state’s attorney general called its platforms a public nuisance.

Tennessee’s attorney general is also suing Meta, raising similar claims about Instagram. That case is on trial in Nashville. – Rappler.com

Similar Posts

  • | |

    Police officer took his own life after leading dou…

    An investigation has found that a police officer who died by suicide in May carried out a series of rapes and attempted murders targeting women over a period of at least fourteen years while serving as an officer. PC Alan Greer’s earliest known victim was a woman he raped inside her own home in Glasgow in 2012, shortly after she had contacted police to report an unrelated crime. The woman came forward late last year to report the assault, a disclosure that triggered one of the largest anti corruption investigations in Police Scotland’s history. Detectives have since identified eight additional victims, five of them sex workers who were attacked while Greer was off duty. Investigators have also established that Greer paid for sex from hundreds of women throughout his career and expect further victims to come forward as the inquiry continues. Assistant Chief Constable Lynn Ratcliff, who is leading the investigation, described the findings as deeply disturbing. She said the officer had abused his position of authority by returning to target a woman he had first encountered through his police duties. Ratcliff said the woman’s decision to come forward and speak with investigators became the catalyst that launched the wider inquiry. Her confirmation of the investigation followed months of reporting into Greer’s conduct. A source close to the case said the scale and nature of the case draws comparisons to the conviction of Wayne Couzens, the London police officer sentenced for the rape and murder of Sarah Everard five years ago, suggesting the Greer case could represent a similarly significant reckoning for Police Scotland. Greer was born in Australia in 1978 and moved to the United Kingdom at age six. He joined Strathclyde Police in 2009, and continued serving after the force merged into Police Scotland in 2013, building what appeared to be an unblemished seventeen year career. He initially worked as a uniformed response officer in Glasgow before moving into an officer safety training role based in Coatbridge around 2016, a position that involved training probationary officers and refreshing the skills of more experienced colleagues. Greer was 47 years old when he died in May, and was married with a child. Those close to him, including his family and police colleagues, are understood to have had no knowledge of his pattern of violence. Senior officers have said there were no clear opportunities that would have allowed the force to identify his offending earlier. The investigation traces back to a woman in her late thirties who walked into a Glasgow police station late last year to report the assault. She described how, in 2012, she had called officers to her home after a disturbance, only for one of the responding officers to later attack her. Cases involving police officers who abuse their positions of trust to target victims, particularly vulnerable women and sex workers, have prompted broader scrutiny of vetting and oversight procedures within UK police forces in recent years. Investigations of this kind often expose gaps in how forces monitor off duty conduct and respond to complaints against serving officers, and they tend to renew public pressure for independent oversight mechanisms capable of identifying patterns of abuse before they escalate over many years. The investigation into Greer’s offending remains active, and Police Scotland has said it anticipates identifying more victims as the inquiry proceeds.

  • |

    Yemen’s Ansarullah movement claims attack on two Saudi oil tankers

    Yemen’s Houthi-aligned Ansarullah movement has claimed responsibility for targeting two Saudi oil tankers in the Red Sea, alleging that the vessels violated a newly declared naval blockade imposed by the group against Saudi Arabia. According to Saudi state media, a Saudi-owned tanker, identified as the Encelia, was struck while transiting the Red Sea, resulting in a fire at the vessel’s bow. Saudi authorities confirmed that the crew managed to contain the fire safely and that no casualties or environmental damage were reported. The United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO) and maritime security group Vanguard had earlier reported a missile strike on a tanker approximately 70 nautical miles southwest of Al Shuqaiq, Saudi Arabia. The vessel’s captain reported that the fire was caused by an incoming projectile. The strike follows Ansarullah’s formal declaration of a naval blockade targeting vessels bound for or operating near Saudi ports. An Ansarullah spokesperson stated that the blockade was enacted in direct response to the siege on Yemen, specifically citing the ongoing closure of Sanaa International Airport, and warned that maritime restrictions would match those imposed on Yemeni airspace.

  • | | |

    Israeli rabbi sparks outrage with denial of Palest…

    JERUSALEM: An Israeli chief rabbi has sparked widespread controversy after reportedly denying the existence of the Palestinian people and asserting that Gaza and the occupied West Bank belong exclusively to Jews. Chief Rabbi David Yosef was quoted as saying that there was no Palestinian nation in the past and that Palestinians have no rights to the land. His reported remarks have drawn attention amid the continuing conflict in Gaza and growing international concern over the humanitarian situation. Yosef also reportedly claimed that Gaza and cities in the West Bank belong to Jews and suggested that Gaza would eventually be destroyed and populated by Jewish people. The comments come as Israeli military operations in Gaza continue, with Palestinian officials reporting further deaths and injuries. The conflict has caused widespread destruction, displacement and a severe humanitarian crisis. The remarks have also renewed scrutiny of developments in the occupied West Bank, where tensions between Palestinians and Israeli settlers remain high. According to reports, Palestinian residents and farmers in areas including Hebron have faced incidents involving Israeli settlers. One reported incident involved a Palestinian farmer’s donkey being tied to a vehicle and dragged, resulting in the animal’s death. The latest statements have added to concerns over rhetoric surrounding the future of Palestinian territories. Palestinian leaders and rights advocates have long opposed attempts to deny Palestinian national identity or rights, while the international community continues to debate the political future of Gaza and the West Bank. The comments also come as diplomatic efforts over the conflict remain under intense scrutiny. The humanitarian situation in Gaza has made the question of civilian protection and the future governance of the territory increasingly urgent. For Palestinians, statements denying their existence or connection to their homeland are particularly sensitive, coming after decades of conflict, displacement and political uncertainty. The controversy surrounding Yosef’s remarks is therefore likely to fuel further debate over Palestinian rights, Israeli settlement policies and the prospects for a lasting political settlement in the region.

  • |

    UN General Assembly extends rights chief’s term despite US objections

    The United Nations General Assembly has voted by a large majority to grant UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Turk a second four-year term, despite strong opposition from the United States, Russia and Israel. The decision came after member states rejected calls to delay the vote and instead backed Secretary General Antonio Guterres’ recommendation to keep Turk in office when his current term expires in October. The 193-member General Assembly approved the extension with 144 countries voting in favor, while 10 countries voted against the proposal and 13 abstained. Before the final vote, member states also rejected a Russian proposal that would have extended Turk’s mandate only until the end of 2026 instead of giving him another full term. Turk has become one of the UN’s most outspoken voices on global human rights issues during his first term. He has repeatedly criticized Russia’s military actions in Ukraine and raised concerns over Israel’s conduct during the conflict in Gaza. He has also called for investigations into deaths that occurred in US immigration detention facilities. His willingness to publicly challenge major world powers has drawn criticism from several governments, including Washington, Moscow and Tel Aviv. The vote reflected growing tensions between the United States and the United Nations under President Donald Trump’s administration. In recent years, Washington has reduced financial support for several UN agencies and withdrawn from multiple international bodies. The administration has argued that reforms are needed before the United States continues its current level of participation and funding. Before the vote, the United States urged the General Assembly to postpone the decision for further consultations. US Representative for UN Management and Reform Jeff Bartos warned member states that approving the appointment without additional debate would damage the organization’s credibility. He said the United States would review its future engagement, participation and financial contributions if the assembly ignored its concerns. The US State Department also criticized the process before the vote, describing it as rushed and lacking sufficient discussion among member countries. Officials argued that member states should have been given more time to examine the proposal before making a final decision. Despite those objections, a broad coalition of countries supported Turk’s reappointment. The European Union strongly backed the extension, along with many African and Latin American nations. China also voted in favor of the proposal, helping secure the overwhelming majority needed for approval. UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres nominated Turk for a second term after working closely with him for several years. Guterres, who is due to leave office in December, praised Turk’s experience and commitment to defending human rights around the world. Turk, an Austrian lawyer, has spent decades working within the United Nations in senior positions based in Geneva as well as field assignments, including Kosovo. With the latest vote, he will become the first UN High Commissioner for Human Rights to serve two full four-year terms since the position was established in 1993. Human Rights Watch welcomed the decision, arguing that strong and independent leadership is needed at a time when democratic freedoms are facing increasing pressure in many parts of the world. The organization’s UN director, Louis Charbonneau, said the global human rights situation requires a commissioner willing to challenge powerful governments regardless of their influence. Russia and Israel strongly criticized the outcome after the vote. Russia’s deputy ambassador to the United Nations accused Turk of showing political bias and making unfair allegations against Moscow. Israeli officials also condemned the decision, describing it as a mistake and arguing that the appointment should have been left to the next UN secretary general rather than being decided during Guterres’ final months in office. The result highlights the continuing divisions within the United Nations over human rights issues and the organization’s relationship with some of its most influential member states. While a large majority of countries supported Turk’s leadership, the objections raised by the United States, Russia and Israel suggest that debates over the UN’s role and future direction are likely to continue throughout his second term.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *