balancing welfare healthcare

Balancing Welfare and Healthcare

By Dr Sajid Shiek

Pakistan’s social protection programmes have helped many vulnerable families. The Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) and its health and nutrition-linked initiatives are meant to support mothers, children, and low-income households. BISP’s Nashonuma programme is described by the programme itself as a conditional cash transfer initiative for health and nutrition, and it works through facilitation centres at government health facilities.

In Sindh, the Mother and Child Support Program, also known as MAMTA, is similarly designed to provide cash support to pregnant and lactating women while linking assistance with regular health checkups.

These efforts are important and deserve recognition. At the same time, public programmes should also be reviewed for how they affect service delivery inside already crowded health facilities.

Having worked as a Medical Officer in the Health Department since 2014, I have seen that the implementation of these programmes in government hospitals can create practical difficulties, especially in rural areas. This is not a criticism of the welfare idea itself. It is a concern about how the system is being managed.

Many rural government hospitals in Sindh already face limited space, staff shortages, and pressure on basic resources. When programme-related procedures are carried out in the same facilities, the number of visitors increases further. In some centres, outpatient attendance has risen sharply, not only because of illness, but also because beneficiaries must visit hospitals to complete formalities linked to these programmes.

As a result, outpatient departments become crowded for much of the day. Doctors and paramedical staff must divide their time between patient care and administrative work. Medicines, supplies, and other hospital resources are used more quickly, which can affect patients who come for treatment of genuine medical problems.

Crowding also makes infection prevention more difficult. The World Health Organization says infection prevention and control is essential for safe and quality healthcare, and that without effective IPC, quality health care delivery is not possible. In busy facilities, long queues and congested waiting areas can increase the risk of spreading communicable diseases, especially among pregnant women, infants, and older patients.

Another issue that deserves attention is the possible effect on family planning services. Financial support linked to pregnancy and safe delivery can encourage maternal care, but policymakers should also consider whether such incentives are fully aligned with broader reproductive health and population management goals. This is an area that needs careful assessment rather than assumptions.

The burden is not only physical. Healthcare workers are also under pressure. The WHO has noted that high levels of stress, burnout, and workforce strain are linked to staff shortages, unsafe working conditions, and stressful environments, and that at least a quarter of health and care workers reported anxiety, depression, and burnout symptoms between January 2020 and April 2022. In crowded facilities, these pressures can grow further and affect the quality of care.

The solution does not require reducing social welfare programmes. It requires better coordination.

A practical step would be to establish separate BISP and MAMTA facilitation centres outside hospitals, or at least in dedicated administrative units with separate staff. This would allow beneficiaries to receive support without interrupting clinical work. Hospitals could then focus on diagnosis, treatment, emergency care, maternal services, immunization, and disease prevention.

Better coordination between social protection and health departments would reduce congestion, improve infection control, and allow medical staff to spend more time on patient care. It would also make the welfare system more efficient and easier for beneficiaries to use.

Pakistan does not need to choose between social protection and healthcare. Both are public responsibilities, and both should strengthen each other. If welfare administration is kept separate from clinical services, hospitals can remain focused on healing, while social programmes continue to support the poor in a more effective way.

This issue deserves review at the policy level. A small structural change could improve both healthcare delivery and social protection outcomes across the country.

The writer is a senior Medical Officer. He can be reached at doctorsajid07@gmail.com

Similar Posts

  • Many smokers still miss major health risks

    A new study has found that public understanding of the health risks of smoking has improved only slightly over the past 20 years. Researchers studied more than 240,000 smokers from 46 countries. Most participants knew that smoking can cause lung cancer.  However far fewer were aware that smoking can also greatly increase the risk of heart disease heart attacks and strokes. Gaps in public awareness The study also found that many smokers do not fully understand the dangers of secondhand smoke.  They may not know that breathing in someone else’s cigarette smoke can also increase the risk of heart disease heart attacks and strokes. The research was published in the journal BMJ Open. Researchers said that despite health warnings on cigarette packs tobacco control policies and years of public awareness campaigns important gaps in knowledge still remain. Heart risks often overlooked Lead author Janet Chung Hall, a scientist with the University of Waterloo’s International Tobacco Control Policy Evaluation Project said the lack of awareness about the serious effects of smoking and secondhand smoke is concerning. Experts estimate that smoking related heart and blood vessel diseases cause more than two million deaths worldwide every year. The researchers say stronger public health campaigns are needed to help people understand that smoking does not only damage the lungs. It can also seriously affect the heart and blood vessels. Better awareness of these risks could encourage more smokers to quit and help reduce the harmful effects of tobacco on both smokers and people around them.

  • Suzi’s monument keeps Lahore Zoo’s beloved elephant alive in memory

    By Sahr Sarfraz A visit to Lahore Zoo recently brought back memories of one of its most beloved residents, Suzi, whose monument continues to preserve the legacy of an elephant that remained close to the hearts of visitors for nearly three decades. Founded in 1872, Lahore Zoo is among Pakistan’s oldest zoological institutions and has witnessed generations of animals becoming part of the city’s collective memory. However, few managed to capture public affection quite like Suzi. The African elephant arrived at Lahore Zoo in 1988 and soon became one of its most popular attractions. Families, schoolchildren and tourists regularly gathered around her enclosure, fascinated by her gentle nature and calm presence. Suzi was more than an animal on display. Over the years, she developed a special relationship with her keepers, who cared for her and became familiar faces in her daily life. Visitors also grew accustomed to seeing her during school trips, holidays and weekend outings. Her popularity was reflected in the affection with which people remembered her. At times, her name was painted on her forehead alongside Pakistan’s crescent and star, a gesture that reflected the special place she held in the hearts of Lahore’s residents. For thousands of visitors, seeing Suzi became part of growing up in the city. Children who first encountered her during school trips later returned with their own families, creating memories that crossed generations. Suzi died on May 13, 2017, after suffering from leg-related health problems. Her death left many visitors and zoo workers grieving, particularly those who had known her for years. Today, a monument at Lahore Zoo stands as a tribute to the elephant who once occupied the area. Although her former enclosure has since become home to other animals, including a white rhinoceros and a hippopotamus, the sculpture keeps Suzi’s memory alive. Standing before the monument offers a quiet opportunity to reflect on the connection that can develop between people and animals. In a rapidly changing city, the memorial serves as a reminder of a life that brought happiness to countless visitors. Lahore Zoo remains an important destination for recreation, education and family visits. Yet Suzi’s monument adds another dimension to the experience by preserving a piece of the zoo’s history. Her story demonstrates that animals can become much more than exhibits. They can become part of a community’s memories, childhood experiences and emotional history. Suzi may no longer be present at Lahore Zoo, but her legacy continues through the monument that ensures generations of visitors can remember the elephant who once brought quiet joy to one of Lahore’s most familiar landmarks. About the writer Sahr Sarfraz is a doctor by profession who enjoys writing reflective articles in her spare time.

  • Montaigne’s philosophy is the antidote to modern burnout

    Approximately four centuries ago, the French Renaissance philosopher Michel de MMontaigne offered a philosophy that feels relevant to our hyper-connected world. He wrote in his famous essay Of Solitude that every person ought to maintain a hidden back room (arrière-boutique) inside their own mind. He should possess an uncolonized space where external obligations, public opinions, and societal expectations are strictly forbidden. In this interior, he argued, we establish our true independence and safeguard our core identity. Montaigne was writing long before the advent of smartphones, social media feeds, and workplace notifications. However, his reflections speak directly to a growing contemporary dilemma. The erosion of personal mental autonomy. This 16th-century insight continues to captivate modern psychologists. It reveals how carving out deliberate quietude remains our strongest defense against emotional exhaustion. To appreciate Montaigne’s metaphor, it helps to envision a medieval or Renaissance shopkeeper. In the front of the store, the merchant greets customers, negotiates prices, manages displays, and puts on a professional performance upto public expectations. However, behind the commercial counter sits a private back room. A space away from the gaze of buyers, where the owner can rest, reflect, and exist simply. Montaigne argued that human life operates on a similar dual structure. We all inhabit public identities. We are employees, parents, partners, citizens, and friends. In these roles, we must navigate duties, relationships, and social etiquette. However, Montaigne warned against allowing these outward roles to swallow our entire psychological existence. Our self-worth and peace of mind mustn’t rely exclusively on external validation. We must leave ourselves utterly vulnerable when those external structures vanish. The back room of the mind isn’t a place to hide misdeeds or abandon loved ones. Rather, it is a deliberate mental reserve. It is the part of your consciousness that remains unrented. It’s where you can question assumptions, process emotions, and figure out what you genuinely believe before the rest of the world tells you how to think. Psychologists today pose distinction between two experiences that are often conflated. Loneliness is an involuntary, painful state caused by an unwanted deficit in social connection. It acts as an emotional alarm signal that our fundamental human need for belonging is unmet. In contrast, solitude is a voluntary, chosen pause from social interaction. Recent psychological studies affirm what Montaigne intuitively understood. When individuals intentionally step back from social eengagements in reflective solitude, they experience lower levels of stress, improved emotional regulation, and creative problem-solving. Crucially, the key variable that determines whether time alone feels refreshing or painful is personal agency. Chosen solitude restores energy, whereas forced isolation breeds distress. Montaigne’s philosophical framework complements these findings by emphasizing that true solitude is a mental habit rather than a physical location. You do not need to retreat to a secluded mountain or cut ties with society to experience it. You can sit in a crowded coffee shop or a busy subway train and still inhabit your internal back room. One condition provided that you retain control over your own thoughts and judgment. In the modern digital landscape, preserving an uncolonized back room has become significantly more difficult. Technology companies design algorithms specifically to capture and monetize human attention. Our devices invite us to check messages from the moment we wake up. Afterwards, we respond to emails, view news updates, and seek social validation in the form of likes and comments. Many people have turned their entire interior life into a public display. Every preference is shared. The thought is broadcast. The free moment is filled with external input. When every gap in our day is filled with podcasts, streams, or scrolling feeds, the boundary protecting our inner retreat disintegrates. We become perpetually accessible to everyone else while remaining complete strangers to ourselves. Most people cannot afford to abandon their careers or family obligations to go live in isolation. So, a mental back room in the 21st century requires intentional daily boundaries. The room does not need to be built with physical walls. It can be constructed out of time and habits. A daily twenty-minute walk without wearing headphones or listening to audiobooks allows thoughts to drift, settle, and organize naturally. The delaying act of checking social media notifications for the first thirty minutes after waking up ensures that your mind starts the day with its own thoughts. Also, keeping personal journal where thoughts are written purely for self-clarification reclaims the joy of private thought. Ultimately, Montaigne’s classic essay reminds us that reserving a private space in the mind is not an act of selfishness or social withdrawal. On the contrary, an inner sanctuary ensures that we return to our families, workplaces, and communities. We bring a grounded, clear-headed, and genuine self to the table. We ensure that while we may give our time to the world, we never give away the key to our mind.  

  • Fight Against Thalassemia

    By Baloch Khan Thalassemia is a serious inherited blood disorder that affects thousands of families in Pakistan. Many patients, especially children, depend on regular blood transfusions and expensive treatment to survive. Sadly, many families cannot afford these costs, and blood shortages make their struggle even harder. The government, hospitals, and welfare organizations should work together to improve awareness about thalassemia. Free screening before marriage, public education campaigns, and better access to treatment can help prevent new cases and save lives. Blood donation drives should also be organized regularly so that no patient suffers due to a lack of blood. It is time to treat thalassemia as a national health priority. With greater awareness, timely screening, and public support, we can reduce the burden of this disease and give patients hope for a healthier future.

  • Ginger: A small root with big benefits

    Ginger is a common ingredient used to add flavor to everyday meals. Although it looks like a simple root experts say it contains several natural compounds that may offer health benefits. Researchers have studied ginger for its possible effects on digestion inflammation cholesterol and blood sugar. Ginger comes from a plant in the Zingiberaceae family. It contains active compounds including gingerol which has antioxidant and anti inflammatory properties. Research published in the journal Molecules suggests that these properties may help reduce inflammation and protect the body from damage caused  by harmful molecules. May support digestion Ginger has been used for centuries to help with stomach and digestive problems.  Studies suggest that adding ginger to the diet may help reduce symptoms such as nausea stomach discomfort and bloating in some people. May help manage cholesterol Ginger has also been studied for its possible effect on cholesterol.  Keeping cholesterol levels within a healthy range is important for overall health. Some research including studies published in the Journal of Nutrition has examined whether ginger may help lower LDL, often called “bad cholesterol.” However more research is needed to fully understand its effects. May support healthy blood sugar Researchers have also looked at ginger and blood sugar control.  One study published in the Iranian Journal of Pharmaceutical Research reported lower blood sugar levels among people with type 2 diabetes who consumed ginger regularly.  Some studies suggest that ginger may also help improve the body’s response to insulin. However it should not replace diabetes treatment or prescribed medicines. Possible Anti-Cancer properties The natural compounds in ginger are also being studied for possible anti-cancer effects.  Early laboratory research suggests that some compounds in ginger may slow the growth of certain cancer cells.  Research published in Gastroenterology has also explored these possible effects. However these findings are still being studied and more research is needed before firm conclusions can be made. Use ginger in moderation Although ginger may have several potential health benefits, consuming too much is not recommended. Ginger should not be considered a replacement for medical treatment. People who have a health condition or take regular medicines should speak with a doctor or qualified health professional before using large amounts of ginger or ginger supplements. Adding a reasonable amount of ginger to a balanced diet can be a simple way to enjoy its flavor and possible nutritional benefits

  • |

    Silence is the gateway to self-knowledge

    In a world governed by the constant impulse to broadcast every thought, quiet reflection has become a rare commodity. Modern culture often treats silence as an uncomfortable void. It is termed as a gap in conversation that must be immediately filled with idle chatter, opinions, or background noise. However, a insightful cultural piece by The Marginalian revisit Kahlil Gibran’s classic masterpiece, The Prophet. It reminds us that embracing silence is not an act of withdrawal, but a necessary passage toward understanding who we truly are. When Kahlil Gibran wrote The Prophet in 1923, he addressed human struggles that remain relevant today. In his discourse on speech, Gibran suggests that incessant talking often springs from a subtle internal distress. We speak most compulsively when we lose touch with the quiet rhythm of our own thoughts. When we can no longer sit comfortably with our internal world, language transforms from genuine connection into a mere distraction. Thus, rendering itself as verbal pastime designed to drown out silence. Gibran offers a vivid metaphor for this dynamic. He writes that thought is a bird of space that can spread its wings inside a cage of words. Yet, it remains incapable of real flight. By reducing complex feelings into rigid verbal formulas, we often constrain the depth of our experiences. Excessive talk can obscure deeper understanding rather than clarify it. It might replace genuine contemplation with superficial noise. Why do so many people flee from quiet moments? According to Gibran, chatter frequently serves as a shield against the intimidating clarity of solitude. In the stillness of being alone, external distractions vanish. This silence forces us to stand face-to-face with our unvarnished selves: our fears, insecurities, unresolved longings, and raw truths. When Gibran’s prophet-protagonist is asked to address the matter of talking, he responds: You talk when you cease to be at peace with your thoughts; And when you can no longer dwell in the solitude of your heart you live in your lips, and sound is a diversion and a pastime. And in much of your talking, thinking is half murdered. For thought is a bird of space, that in a cage of words may indeed unfold its wings but cannot fly.In a world governed by the constant impulse to broadcast every thought, quiet reflection has become a rare commodity. For many, this exposure feels uncomfortable, triggering an urgent desire to keep a conversation going. It takes genuine courage to endure the silence long enough to hear what our inner world is actually trying to tell us. Gibran’s perspective on self-knowledge carries a warning against over-categorizing human identity. He cautions against treating the human soul as a static math problem or a territory that can be fully mapped and measured. Rather than declaring, “I have found the absolute truth,” Gibran suggests a humbler, more open attitude: “I have found a truth” He describes the human spirit not as a straight line or a single rigid structure, but as a boundless sea unfolding like a lotus with countless petals. When we attempt to define our entire identity through fixed labels or rigid verbal definitions, we risk placing artificial boundaries around a psyche that is naturally vast and evolving. Real self-knowledge isn’t about arriving at a final conclusion about who we are… it is about maintaining a curiosity toward our own inner evolution. Reclaiming Quiet in a Hyper-Connected Age In an epoch characterized by constant connectivity, Gibran’s reflections serve as an urgent invitation to recalibrate our relationship with quietness. Silence is not the absence of sound. Rather, it is a space where creative intuition, emotional healing, and genuine self-awareness take root.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *