balancing welfare healthcare

Balancing Welfare and Healthcare

ByJustpaste.in

By Dr Sajid Shiek

Pakistan’s social protection programmes have helped many vulnerable families. The Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) and its health and nutrition-linked initiatives are meant to support mothers, children, and low-income households. BISP’s Nashonuma programme is described by the programme itself as a conditional cash transfer initiative for health and nutrition, and it works through facilitation centres at government health facilities.

In Sindh, the Mother and Child Support Program, also known as MAMTA, is similarly designed to provide cash support to pregnant and lactating women while linking assistance with regular health checkups.

These efforts are important and deserve recognition. At the same time, public programmes should also be reviewed for how they affect service delivery inside already crowded health facilities.

Having worked as a Medical Officer in the Health Department since 2014, I have seen that the implementation of these programmes in government hospitals can create practical difficulties, especially in rural areas. This is not a criticism of the welfare idea itself. It is a concern about how the system is being managed.

Many rural government hospitals in Sindh already face limited space, staff shortages, and pressure on basic resources. When programme-related procedures are carried out in the same facilities, the number of visitors increases further. In some centres, outpatient attendance has risen sharply, not only because of illness, but also because beneficiaries must visit hospitals to complete formalities linked to these programmes.

As a result, outpatient departments become crowded for much of the day. Doctors and paramedical staff must divide their time between patient care and administrative work. Medicines, supplies, and other hospital resources are used more quickly, which can affect patients who come for treatment of genuine medical problems.

Crowding also makes infection prevention more difficult. The World Health Organization says infection prevention and control is essential for safe and quality healthcare, and that without effective IPC, quality health care delivery is not possible. In busy facilities, long queues and congested waiting areas can increase the risk of spreading communicable diseases, especially among pregnant women, infants, and older patients.

Another issue that deserves attention is the possible effect on family planning services. Financial support linked to pregnancy and safe delivery can encourage maternal care, but policymakers should also consider whether such incentives are fully aligned with broader reproductive health and population management goals. This is an area that needs careful assessment rather than assumptions.

The burden is not only physical. Healthcare workers are also under pressure. The WHO has noted that high levels of stress, burnout, and workforce strain are linked to staff shortages, unsafe working conditions, and stressful environments, and that at least a quarter of health and care workers reported anxiety, depression, and burnout symptoms between January 2020 and April 2022. In crowded facilities, these pressures can grow further and affect the quality of care.

The solution does not require reducing social welfare programmes. It requires better coordination.

A practical step would be to establish separate BISP and MAMTA facilitation centres outside hospitals, or at least in dedicated administrative units with separate staff. This would allow beneficiaries to receive support without interrupting clinical work. Hospitals could then focus on diagnosis, treatment, emergency care, maternal services, immunization, and disease prevention.

Better coordination between social protection and health departments would reduce congestion, improve infection control, and allow medical staff to spend more time on patient care. It would also make the welfare system more efficient and easier for beneficiaries to use.

Pakistan does not need to choose between social protection and healthcare. Both are public responsibilities, and both should strengthen each other. If welfare administration is kept separate from clinical services, hospitals can remain focused on healing, while social programmes continue to support the poor in a more effective way.

This issue deserves review at the policy level. A small structural change could improve both healthcare delivery and social protection outcomes across the country.

The writer is a senior Medical Officer. He can be reached at doctorsajid07@gmail.com

Similar Posts

  • How your posture affects your mood and mind

    ByJustpaste.in

    In today’s digital world most people spend hours every day looking at a phone laptop tablet or book.  Experts say that constantly bending your neck or sitting in a slouched position does more than cause neck and shoulder pain it can also affect your mental health. According to health experts the way you sit or stand has a direct effect on your mood and emotions. Even the way you hold your phone or book can influence how you feel.  If you are reading this while looking down at your phone experts suggest sitting up straight. They explain that when you stay in a slouched position your brain may read it as a sign of weakness or stress.  This can increase feelings of anxiety sadness and mental tiredness. Dr. Nitin Menon, a senior consultant in physical medicine says poor posture can make existing mental health problems worse.  Long periods of physical strain may also increase stress and anxiety. Psychiatrist Dr. Shiv Kataria says people often curl up and become disconnected from their surroundings while using their phones. This can make them feel more isolated and lonely. Experts also say the way you hold your phone may reflect your mental state. Holding it tightly checking it repeatedly or endlessly scrolling can increase anxiety and make it harder to relax. Poor posture can also affect your breathing. When you hunch forward your chest becomes compressed making it harder to take deep breaths. This may leave you feeling more tense and uncomfortable. It can also put extra pressure on your neck shoulders and back leading to pain over time. The good news is that improving your posture may help both your body and your mind. Sitting or standing upright with your shoulders back and chest open allows you to breathe more deeply and activates the body’s natural relaxation system. This is one reason why the idea of a “power pose” has become popular. Experts tips for better posture Keep your phone laptop or monitor at eye level. Follow the 20-20-20 rule: Every 20 minutes look at something 20 feet away for 20 seconds and gently stretch your neck and shoulders. Use a book stand or pillow to raise books instead of looking down. Make sure your chair supports your lower back keep your feet flat on the floor and place your screen at eye level. Strengthen your posture muscles with simple daily exercises such as chin tucks and shoulder blade squeezes. Experts say that changing your posture is a simple step you can take right away to improve your mood and reduce stress. While it may not be easy to avoid screens making small posture changes every day can support both your physical and mental health.

  • Does phone charging waste power?

    ByJustpaste.in

    Mobile phones have become an important part of daily life. Many people charge their phones every morning every night or even several times a day. This often raises a common question •Does charging a phone every day add a lot to your electricity bill? The simple answer is no. Charging a smartphone uses very little electricity compared to household appliances such as refrigerators fans irons or air conditioners. The amount of electricity used depends on the phone’s battery size the charger’s power and how long the phone takes to charge. Even if a phone needs around three hours to fully charge it still uses only a small amount of electricity. Over the course of a year charging a phone every day usually consumes only a few units of electricity. Fast chargers may use slightly more power but the difference is very small and is unlikely to make a noticeable impact on your electricity bill. Experts also recommend following safe charging habits. Always use the original or a certified charger avoid charging your phone under a pillow or blanket and replace damaged chargers immediately. These simple steps can help prevent overheating and protect your phone’s battery. •Tips keeping your phone charged every day costs very little and is one of the least expensive ways to use electricity at home.

  • Talking to yourself may boost brain power

    ByJustpaste.in

    Some habits may look strange to other people. Talking to yourself is one of them.  Many people think it shows poor concentration or a weak mind but research suggests that this habit can sometimes have positive effects. Self talk can support your brain Talking to yourself can help you organize your thoughts and understand your feelings.  It may also help improve memory focus, and confidence. A 2012 study found that people who talked to themselves could identify objects in pictures more quickly.  This suggests that saying things out loud may sometimes help the brain focus on what it is looking for. It may improve self control Research has also found a possible link between self talk and better self control.  Talking through a problem can help people think before acting and make better decisions. Self talk may also help people understand themselves better by giving them a chance to think about their feelings plans and problems. Positive self talk matters Not all self talk is helpful. Constantly criticizing yourself or using negative words can make you feel worse and may affect your confidence. Positive and balanced self talk can be more useful. For example reminding yourself to stay calm focus on a task or keep trying can help you manage difficult situations. So if you sometimes talk to yourself there is no need to feel embarrassed.  When kept positive and balanced this simple habit may help you focus organize your thoughts and understand yourself better.

  • Viral video highlights risky school route in India

    ByJustpaste.in

    Millions of children around the world go to school every day but for some simply reaching the classroom can be a dangerous journey. In India a viral video has raised concerns after showing schoolchildren taking a highly risky route to get to school in Madhya Pradesh’s Vidisha district. The students reportedly have to jump across a river embankment to reach their school while strong water flows below. The dangerous journey has shocked people on social media and raised serious questions about the safety of the children. Parents and local residents say there is no safe route for the children to reach school forcing them to take the dangerous path every day. The situation becomes even more risky during the rainy season when the water level and flow increase. Locals have urged the authorities to inspect the area immediately and provide a safe and permanent route for the students instead of waiting for a tragic accident to happen.

  • | | |

    Pakistan imposes new restrictions on foreign media

    ByJustpaste.in

    Pakistani authorities have exposed regulatory measures governing foreign media operations in the country. The strategy has triggered an alarm among press freedom advocates, legal observers, and media personnel. Under the newly issued Foreign Media Facilitation Guidelines, journalists representing international organizations will no longer be permitted to travel or cover news events outside three major metropolitan hubs without explicit prior authorization from the government. The regulations come at a delicate juncture marked by escalating political instability, public demonstrations, and security crackdowns across key regions including recent demonstrations connected to heightened tensions in Kashmir and subsequent enforcement actions in urban centers like Lahore. Critics argue that by constraining the scope of international newsgathering precisely when accurate coverage is most vital, the state risks deepening information voids and exacerbating the spread of unverified claims. Key Requirements of the New Media Framework Administered through the External Publicity Wing of Pakistan’s Ministry of Information, the updated regulatory policy establishes procedural hurdles for international news agencies. Foreign correspondents, local staff, contributors, and freelance journalists working for international outlets must secure an official No Objection Certificate (NOC) before traveling to conduct reporting assignments outside Islamabad, Karachi, and Lahore. Regions requiring prior approval now explicitly cover all provincial territories, sensitive border zones, and Pakistan-administered Kashmir. The framework provides no defined processing timeframe for NOC applications, leaving reporting teams facing unpredictable delays and potential administrative holds. The Ministry reserves the authority to suspend or revoke official media accreditation if reporting is judged to run counter to the country’s national sovereignty, ideology, or public safety phrasing that legal analysts describe as intentionally open-ended. Backlash from Analysts and Rights Groups The enactment of these guidelines has drawn sharp rebuke from political commentators, civil society organizations, and international press watchdogs, who view the move as part of a systematic contraction of independent journalism within the country. Former senator and political commentator Mustafa Nawaz Khokhar highlighted the grave consequences of curtailing foreign news organizations, warning that restricting legitimate press operations ultimately undermines public trust. These guidelines are tantamount to choking international media in an increasingly shrinking space, Khokhar noted, emphasizing the vital role global news outlets play when local media environments face structural pressure. The public looks at the international media for independent reporting. Placing restrictions simply creates more room for disinformation and the spread of fake news.   Rights groups including the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ) and international watchdogs have echoed these concerns. They’re pointing out that advance the requirement of government permission for routine reporting effectively grants authorities veto power over what news reaches the global audience. Broader Context of Press Freedom in Pakistan Pakistan’s media environment has historically operated in a complex space balancing constitutional guarantees of free speech against national security laws. However, media analysts note that state oversight of both traditional print/broadcast journalism and online digital spaces has tightened significantly in recent years. The introduction of the new foreign media guidelines coincides with broader legislative shifts aimed at regulating online speech and social media platforms. Observers express concern that administrative barriers, combined with strict digital laws, could leave remote or politically sensitive areas completely cut off from independent news coverage. By limiting foreign journalists’ mobility primarily to the capital and two largest economic centers, field reporting from rural regions, border zones, and conflict-affected territories will become exceptionally difficult to conduct legally. Implications for International Coverage As international newsrooms adapt to the new framework, news gathering strategies across South Asia are likely to face operational friction. Bureau chiefs and correspondents report that unpredictable NOC processing times make time-sensitive breaking news coverage outside major cities nearly impossible to guarantee.   Without direct on-the-ground access for independent journalists, global news consumers may increasingly have to rely on official statements or unverified social media updates during crises. For a country navigating complex domestic politics and delicate international relations, press freedom advocates warn that restricting the lens through which the world views Pakistan could backfire, isolating the nation’s political discourse and fostering an environment where misinformation thrives unchecked.

  • Can you take a bath during fever?

    ByJustpaste.in

    During the rainy season and changing weather cases of dengue malaria viral fever typhoid and other illnesses often increase. When people develop a fever many wonder whether taking a bath could make their condition worse. Health experts say that taking a bath during fever is generally safe. A bath with lukewarm water can help the body feel more comfortable and may temporarily reduce body temperature. However the water should not be extremely hot or cold. Avoid very cold water Experts advise against bathing with ice-cold or very cold water during a fever.  Sudden exposure to cold water can cause shivering. This may make the body work harder to produce heat and can increase discomfort. Very hot water should also be avoided. It can raise body temperature and may make weakness and tiredness worse. Do not use alcohol on the skin Some people use alcohol or spirit on the skin to try to lower fever. Health experts do not recommend this method. Alcohol can be absorbed through the skin and may cause harmful effects. It should especially never be used on children for this purpose. What should you do during a fever? Fever is usually not a disease itself. It is often a sign that the body is fighting an infection.  Therefore it is important to find and treat the cause of the fever instead of only trying to lower the temperature. Drink plenty of fluids during a fever to prevent dehydration. Water, ORS coconut water soup and other suitable drinks can help. Wear light comfortable clothes and make sure the room has good airflow. If a full bath feels difficult you can gently clean the body with a soft cloth dipped in lukewarm water. Eating light and easily digestible foods such as porridge, khichdi, and other soft foods may also help the body recover. When should you see a doctor? A mild fever may improve with rest enough fluids and medicines recommended by a doctor. However medical help should be sought if the fever lasts for more than two to three days or is accompanied by confusion breathing problems severe headache repeated vomiting unusual skin rashes, or other serious symptoms. A baby under three months old with a fever should be examined by a doctor immediately. Overall taking a lukewarm bath during fever is usually not a problem. Staying hydrated, getting enough rest eating light food and finding the actual cause of the fever are much more important for recovery.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *