ask tax whiz
| | |

[Ask the Tax Whiz] Should billionaires pay more?

Should billionaires pay more?

Yes. But before Congress creates another tax, government must answer a more basic question: Can it identify the real billionaires, determine what they actually own, and verify whether that wealth was legitimately earned and properly taxed?

House Bill No. 9274 proposes annual rates of 1% on net taxable assets above ₱1 billion, 2% above ₱2 billion, and 3% above ₱3 billion. Greater progressivity is a defensible objective. But a wealth tax without modern tax administration risks becoming a classic Philippine reform: good policy on paper, weak enforcement in practice. 

The most revealing number is not the proposed 3% rate.

It is 97.55%.

According to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR)’s 2025 Annual Report, ₱3.03 trillion—or 97.55% of total collections—came from voluntary payments. Preliminary and final assessments contributed only 2.33%, while delinquent accounts added 0.12%. 

That does not make audit unimportant. Tax audit and investigation deter tax evasion and protect compliant taxpayers. But it tells policymakers where sustainable revenue really comes from: voluntary compliance supported by credible enforcement.

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) similarly reports that additional assessments from audit averaged about 3% of collections among reporting tax administrations in 2023. Modern tax administrations do not finance government by auditing everyone. They use information, risk management, and targeted enforcement to encourage everyone else to comply voluntarily. 

Modern tax administration should therefore be the reform—not simply another tax.

The Philippines can learn from countries that have retained wealth taxes. Switzerland integrates wealth taxation with annual income-tax reporting and established asset-valuation systems. Norway imposes combined wealth-tax rates around 1% at higher levels and provides valuation discounts for shares and operating assets. Colombia, a more relevant emerging-market example, made its wealth tax permanent, with rates from 0.5% to 1.5%. 

Lessons and tax reforms

The lesson is not that we should copy them.

Wealth taxes work best when government can see, value and verify wealth.

That is precisely where our institutional reform must begin.

The Philippines needs a modern revenue administration that is fiscally autonomous, professionally managed and politically insulated, with strong internal controls and accountability. It should integrate tax returns, beneficial ownership, property, securities, major asset acquisitions and legally accessible financial information to build verified asset-and-income profiles of high-net-worth taxpayers.

Forbes is useful for headlines. It is not a tax database.

Bank secrecy must also evolve. It should protect legitimate privacy—not unexplained wealth, tax evasion, money laundering or corruption. Reform must come with strict access rules, digital audit trails, confidentiality safeguards, and severe penalties for abuse. (READ: [Puso at Diwa] Foreign currency deposit secrecy: Time for a constitutional rethink)

Objective risk-based scrutiny should follow the evidence wherever it leads—including to public officials, politically exposed persons, political families, major campaign donors, and government contractors when declared lawful income is materially inconsistent with accumulated assets.

That is not political persecution. The best protection against weaponized taxation is an independent institution applying transparent rules and due process regardless of who is in power.

Our decades-long struggle to recover ill-gotten wealth should have taught us another lesson: once assets disappear behind nominees, corporations and layered transactions, recovery becomes far more difficult.

Government should detect unexplained wealth early—not decades later.

But tax policy must distinguish legitimate wealth from ill-gotten wealth.

An entrepreneur who builds a multibillion-peso company, creates thousands of jobs, attracts investment and pays the correct taxes is not the problem. Developing economies need successful businesses, deeper capital markets, and more investment.

Tax policy should distribute the fiscal burden more fairly—not destroy the productive wealth that creates jobs.

That is why Congress should carefully model a recurring tax as high as 3% of net wealth. Start with a genuinely ultra-high threshold. Consider moderate marginal rates. Provide tightly designed rules for productive but illiquid assets. Close artificial-debt and beneficial-ownership loopholes. Then measure actual collections, investment effects and administrative costs.

The World Bank likewise emphasizes transparency, beneficial-ownership information, international information exchange, and advanced data analytics as foundations of stronger domestic revenue mobilization, especially in developing economies.

So, should billionaires pay more?

Yes. But first build a government capable of finding the real billionaires—and distinguishing wealth created through enterprise from wealth accumulated through corruption or tax evasion.

Collect better before taxing more.

Tax verified wealth, not headlines. Modernize tax administration. Protect legitimate investment. Follow unexplained wealth wherever it leads.

Otherwise, we may create another tax that looks progressive on paper—while the truly rich and powerful remain beyond its reach. – Rappler.com

Mon Abrea, CPA, MBA, MPA (Harvard) is a global tax policy expert and Chief Tax Advisor of Asian Consulting Group (ACGlobal). He advises governments, multinational enterprises, and international organizations on tax policy, investment competitiveness, and fiscal reform. He is the author of Reimagining the World Without Corruption and Why Invest in the Philippines? CREATE MORE Edition, and has represented the Philippines in policy dialogues at the OECD, World Bank, and other international forums.

Below are some related columns of Mon Abrea you may have missed:

Similar Posts

  • |

    Senate pushes Rs617m gas project for 42 Ghotki villages

    Islamabad: After years of waiting, 42 villages located near the Badar Gas Field in District Ghotki are finally moving towards receiving natural gas as the Senate Petroleum Sub Committee pushed authorities to act on a long delayed promise linked to the Prime Minister’s Directive of 15 September 2003 and Supreme Court directions. The Sub Committee, convened by Senator Jam Saifullah Khan, expressed concern over the continued delay in providing gas facilities to villages located within five kilometres of gas producing fields. The Committee directed relevant departments and companies to ensure that previous commitments are converted into practical work without further delay. The meeting was attended by Senators Manzoor Ahmed Kakar and Haji Hidayatullah Khan along with senior officials from the Petroleum Division, Finance Division, Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority, Sui Southern Gas Company Limited, Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited, Oil and Gas Development Company Limited, Pakistan Petroleum Limited, Mari Energies and other stakeholders. During the meeting, the Sub Committee decided to give top priority to the gasification project for the remaining 42 villages near Badar Gas Field, District Ghotki. The estimated cost of the project is Rs617 million. The Special Secretary Petroleum Division, Finance Division officials and Chairman OGRA assured the Committee that Rs200 million would initially be released from the allocated Rs1 billion funds to start the project immediately. Managing Director Sui Southern Gas Company Limited informed the Committee that the company would provide its share of funding and begin technical planning, engineering work and procurement activities. It was decided that project activities would begin within ten days after the release of initial funds. The Committee was informed that remaining funds required for completing the project would be arranged without interruption. The Petroleum Division and Finance Division assured the Committee that financial issues would not become a reason for further delay. The Sub Committee also reviewed the wider issue of gas supply to villages located within five kilometres of gas producing fields across Pakistan. Officials informed the Committee that new policy guidelines are being prepared to implement the Prime Minister’s Directive and Supreme Court instructions regarding gasification of eligible villages. The Petroleum Division was directed to present a complete implementation plan in the next meeting. The plan will include details about funding arrangements, responsibilities of different organizations, district wise schedules and clear completion timelines for all remaining eligible villages across the country.

  • Singapore Oil Stocks Bounce Back as Fuel Inventories See Major July Surge

    BANGKOK – Singapore is witnessing a welcome shift in its critical energy markets this month. Recent data reveals that fuel oil inventories in the Asian trading hub have finally bounced back. Following several months of steady declines, onshore stockpiles surged by an impressive nine percent during July. This much-needed rebound pushes the busy port’s total […]

  • | | |

    Tax ombudsman flags flaw in FBR refund system

    Pakistan’s Federal Tax Ombudsman has identified a major flaw in the Federal Board of Revenue’s (FBR) FASTER sales tax refund system and directed the tax authority to take immediate corrective measures. The ombudsman said the issue is affecting exporters and undermining the effectiveness of the automated sales tax refund mechanism, which was introduced to ensure quicker processing of refund claims. The observations were made in a ruling issued by Federal Tax Ombudsman Zafar Hijazi while deciding complaints filed by a company regarding delays and issues in the refund process. According to the decision, the FASTER system is unable to distinguish between commercial export goods declarations and non-commercial sample exports. As a result, exporters may face unnecessary delays or complications in obtaining legitimate sales tax refunds. The ombudsman directed the FBR to address the technical shortcomings in the system without delay to ensure that genuine exporters receive timely refunds and the automated mechanism functions efficiently. The ruling emphasized that improving the FASTER system is essential for protecting exporters’ interests and maintaining confidence in Pakistan’s tax refund process

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *