nccia under fire
|

NCCIA under fire over social media figures, PECA cases and newspaper column complaint

Islamabad: A controversy has erupted over the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) after a Senate committee questioned differences in social media statistics, delays in transferring PECA cases and the registration of complaints linked to a newspaper column.

The Senate Standing Committee on Information and Broadcasting has sought answers from NCCIA over claims that figures shared earlier with lawmakers were later described as incorrect by its own officials. The committee questioned how NCCIA could provide one set of figures before the Senate and later have its officials reportedly distance themselves from those numbers.

The dispute mainly focused on claims about fake social media accounts and content removal requests. Earlier figures suggested that around 20 percent of social media accounts were fake, but questions were raised after officials allegedly suggested that the number was much lower.

The committee also questioned claims that 83 percent of content removal requests received responses from social media companies. Officials explained that a response from platforms does not always mean the request was accepted or action was taken. They said some requests were accepted while others were rejected, but companies provided replies.

During the meeting, NCCIA officials defended the figures and said the data was publicly available online. They said the 83.64 percent response figure related to Meta was available through official reports and could be verified by anyone through the internet.

Officials said if journalists had checked the available reports before publishing news, the confusion could have been avoided. They also explained that Pakistan’s response rate was compared with India’s figures, noting that both countries’ data was available online.

Another major issue discussed was the transfer of cases under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA). The committee questioned why provinces had not transferred all relevant cases to NCCIA after PECA powers were shifted. NCCIA officials informed the committee that hundreds of cases existed across Pakistan.

According to the briefing, Islamabad had 19 cases, Punjab had 268, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had 47, Balochistan had 7, Sindh had 21, Azad Jammu and Kashmir had 10, while Gilgit Baltistan had none. The total number mentioned was 372 cases across Pakistan.

Officials said only nine cases from Sindh Police had so far been transferred to NCCIA, while many others were still pending. Committee members questioned why cases already before courts or under trial were not being transferred.

They said earlier instructions had been issued to provincial authorities to move investigation stage cases to NCCIA, but the orders had not been fully followed. The committee decided to again contact provincial police chiefs and legal authorities to ask why transfers were delayed.

The most sensitive discussion came a complaint related to journalist Toufeeq Butt’s column published in Daily Nai Baat. The column titled “Bero Corrupts” became controversial after the Pakistan Administrative Services Association filed a complaint.

The complainant argued that the term used in the article was insulting and damaging to the reputation of civil servants. NCCIA officials clarified that no case had been registered against the writer.

They said only a complaint was received and an inquiry process started to hear both sides. Toufeeq Butt was issued notices to provide his explanation, but officials said he did not appear after receiving two notices.

The committee debated whether NCCIA should handle newspaper content or if such matters should go to press related institutions. Members warned that allowing every complaint against newspapers and journalists to reach the NCCIA could create a flood of cases.

They pointed out that newspapers are regulated by the Press Council while television is handled by PEMRA. Some members argued that asking for an explanation differed from taking legal action. They said every person has the right to present their side before any decision is made.

Others warned that using cybercrime laws for newspaper related matters could open a new door for pressure against journalists. Chairman directed NCCIA to refer both the complaint and the complainant to the Press Council of Pakistan, being the appropriate forum to examine the published column and decide the matter.

Similar Posts

  • |

    India’s top court orders release of minors amid exam protests

    NEW DELHI: India’s Supreme Court has ordered authorities to release minors detained during protests over examination paper leaks and directed officials to preserve evidence linked to allegations of excessive police force. Chief Justice Surya Kant reportedly issued the interim directions while hearing petitions filed by student protesters and activists. The petitions accuse police and paramilitary personnel of using excessive force, including baton charges and other crowd-control measures, against demonstrators. The court also directed authorities to preserve all available surveillance material from the protests. This includes CCTV recordings, drone footage and body-camera video. Officials were further told to protect the personal and digital information of protesters and ensure that it is not publicly disclosed. The court reportedly barred authorities from taking coercive action against protesters while the matter remains under consideration. Justice Kant stressed the importance of an independent investigation into allegations of mistreatment. He said accountability must be established if wrongdoing occurred. The government has defended the security forces’ response, describing the measures as necessary for crowd control. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the court that around 250 police officers were also injured during the unrest. He reportedly said the government had no objection to an investigation into allegations involving protesters. The protests erupted after question papers for a national medical college entrance examination were leaked. The controversy triggered demonstrations in New Delhi and several other parts of India. Protesters demanded reforms to the examination system, withdrawal of cases against demonstrators and compensation for families of students who died by suicide following the controversy. The demonstrations ended after the education minister resigned and the government agreed to several demands raised by the protesters. Meanwhile, the Indian government has proposed tougher penalties for examination paper leaks. Under the proposed amendments, the maximum prison sentence could be increased to 10 years, while fines could rise to more than $1 million. The government says the proposed changes are intended to strengthen the examination system, speed up legal proceedings and restore confidence among students and young people. The issue has also created political tension in parliament. Opposition lawmakers have repeatedly raised concerns about the police response to the protests and demanded accountability. In several cities, clashes between demonstrators and security personnel led to tear gas and baton charges. Authorities also suspended a police officer in an eastern state after he allegedly fired rounds into the air while attempting to disperse student protesters. Concerns have additionally emerged over the use of artificial intelligence-powered surveillance during demonstrations. Activists have questioned the deployment of police surveillance equipment capable of providing wide-area monitoring of protest gatherings. A protest group that helped lead the movement has claimed that hundreds of students were arrested in different states. However, the figure has not been independently verified.

  • | | |

    NCCIA Punjab arrests 4 in cybercrime crackdown

    LAHORE: The National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) Punjab has arrested four suspects during coordinated enforcement operations conducted in Lahore and Multan as part of its ongoing campaign against serious cybercrime. The cases involve the alleged trafficking of Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM), online harassment of a minor, cyber blackmail, and the unlawful sharing of intimate digital content. In the most significant operation, NCCIA investigators in Lahore arrested a suspect accused of possessing and distributing Child Sexual Abuse Material, including illegal content depicting the sexual abuse of children and animals. According to investigators, the material was allegedly circulated through online platforms for commercial purposes. Mobile devices and other electronic evidence were seized during the operation and have been sent for forensic examination. Investigators are working to identify additional victims, trace the origin of the material, and determine whether other individuals were involved. Child Sexual Abuse Material is regarded worldwide as one of the most serious forms of online criminal exploitation. The production, possession, distribution, or sale of such material is treated as a major criminal offence by law enforcement agencies across the globe. In a separate operation in Lahore, NCCIA officers arrested another suspect accused of using social media to harass and intimidate a minor. Investigators collected digital evidence that will form part of the continuing criminal investigation. In Multan, two additional suspects were taken into custody in separate investigations involving the alleged blackmail of female victims through private photographs and videos. Investigators allege that the suspects used WhatsApp and other online platforms to issue threats and unlawfully share sensitive digital content. Electronic devices and other evidentiary material were recovered during the operations, and forensic analysis is continuing. Director NCCIA Punjab Muhammad Ali Wasim said the agency will continue to pursue individuals involved in child exploitation, cyber extortion, online harassment, and related offences. He said crimes involving Child Sexual Abuse Material demand an immediate and uncompromising law enforcement response because of the serious harm they inflict on children. He also encouraged parents and members of the public to remain alert, supervise children’s online activity, and promptly report suspected cybercrime so that timely legal action can be taken.

  • |

    Khairpur Lithium discovery boosts industry plans

    Pakistan has taken a significant step towards developing its first indigenous lithium industry after the discovery of high-quality lithium reserves in Sindh’s Khairpur districtPakistan has taken a significant step towards developing its first indigenous lithium industry after the discovery of high-quality lithium reserves in Sindh’s Khairpur district, opening new opportunities for the country’s mineral and industrial sectors. In a major development, the Oil and Gas Development Company Limited (OGDCL) has entered into a strategic agreement with the Pakistan Institute of Nuclear Science and Technology (PINSTECH) to jointly develop technology for the commercial-scale extraction of lithium from geothermal brine. The collaboration follows the successful identification of high-grade lithium in samples collected from a well located in Khairpur. The discovery is being viewed as a breakthrough that could reduce Pakistan’s dependence on imported lithium while creating new investment and industrial opportunities. Under the agreement, OGDCL and PINSTECH will work together to design and develop advanced extraction technologies capable of recovering lithium efficiently from geothermal brine. The initiative is expected to pave the way for the establishment of a domestic lithium processing industry, supporting the growing global demand for the critical mineral. Lithium is considered one of the world’s most valuable strategic minerals due to its extensive use in rechargeable batteries for electric vehicles, mobile phones, laptops, renewable energy storage systems, and other advanced technologies. As global demand continues to rise, countries with commercially viable lithium resources are increasingly focusing on developing local production capabilities. Officials believe the partnership will strengthen Pakistan’s mineral exploration efforts, promote scientific research, and encourage technology-driven industrial development. The project is also expected to contribute to economic growth by attracting investment, generating employment opportunities, and enhancing the country’s position in the global critical minerals market.

  • | | | |

    Pakistan’s blasphemy cases hit record low

    Pakistan has witnessed a significant decline in registered blasphemy cases this year following a crackdown on hardline religious groups, signalling what analysts describe as a major shift in the country’s security policy. According to figures cited by the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), only 13 blasphemy cases have been registered so far in 2026, marking a fall of nearly two-thirds compared with the same period in recent years. Data from conflict monitoring organisation ACLED also indicates that only one blasphemy-related riot or attack has occurred over the past year, compared with an annual average of more than seven incidents between 2021 and 2024. The decline comes after security agencies intensified action against several extremist organisations accused of exploiting blasphemy allegations to incite violence. Officials familiar with the matter said the campaign has included arrests of key figures, restrictions on organisational activities, freezing of financial assets and tighter monitoring of religious gatherings. The change was evident during an incident in Karachi last month, where allegations of blasphemy against a Christian family drew a large crowd. Police officers intervened before the situation turned violent and persuaded protesters to disperse peacefully. Authorities later determined that the accusations against the family were baseless, allowing them to be moved to safety without further harm. Analysts believe the reduced presence of organised extremist groups has played a key role in preventing mob violence that has historically followed blasphemy accusations. Pakistan has witnessed around 90 blasphemy-related lynchings since 1990, with many incidents beginning after rumours spread through local communities. Security experts say the military leadership has adopted a tougher stance against groups previously accused of using religious sentiments to mobilise supporters and pressure governments. They argue the policy shift is linked to broader efforts to strengthen Pakistan’s international image, attract foreign investment and improve relations with Western countries while tackling growing security threats at home. Officials also believe that curbing religious extremism is necessary to address worsening militancy in Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where insurgent violence continues to challenge the state’s authority. Some analysts say extremist organisations and militant groups have historically drawn support from similar networks of radicalised youth. The country’s largest hardline religious party, Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan (TLP), was banned last year after authorities concluded that its activities posed a threat to public order and Pakistan’s international reputation. Government measures reportedly included detaining senior leaders, sealing offices and restricting financial operations. The party has rejected the ban, calling it unconstitutional. Despite the decline in violence, observers caution that extremist ideology remains deeply rooted in parts of society. Human rights advocates say minority communities, including Christians, Ahmadis and Shia Muslims, continue to live under the fear of false accusations, as Pakistan’s blasphemy laws remain in force and carry the death penalty. Security analysts also warn that sustained enforcement will be necessary to prevent banned organisations from regrouping or resurfacing under new identities. They argue that long-term success will depend on consistent policies rather than temporary crackdowns.

  • | | | |

    Malala expresses grief over Swat attack, calls for…

    Nobel Peace Prize laureate Malala Yousafzai has expressed deep sorrow over the recent suicide attack in Swat, urging authorities to ensure the protection of civilians and prevent the region from falling back into violence. In a statement, Malala said she was deeply saddened by the suicide bombing in her hometown of Swat, describing the incident as a tragic reminder of the suffering the region has endured over the years. She noted that the attack claimed the lives of more than a dozen people, including police personnel, and said she could understand the pain and grief being experienced by the families of the victims. Malala extended her heartfelt condolences to those who lost their loved ones and prayed for strength and patience for the bereaved families. She also expressed hope for the speedy recovery of those injured in the attack. Emphasising the importance of public safety, Malala called on the authorities to take all necessary measures to protect the lives and property of citizens and ensure lasting peace and security in the region. Reflecting on Swat’s past, she said the girls of the valley have always dreamed of living in peace, free from fear and violence. She added that her prayers are with the people of Swat and expressed hope that they would never again be forced to live under the shadow of the Taliban. Malala said the people of Swat deserve a peaceful future where children can pursue their education, families can live without fear, and communities can rebuild their lives in a secure environment.

  • | |

    Ishaq Dar holds telephone conversation with Saudi …

      Pakistan’s Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar held a telephone conversation with Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan, during which the two sides discussed matters of mutual interest as well as regional and international developments. According to a statement issued by the Foreign Office spokesperson, the two foreign ministers exchanged views on a range of issues of common interest during the telephone call. The conversation focused on strengthening bilateral relations between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia and maintaining close coordination on important regional and global matters. During the discussion, Ishaq Dar and his Saudi counterpart also reviewed the prevailing regional situation. The two ministers exchanged views on developments affecting peace and stability in the region and discussed the importance of continued diplomatic engagement and cooperation among countries. The foreign ministers also discussed multilateral cooperation and matters related to international forums. They emphasised the importance of maintaining coordination between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia on issues of common concern at both regional and international levels. According to the Foreign Office, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia reaffirmed their commitment to maintaining close contact and cooperation through bilateral and multilateral platforms. The telephone conversation comes as Pakistan and Saudi Arabia continue to maintain close and longstanding relations based on political, economic, diplomatic and people-to-people ties. Both countries regularly consult each other on regional developments and issues of mutual interest. Pakistan considers Saudi Arabia an important partner in the Middle East, while Saudi Arabia has maintained close relations with Pakistan over the years. High-level exchanges between officials from both countries have remained an important feature of their bilateral relationship. The discussion between Ishaq Dar and Prince Faisal bin Farhan also reflects the importance attached by both countries to regular diplomatic consultations. Such contacts provide an opportunity for the two sides to exchange assessments of emerging regional developments and coordinate their positions on matters discussed at international forums. Multilateral cooperation was another important aspect of the conversation. Pakistan and Saudi Arabia have worked together at various international platforms and have frequently supported closer coordination on issues affecting the Muslim world and the broader international community. The two ministers also reiterated the importance of continued engagement between their respective governments. By maintaining regular communication, both sides aim to strengthen their strategic partnership and enhance cooperation on matters of mutual interest. The telephone conversation is expected to contribute to ongoing diplomatic efforts to further deepen Pakistan-Saudi Arabia relations. Both countries have repeatedly expressed their desire to expand cooperation across multiple areas and maintain strong institutional and political contacts. The Foreign Office spokesperson did not provide further details about the specific regional issues discussed during the call. However, the reference to the regional situation and multilateral cooperation indicates that the conversation covered broader developments beyond bilateral relations. The reaffirmation of close coordination on bilateral and multilateral platforms demonstrates the continued importance of the relationship between Islamabad and Riyadh. Regular communication between senior officials remains a key mechanism for both countries to exchange views, coordinate diplomatic positions and respond to developments in the region. The latest telephone conversation between Ishaq Dar and Prince Faisal bin Farhan therefore underscores the two countries’ commitment to maintaining close diplomatic engagement and strengthening cooperation at both bilateral and international levels.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *