opinion america8217s boom
| | | | | | |

[OPINION] What America’s AI boom teaches us about scrutinizing Pax Silica

During the past week, I heard one expert argue that Filipinos should give Pax Silica a chance because of its promise of industrialization and economic growth.

It’s a fair argument. The Philippines could use industrialization. We need better jobs, stronger technological capabilities, and a larger role in the global semiconductor and artificial intelligence industries where we currently participate in the lower rungs of assembly, testing and packaging.

But I would disagree with the suggestion that we should tone down the level of scrutiny, especially when this matter — and it’s no small one by geographical measure alone — feels like it’s moving at remarkable speed.

Since I began writing this piece, the Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA) walked back its initial statements on data centers being part of Pax Silica, saying that the site will not host data centers after all, but semiconductor and advanced manufacturing facilities. 

Among other things, it reinforces a broader point: public scrutiny works.

That process should continue, because with the removal of data centers, what happens as well to the initial estimates for energy, water and electricity use? This is still a huge project, data centers or not. 

To appreciate the scale of what is being proposed in Tarlac, consider Meta’s Hyperion project in Louisiana. The AI-related campus spans roughly 3,650 acres and is expected to require about five gigawatts of power. Pax Silica, meanwhile, envisions a 4,000-acre industrial hub with a projected power requirement of around three gigawatts.

The comparison is not meant to suggest the two projects are identical. Rather, it illustrates the sheer scale of AI-related industrial infrastructure now being contemplated.

Whether that electricity ultimately powers semiconductor fabrication, mineral processing, or artificial intelligence infrastructure, Pax Silica will permanently reshape part of Tarlac’s landscape. 

If we needed any more reason to scrutinize the proposal, we only need to revisit what has happened in the United States.

Over the past few days, I reviewed investigative video reports such as those by Business Insider, PBS, and More Perfect Union documenting US communities already living beside large-scale AI infrastructure and the experts studying its impacts.

What’s striking is that many of the questions now being asked about Pax Silica are the same questions Americans are asking after the AI boom and data center buildout have already begun.

The companies involved are, by now, household names. Amazon, Microsoft, Meta and Google are collectively investing hundreds of billions of dollars to build the computing infrastructure needed to power artificial intelligence. 

Remember, even with the claim now that there will be no data centers in Pax Silica, the whole project is still tied to a proposed AI value chain led by the US — and AI, no matter where we sit on that chain, is ultimately a power- and resource-hungry creation.

There are lessons to be learned from how Americans are experiencing this AI expansion. 

In the More Perfect Union investigation, one New Jersey resident only discovered something was happening after noticing her electric bill had climbed despite using less electricity.

“I started asking my neighbors, is your bill also going up? And they had no idea that this was happening.”

Digging deeper, the journalists found that many agreements between utilities and technology companies remained hidden from public view. As one expert put it, “the deals between tech companies and utilities are typically hidden from the public,” making it difficult for residents to understand who ultimately pays for the infrastructure needed to support AI.

Reporting by The New York Times on Meta’s Hyperion project in Louisiana described how confidential negotiations with local officials became a flashpoint in the debate over transparency, concluding that the project “could be a blueprint for other companies intent on avoiding local opposition in order to get massive data centers built fast.”


[OPINION] What America’s AI boom teaches us about scrutinizing Pax Silica

Communities interviewed in Virginia by PBS described living beside facilities operating around the clock. Residents complained about the constant mechanical hum generated by cooling systems, while experts discussed diesel backup generators and proposals for new natural gas-fired power plants built largely to satisfy AI-related electricity demand. Residents also questioned whether they had been meaningfully consulted before projects moved forward.

What’s the point here? These US communities experienced strategies underpinned by secretive deals and what appears to be a lack of deep consultation with affected communities with regards to electricity, water, transparency, and environmental safeguards. These households are left trying to adjust after the fact. 

Energy should remain a key subject in future discussions. 

Pax Silica’s plans include a 500-megawatt solar farm alongside a proposed 1.2-gigawatt liquefied natural gas (LNG) power plant. LNG burns cleaner than coal but remains a fossil fuel. It is not a renewable energy source, raising legitimate questions about the project’s long-term sustainability and carbon footprint.

As we’ve seen in Capas, Tarlac residents have expressed concerns over consultations and reports of land acquisition efforts. Those concerns deserve to be addressed fully and transparently.

If these are addressed now with genuine community discussions, and with transparency towards the national audience, we could avoid the sudden stopgap measures happening in some US states now with their moratoriums on data centers. 

In Texas, Governor Greg Abbott recently halted approvals for new data centers seeking connection to the state’s power grid until regulators could audit projects’ electricity demand, water consumption, cooling systems, ownership, and plans to reduce impacts on nearby communities.

New York reached a similar conclusion. Governor Kathy Hochul imposed a one-year moratorium on new hyperscale data centers while regulators develop a framework to assess their effects on electricity demand, water use, water quality, air quality and local communities before additional projects receive environmental permits.

Both continue to pursue AI development. But both have concluded that responsible oversight must keep pace. 

Then there are the jobs. The sudden exclusion of data centers in the Pax Silica plan looks to be an appeasement for critics saying that data centers don’t need to be manned by a lot of individuals, and therefore will not create lasting jobs. 

That was a similar concern in the US where technology companies frequently promote thousands of jobs accompanying new developments. Yet experts cautioned to distinguish between temporary construction employment and permanent operational work. Once built, AI facilities employ far fewer workers than many people imagine because much of the operation is automated.

The United States is already living through the consequences of rapidly expanding AI infrastructure. Its communities have taught us that asking difficult questions after agreements are signed is often too late.

Filipinos — including their representatives in the Senate and the House — still have the opportunity to ask those same questions before pen is put to paper and before concrete is poured.

We should not waste that opportunity, informed by hindsight of the American experience. – Rappler.com

Must Read

Pax Silica: BCDA’s claims and the counterarguments


Pax Silica: BCDA’s claims and the counterarguments

Similar Posts

  • | | |

    Indian cargo ship sinks after suspected attack nea…

    An Indian cargo ship sank in the Red Sea after suffering severe damage in a suspected maritime attack near Yemen’s western coast. The incident, which reportedly involved an explosive-laden boat or unidentified projectile, caused a powerful explosion and fire aboard the vessel before it eventually went down despite rescue efforts. According to international media reports, the cargo ship sustained extensive damage following the blast. Several crew members were injured during the incident, but no fatalities have been reported. The crew immediately initiated emergency procedures and alerted nearby maritime authorities, who responded with rescue operations. Authorities attempted to secure and tow the damaged vessel to a safe location. However, the ship’s condition deteriorated, and it eventually sank in the Red Sea. Medical assistance was provided to injured crew members, while rescue teams ensured the safe evacuation of everyone on board. India’s Ministry of External Affairs stated that the vessel was struck by an unidentified projectile, confirming that the cargo ship later sank. The ministry added that all crew members were safely rescued and no loss of life occurred. As of now, no group has officially claimed responsibility for the attack. However, the incident comes amid heightened security concerns in the Red Sea, where commercial shipping has faced repeated threats in recent months. Several previous attacks on merchant vessels in the region have been claimed by the Iran-backed Houthi movement, although no evidence has yet linked this specific incident to any particular group. The Red Sea has become one of the world’s most sensitive maritime routes due to ongoing regional tensions. Commercial vessels transiting the area have encountered increased security risks, prompting many shipping companies to strengthen safety measures or alter their routes. Recent months have also seen warnings and threats against ships passing through the Bab el-Mandeb Strait, a strategic waterway connecting the Red Sea with the Gulf of Aden. Disruptions in this corridor can have significant consequences for global trade, particularly the transportation of oil, gas, and other essential commodities. The Red Sea and Bab el-Mandeb Strait rank among the world’s busiest shipping lanes, serving as critical links between Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. Any disruption in these waters can affect international supply chains, increase shipping costs, and impact global energy markets. Investigations into the cause of the attack are expected to continue as maritime authorities gather evidence. Meanwhile, shipping companies and governments are closely monitoring the security situation in the region to ensure the safety of commercial vessels and international trade routes.

  • |

    China seeks Houthi assurances for safe passage of oil tankers in Red Sea

    China has held direct discussions with Yemen’s Houthi movement in an effort to secure safe passage for its oil tankers through the southern Red Sea as regional tensions continue to disrupt one of the world’s busiest shipping routes. According to sources familiar with the talks, Beijing wants to ensure that vessels carrying energy supplies to China can travel without being targeted by attacks. The negotiations follow the Houthis’ announcement on July 20 that they would block access to Saudi Arabian ports, expanding their military campaign during the ongoing regional conflict. The group said it would target ships linked to Saudi ports, raising fresh concerns over the safety of commercial shipping and global energy supplies. Sources said China was among the first countries to contact the Houthis directly after the new restrictions were announced. Beijing reportedly requested guarantees that Chinese flagged or China bound tankers would be allowed to pass safely through the Bab el Mandeb Strait, a strategic waterway connecting the Red Sea with the Gulf of Aden. A senior Iranian official was among those who confirmed that the discussions had taken place. China’s priority is to keep crude oil shipments moving from Saudi Arabia’s Red Sea export terminals, particularly the port of Yanbu. Maintaining those supplies has become increasingly important as disruptions around the Strait of Hormuz have reduced the flow of Iranian oil through another key maritime route. Officials believe uninterrupted shipments from Saudi Arabia will help stabilize China’s energy imports during the regional crisis. Shipping data shows that at least four oil tankers carrying Saudi crude for China have successfully passed through the Bab el Mandeb Strait since the Houthis announced their blockade. Industry analysts said Chinese officials coordinated the passage of each vessel individually with the Houthi movement. Sources also indicated that both sides kept Iranian authorities informed throughout the process. At the same time, the Houthis have warned international shipping companies that vessels loading or unloading cargo at Saudi Arabian ports could become military targets. The warning has increased concerns among shipping operators, prompting some vessels to reconsider their planned routes. Two oil supertankers recently altered their journeys because of security fears. The New Champion, which was scheduled to load crude oil at Yanbu, and the New Prime, which was already carrying oil, both turned away from the Bab el Mandeb Strait and returned to open waters in the Gulf of Aden rather than continue through the high risk area. Last week, the Houthis claimed responsibility for missile and drone attacks on two Saudi oil tankers, the Encelia and the Layla. Maritime security officials confirmed that the Encelia had been struck, adding to concerns over the safety of commercial vessels operating in the region. The Red Sea remains one of the world’s most important trade routes because it provides the shortest sea connection between Europe and Asia. A direct journey from Yanbu to Asian markets through the Bab el Mandeb Strait normally takes around 16 days. However, ships that avoid the route and instead travel through the Suez Canal before sailing around the southern tip of Africa face voyages lasting about 50 days, significantly increasing fuel costs and delivery times. Recent shipping data indicates that traffic through the Bab el Mandeb Strait has started to recover slightly despite ongoing security risks. Twenty eight vessels passed through the waterway on Monday, the highest daily total in four days, although traffic remained below the monthly peak recorded earlier in July. Of the 12 ships entering the Red Sea that day, four were oil tankers, showing that energy exports continue despite heightened regional tensions and continuing security concerns.

  • | |

    Iran names battle-tested commanders

      Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi and Parliament Speaker and senior negotiator Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf have defended the country’s latest military appointments, saying the newly selected commanders bring extensive battlefield experience to their new positions. Their comments came after Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei approved the appointment of six senior military commanders to key positions within Iran’s armed forces and the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC). In a post on his Telegram channel, Araghchi said the six commanders had demonstrated their capabilities during the two recent wars imposed on Iran. He described their combat experience as an important factor behind their selection for senior military roles. Ghalibaf also welcomed the appointments, according to a statement carried by Iranian state media. He specifically highlighted General Ahmad Vahidi, saying Vahidi led the IRGC during the recent 40-day war and gained significant operational experience during the conflict. Ghalibaf said the IRGC should continue its mission while drawing on the guidance and direction of Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei. He also stressed the importance of maintaining the force’s capabilities and experience as Iran faces continued regional security challenges. The latest appointments cover some of Iran’s most influential military positions. They include the chief and deputy chief of staff of the Armed Forces, the commander and deputy commander of the IRGC, the commander of the IRGC Navy, and the commander of the Basij paramilitary force. Iranian officials have presented the appointments as part of an effort to place experienced military figures in strategic command positions. The emphasis on commanders with recent battlefield experience also reflects the security pressures Iran has faced during the latest period of regional conflict. The appointments are expected to shape Iran’s military leadership and operational strategy in the period ahead, particularly as Tehran continues to deal with heightened tensions and evolving security challenges across the region.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *