rs19000 billion federal
| |

Rs19,000 billion federal spending sparks Senate de…

Islamabad: A Senate committee has raised serious questions over the functioning of the Council of Common Interests (CCI), warning that constitutional powers given to provinces after the 18th Amendment are being weakened through the revival of federal ministries on devolved subjects.

The Senate Standing Committee on Devolution expressed concern that ministries related to education, health, agriculture, food security, climate change and other provincial matters were recreated at the federal level despite their transfer to provinces under the constitutional process.

The committee questioned why federal institutions were continuing to handle matters that were supposed to belong to provinces after the 18th Constitutional Amendment, calling for a review of the entire system.

The meeting was held at Parliament House, Islamabad, where Senator Zamir Hussain Ghumro presided over the session. Senators Poonjo Bheel and Jan Muhammad Buledi also attended the meeting.

Senator Ghumro said that under the 18th Amendment, a detailed process was completed in 2010 and 2011 to transfer powers from the federal government to provinces.

He explained that notifications issued on December 2, 2010, April 15, 2011, and June 29, 2011 resulted in the devolution of 17 ministries dealing with subjects that were shifted to provincial control.

According to Senator Ghumro, the recreation of ministries after June 30, 2011, on subjects already transferred to provinces was against the spirit of the Constitution.

He specifically pointed towards areas including education, health, national food security, culture, climate change, housing, social initiatives, EOBI, Evacuee Trust matters and Zakat and Ushr related functions.

The senator argued that creating federal structures for provincial subjects has increased government expenses at a time when Pakistan is facing financial pressure.

He claimed that federal government expenditure has increased to around Rs19,000 billion, while the country’s total tax and non tax revenue stands near Rs20,000 billion.

Senator Ghumro said that apart from defence requirements due to security challenges, other federal ministries should have limited budgets according to constitutional responsibilities.

He suggested that reducing unnecessary federal administrative structures could save around Rs5,000 to Rs6,000 billion and help reduce dependence on foreign loans.

The committee also raised concerns about the ineffective role of the Council of Common Interests, a constitutional body responsible for resolving issues between the federation and provinces.

Senator Ghumro said the CCI’s permanent secretariat was not functioning effectively and stressed that the institution must be strengthened to protect provincial rights.

The committee decided to form a subcommittee to examine alleged violations related to the implementation of the 18th Amendment, including the revival of ministries and the role of the CCI.

Senator Poonjo Bheel said that ministries created on devolved subjects should be abolished because the matter had already been settled through the constitutional process.

Senator Jan Muhammad Buledi said the subcommittee should not only review the recreated ministries but also examine why the CCI had become ineffective despite having an important constitutional role.

The committee also directed the Establishment Division to avoid making appointments in departments dealing with devolved subjects and ensure that provincial representation is protected in government appointments and promotions.

Officials were asked to provide details of appointments in different grades within two weeks and submit a compliance report within 15 days.

It emphasized that the federal government should support provinces rather than reduce their constitutional benefits.

The committee also reviewed the issue of the Rs46 billion allocation for Quaid-e-Azam’s Mausoleum, which was not released last year and was reportedly transferred to another ministry.

The committee directed authorities to provide monthly progress reports regarding the development and maintenance of Mazar-e-Quaid.

The committee further sought details about the tenure of federal secretaries and directed the Establishment Division to submit complete records.

Similar Posts

  • |

    Pakistan U21 hockey team leaves for Oman series

    Pakistan’s Under-21 hockey team has departed for Muscat to take part in a five-match Test series against Oman’s senior national side, giving the country’s emerging players a valuable opportunity to gain international experience against more seasoned opposition. The young Pakistan squad left for Oman on Monday, accompanied by head coach and Olympian Ayaz Mahmood, coach and Olympian Sameer Hussain, and coach Azfar Yaqoob. The series is being viewed as an important step in the development of Pakistan’s junior hockey players, particularly as they prepare to transition from age-group competition to the demands of senior international hockey. The first Test will be played on July 29, followed by the second on July 31. The third match is scheduled for August 1, while the fourth Test will take place on August 2. The five-match series will conclude with the final Test on August 4. The Pakistan Hockey Federation (PHF) believes the exposure will help the young players understand the pace, physical demands and pressure associated with international hockey. PHF President Mohyuddin Ahmad Wani extended his best wishes to the team before its departure and said the decision to send the players to Oman was aimed at boosting their confidence and providing them with meaningful international exposure. “Our junior players will gain confidence when they compete against foreign teams at the international level,” Wani said, stressing the importance of giving promising players opportunities to perform outside the domestic circuit. The series against Oman’s senior team could prove particularly useful for Pakistan’s youngsters because they will be competing against players with greater experience and exposure to high-level hockey. Such matches can help young athletes identify weaknesses, improve decision-making and develop the composure required in competitive international fixtures. For Pakistan, the tour is also an opportunity to assess the depth of its emerging talent. With the national side looking to strengthen its future pool of players, regular international exposure at the Under-21 level could play a key role in preparing the next generation for senior hockey. The five-Test format will provide the players with multiple opportunities to adapt. Rather than relying on a single match, the youngsters will have to recover quickly, learn from mistakes and make tactical adjustments throughout the series. The tour also gives the coaching staff an opportunity to evaluate players under challenging conditions and identify individuals capable of progressing to the senior national setup. As Pakistan’s junior players prepare to take on Oman’s senior side, the series promises to be more than a collection of practice matches. It represents a test of character, confidence and readiness—and potentially another important chapter in the development of Pakistan hockey’s next generation.

  • | |

    China lodges complaint after New Zealand’s W…

    China’s embassy in New Zealand has filed a formal complaint after Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters told a Green Party lawmaker of Chinese descent to return to his own country during a heated parliamentary exchange. The clash unfolded Wednesday when Green Party member Lawrence Xu-Nan, who was born in the Chinese city of Tianjin but raised in New Zealand, asked Peters during a debate over the country’s Covid pandemic response whether he was vaccinated. Peters, who leads the populist NZ First party, responded by telling Xu-Nan he had arrived in the country only recently and should return home, adding a remark suggesting dishonesty in China that does not apply in New Zealand. He went on to describe New Zealand as a democracy, in contrast to what he implied Xu-Nan was used to, and told him to go back to where he came from. The remarks prompted an unusual public response from Chinese Ambassador to New Zealand Wang Xiaolong, who said on social media that he generally avoids commenting on domestic politics but suggested the statement revealed more about the speaker than anyone else. China’s embassy in Wellington confirmed it had lodged a complaint with New Zealand’s foreign ministry over what it called negative China related remarks from a New Zealand politician. Peters has stood by his comments, saying New Zealand’s democratic system protects free speech and rights that other countries restrict, at times through force. He said on social media that those offended by his remarks were welcome to the reality of living in New Zealand. New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, whose National Party governs in coalition with Peters’ NZ First, criticized the remarks as inappropriate attention seeking behavior. This is not the first time Peters and his party, who hold significant influence as coalition partners in New Zealand’s fragmented political landscape, have faced accusations of racially charged rhetoric. Earlier this year, Peters’ deputy Shane Jones drew criticism for describing a free trade agreement with India as risking what he called a butter chicken flood. Last year, Peters and Jones faced backlash after Jones shouted at another lawmaker to send Mexicans home during a parliamentary debate, a comment aimed at a legislator who was actually born in the Philippines. Peters later told that lawmaker and Xu-Nan that they should show gratitude for being allowed to live in New Zealand. The episode adds to a pattern of controversies surrounding minor coalition partners in small parliamentary democracies, where kingmaker parties often wield outsized influence despite representing a smaller share of the electorate, occasionally straining diplomatic relationships in the process.

  • | |

    Tabish Hashmi announces departure from Hansna Mana Hai

    Pakistani comedian and television host Tabish Hashmi has announced that he is leaving the popular comedy talk show Hansna Mana Hai, bringing an end to his association with the programme after nearly five years. Hashmi shared the news through a post on Instagram, where he thanked his colleagues and viewers for their support throughout his journey on the show. Reflecting on his time as host, he wrote that the experience had been memorable and expressed gratitude to everyone who contributed to the programme from 2022 to 2026. He also thanked the audience for the love and encouragement they had shown over the years. Tabish Hashmi became a household name after hosting Hansna Mana Hai, a comedy and celebrity talk show that earned a loyal fan base. His witty interviewing style and humorous interactions with guests helped make the programme one of Pakistan’s most popular entertainment shows. Before joining television, Hashmi gained recognition as a stand-up comedian and through digital content. He later expanded his career into mainstream entertainment and is currently hosting Pakistan Got Talent. He has also appeared in a feature film, further strengthening his presence in the country’s entertainment industry. Following his announcement, social media users reacted with surprise and disappointment. Many fans thanked him for entertaining audiences over the years and wished him success in his future projects.

  • |

    High taxes and energy costs push businesses out of Pakistan

    Islamabad: A Senate subcommittee has raised serious concerns over Pakistan’s tax system after being told that companies are reducing operations or leaving the country because of high electricity costs, heavy taxes and difficult business rules. The committee also warned the Finance Secretary that continued absence from its meetings could lead to the matter being sent to the Senate Privileges Committee. The Sub-Committee of the Senate Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue, chaired by Senator Muhammad Talha Mahmood, reviewed Federal Board of Revenue taxation policies and their impact on businesses, investment and economic activity. Senator Talha Mahmood said the main aim was to find ways to increase economic activity and create a better environment for businesses. He said many companies were either reducing their operations or leaving Pakistan because energy costs were too high and the tax system was pressuring businesses too much. The committee also expressed serious concern over the absence of the Finance Secretary. Senator Talha Mahmood directed the Finance Secretary to attend the next meeting and warned that another absence could result in the matter being referred to the Senate Privileges Committee. Business representatives also strongly criticised the current taxation system. Mian Zahid Hussain of the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry said national policy appeared to focus more on collecting revenue than on increasing economic growth. He called for a reduction in advance taxes and withholding taxes. He also asked the government to review customs duties, simplify tax audits and reconsider factory surveillance systems. According to him, complicated tax procedures and compliance requirements were increasing the cost of doing business and discouraging industrial growth. Another business representative, Mr Jadoon, Vice President of a Chamber of Commerce, said Pakistan had competitive labour costs but businesses were still struggling because of high electricity tariffs and regulatory pressure. He said the government should bring more businesses and sectors into the tax system instead of repeatedly increasing pressure on people and companies that were already paying taxes. FBR officials defended recent government measures, telling the committee that taxation policies were influenced by Pakistan’s import requirements and financial limitations. Officials said the government had introduced tax relief for salaried people, reduced super tax and removed super tax for exporters. The committee was informed that the government accepted a revenue impact of around Rs 359 billion while trying to provide relief to businesses and increase economic activity. FBR officials also said exporters facilitation committees had been established in Karachi, Lahore, Sialkot, Faisalabad, Islamabad and Multan to deal with tax related complaints and problems. Senator Talha Mahmood questioned whether current government policies were actually successful in attracting foreign investment. He sought details about investor protection and the rules for transferring shares. The committee directed the relevant authorities to provide a complete briefing on the existing system. The committee also discussed reforms FBR is introducing to simplify tax procedures. FBR officials said work was underway on a mobile application for tax reimbursements. They also said special facilitation days were being arranged in major commercial centres to help taxpayers deal with their problems. The ongoing goods transport strike also came under serious discussion. Senator Talha Mahmood said the strike was damaging trade and business activity and criticised delays in resolving the issue. He warned that perishable goods could be destroyed while businesses were also facing heavy financial losses because containers were being held for longer periods. The committee said the government should immediately open talks with transporters and other affected groups. Members warned that continued disruption could damage Pakistan’s trade and also hurt the country’s international business reputation. The sub committee strongly recommended immediate talks with transporters to restore normal business operations. Senator Talha Mahmood also called for faster action when taxpayers make genuine mistakes in their tax returns. He recommended that if a taxpayer corrects an honest mistake, the blocked account should be restored within 24 to 48 hours. He also called for a better biometric verification system so that taxpayers could complete required procedures more easily. The committee further discussed market closure timings. Senator Talha Mahmood said closing markets early was hurting business activity and reducing traders opportunities to earn income. The convener said Pakistan could achieve sustainable economic growth only through business friendly policies and transparent governance. He stressed that competent and honest officials should be appointed to important positions so they could create policies that support investment, industry and entrepreneurship.

  • |

    Emilio Gay boosts England ahead of Pakistan Tests

    BECKENHAM: England have received a timely boost ahead of their Test series against Pakistan, with opener Emilio Gay included in the Professional County Club Select XI squad for a three-day warm-up match. Gay’s participation is encouraging news after the left-handed batter suffered a right shoulder injury while representing Durham against Middlesex in the One-Day Cup last week. He experienced discomfort early in his innings before aggravating the problem while playing a straight drive against Toby Roland-Jones. The 26-year-old was forced to leave the field after scoring nine runs from 17 deliveries, raising concerns over his availability for England’s upcoming Test assignment. However, medical scans reportedly showed no serious damage, allowing Gay to return to competitive action as England assess his fitness. The warm-up fixture at Beckenham was initially scheduled for four days but has been shortened to three following an agreement between the England and Wales Cricket Board and the Pakistan Cricket Board. Gay will feature alongside England Test squad members Shoaib Bashir and Matthew Fisher in the PCC Select XI. The match could provide England with an important opportunity to monitor Gay’s shoulder before the first Test. Gay earned his place in England’s Test plans after an impressive run of form and made his international debut earlier this summer. His availability is particularly significant as England reshape their batting line-up following Ben Stokes’ retirement. Bashir, meanwhile, remains highly regarded by England’s selectors despite limited recent county appearances. The young spinner may not feature in the Test XI, with England considering a four-seamer attack and relying on Dan Lawrence and Joe Root for occasional off-spin. The PCC Select XI will be coached by England Under-19 head coach Mike Yardy, with the England Lions head-coach position currently vacant. For England, Gay’s return offers a welcome sense of relief — but the warm-up match will reveal whether the opener is truly ready for the pressure of Test cricket against Pakistan. PCC Select XI squad Tom Haines (c), Shoaib Bashir, Luc Benkenstein, Caleb Falconer, Matt Fisher, Emilio Gay, Nathan Gilchrist, Josh Hull, Manny Lumsden, James Rew, James Sales, Charlie Tear, Noah Thain, Saif Zaib.

  • Southern Thailand Flood Death Toll Soars to 145, Recovery Efforts Intensify

    BANGKOK – The death toll from the catastrophic flooding in Southern Thailand has risen sharply to 145, with the province of Songkhla suffering the heaviest loss at 110 lives, Government spokesman Siripong Angkasakulkiat announced today. The figures, based on a report from the Public Health Ministry, mark one of the largest casualties from a disaster […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *