pakistan8217s college education

Pakistan’s College Education Crisis

Educational debates in Pakistan usually begin with schools and end with universities. Somewhere in between lies a vast public college network that has quietly undergone a transformation without receiving the reforms necessary to sustain it. For decades, colleges were viewed merely as institutions imparting Intermediate education. That perception is now obsolete. Government colleges across Pakistan award four-year BS degrees, supervise undergraduate research, implement semester systems, and produce graduates completing sixteen years of education. They have become institutions of higher education in every meaningful sense except in the standards by which they recruit, promote and evaluate their faculty.

The real crisis begins not when institutions disappear but when they continue to exist while quietly abandoning the purpose they were meant to serve. Pakistan’s college education system increasingly reflects this uncomfortable reality. Buildings stand, classrooms remain occupied, salaries are paid and degrees continue to be awarded, yet the intellectual purpose that ought to define higher education is steadily weakening. The system continues to function, but it no longer asks whether it is producing scholars, researchers and critical thinkers or merely issuing degrees.

This contradiction is not merely administrative. It is national. Countries do not build knowledge economies simply by increasing enrolment or opening new campuses. They do so by ensuring that those entrusted with educating the next generation possess the intellectual depth, scholarly discipline and professional integrity demanded by higher education. Pakistan has expanded the responsibilities of its colleges without fundamentally reforming the standards governing those who teach in them. It is this mismatch between expanding responsibilities and stagnant reforms that explains much of the present crisis.

History offers repeated warnings against confusing continuity with progress. Great civilisations have seldom been defeated by ignorance alone; far more often, they have been weakened by their refusal to reform. Ancient Troy believed its mighty walls guaranteed safety until destruction entered concealed within the famous wooden horse. Institutions, too, often collapse not because external forces overwhelm them but because internal weaknesses become too familiar to recognise. Pakistan’s colleges face a similar danger. The greatest threat is not inadequate infrastructure or declining enrolment. It is the quiet normalisation of standards that no longer correspond with the responsibilities these institutions now carry.

Perhaps nowhere is this more evident than in faculty recruitment.

Every education system is ultimately only as strong as the people it appoints to teach. Laboratories, libraries and curricula matter, but they cannot compensate for weak academic recruitment. A nation’s classrooms reflect the intellectual standards it establishes at the point of entry into the profession. Countries that consistently perform well in higher education understand this principle with remarkable clarity.

Finland recruits teachers from among its highest-performing graduates and treats teaching as one of the country’s most competitive professions. Singapore invests heavily in teacher selection, structured professional development and continuous evaluation throughout an educator’s career. South Korea subjects aspiring academics to rigorous competition, while Germany closely links academic progression with scholarly achievement and research productivity. These countries differ in culture, politics and economic history, yet they share one conviction that higher education depends first and foremost upon the quality of its faculty.

Pakistan, regrettably, often operates on a different assumption.

Recruitment is frequently treated as the culmination of academic achievement rather than its beginning. A lecturer appointed with only a sixteen years education may spend an entire career within the same system without acquiring higher qualifications or contributing substantially to research, yet still retire after holding senior academic positions carrying the titles of Associate Professor or Professor. Such a framework might have appeared understandable when colleges were primarily institutions for Intermediate education. It becomes increasingly indefensible once those same institutions award undergraduate degrees equivalent to those offered by universities.

Academic titles should signify scholarly accomplishment rather than the mere passage of time. Across the world, the designation of Professor represents sustained intellectual contribution, recognised research, advanced qualifications and academic leadership. When promotion depends overwhelmingly upon seniority rather than scholarship, titles gradually lose their meaning. The loss is not symbolic alone. It diminishes public confidence in higher education itself.

This is not an argument against experience. Experience remains indispensable in teaching. A seasoned educator often possesses insights that no newly qualified academic can immediately acquire. Classrooms are enriched by years of interaction with students, evolving pedagogical techniques and practical wisdom accumulated over decades.

Experience, however, should complement scholarship, not replace it.

Knowledge no longer remains static for an entire career. Disciplines evolve at astonishing speed. Artificial Intelligence is reshaping linguistics, medicine, engineering, law and the humanities alike. Climate science has transformed environmental studies. Digital humanities have altered literary scholarship. Advances in neuroscience continue redefining educational psychology. A qualification earned thirty years ago, valuable though it remains, cannot alone certify mastery over fields that have changed beyond recognition.

Medicine provides an obvious comparison. No patient would willingly place complete trust in a surgeon who had never updated professional knowledge after graduation. Engineers continually adapt to changing technologies and safety standards. Judges engage with evolving constitutional interpretation. Military officers undergo regular professional education throughout their service. Every serious profession recognises that learning is continuous.

Higher education cannot become the sole profession where intellectual growth effectively ends with appointment.

The irony is that Pakistan’s college sector contains thousands of exceptionally capable teachers who have voluntarily pursued MPhil and PhD degrees despite limited institutional incentives. Many complete advanced research while balancing heavy teaching schedules, administrative responsibilities and family obligations. Their commitment deserves recognition because it reflects a genuine desire to improve professionally rather than merely fulfil formal requirements.

Yet the existing structure frequently sends the opposite message. Promotion often rewards waiting more consistently than learning. When advanced qualifications receive insufficient institutional value, the incentive to pursue rigorous scholarship inevitably weakens. No education system can flourish if intellectual ambition appears optional while seniority remains sufficient.

The anomaly becomes even more striking when one examines the present hierarchy within many public colleges. It is no longer uncommon to find an MPhil-qualified lecturer or even a PhD serving under an officer whose highest academic qualification remains a an undergraduate degree obtained decades earlier. Respect for seniority is a cherished academic tradition and ought never to be discarded. Administrative experience has its own value, and wisdom acquired over years of teaching deserves recognition. Yet respect for experience cannot become an argument against academic advancement.

The issue is not one of personalities; it is one of principles.

A system that allows higher qualifications to become academically irrelevant eventually discourages the pursuit of excellence itself. When a young academic spends six or seven years completing an MPhil or PhD, publishes research, presents papers at conferences and contributes to scholarly debates, only to discover that these achievements have little bearing on career progression within the college sector, the institution unintentionally tells its brightest minds that intellectual effort is secondary to the passage of time. Such messages could be more damaging for a knowledge-based society.

The irony becomes even deeper because the same colleges are now entrusted with awarding BS degrees recognised by the Higher Education Commission. Undergraduate education is no longer an extension of school education; it is the first stage of higher education. Students are expected to undertake research projects, conduct literature reviews, analyse data, prepare dissertations and engage with contemporary scholarship. Such expectations cannot be fulfilled through teaching alone. They require faculty who themselves remain active participants in scholarly inquiry.

Here lies the fundamental inconsistency.

For universities, the Higher Education Commission has laid down clear standards regarding qualifications, research publications and academic progression. An Assistant Professor is expected to possess qualifications that reflect advanced scholarship. Promotion to Associate Professor and Professor requires demonstrable research output published in recognised journals alongside academic contributions extending beyond classroom teaching. The philosophy behind these requirements is simple. Universities exist not merely to disseminate knowledge but also to produce it.

Public colleges now perform many of the same academic functions, yet large sections of the promotion structure continue to operate according to assumptions inherited from a period when undergraduate education was not their responsibility. The result is an educational hybrid in which institutions have become universities in function but not in professional standards.

This duality serves neither students nor teachers.

If a BS degree awarded by a college carries the same academic value as one awarded by a university, then students deserve comparable academic standards irrespective of where they study. The principle is not difficult to understand. Equality of degrees must imply equality of academic expectations. Otherwise, identical qualifications begin to represent unequal educational experiences.

The Higher Education Commission’s framework should therefore not remain confined to universities alone. It should gradually extend to all public colleges offering sixteen years of education. This does not require mechanically transplanting every university regulation into the college system. Colleges have distinct administrative realities and heavier teaching responsibilities. Nevertheless, the fundamental principles should remain identical. Recruitment should increasingly prioritise advanced qualifications. Promotions should depend not merely upon years of service but also upon scholarly achievement, professional development and measurable academic contribution. Research should become an expectation rather than an exception.

Critics may argue that research belongs to universities and not to colleges. Such a distinction might have carried weight two decades ago. It carries very little today.

Across the world, undergraduate teaching is increasingly enriched by faculty who remain engaged with current scholarship. Students benefit when teachers are not merely consumers of knowledge but contributors to it. A lecturer actively involved in research introduces students to evolving debates rather than outdated certainties. Classrooms become places of inquiry instead of repetition. Facts are no longer memorised merely because textbooks record them; they are questioned, analysed and tested against emerging evidence.

Teaching and research are often portrayed as competing responsibilities. In reality, they sustain one another. Research keeps teaching intellectually alive, while teaching continually reminds research of its social purpose.

UNESCO has repeatedly argued in its Global Education Monitoring Reports that improving educational quality depends upon investing in teacher competence, professional development and institutional accountability. Similarly, successive reports of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), particularly through the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), consistently demonstrate that educational success is closely linked with teacher quality, evidence-based policymaking and sustained professional learning. The World Bank has likewise concluded across numerous education studies that teacher effectiveness remains among the strongest school-based determinants of student learning.

These conclusions are neither ideological nor speculative. They emerge from decades of comparative international evidence.

Pakistan need not imitate every foreign model, but it cannot afford to ignore global experience either. Nations that transformed themselves through education understood one lesson exceptionally well that institutions become stronger when academic standards become progressively higher rather than progressively easier.

Japan’s transformation after the Meiji Restoration did not begin with factories; it began with classrooms. South Korea emerged from the devastation of war by investing relentlessly in education and research. Singapore, lacking natural resources, chose to develop human capital with uncompromising seriousness. None of these countries regarded higher education as a routine administrative service. They regarded it as a strategic national investment.

Pakistan often speaks about becoming a knowledge economy while preserving systems that reward longevity more consistently than learning.

This contradiction cannot continue indefinitely.

Another uncomfortable question deserves honest discussion. Promotions in public service generally recognise administrative competence, but academic promotions should recognise intellectual leadership. The two are not always identical. An excellent administrator may not necessarily be an outstanding scholar, just as an accomplished researcher may require support in administration. The present structure frequently conflates the two without evaluating either adequately.

Academic leadership should mean far more than occupying a higher office. It should involve mentoring younger faculty, initiating research collaborations, improving curricula, supervising undergraduate scholarship, encouraging innovation and cultivating a culture where intellectual curiosity becomes institutional habit rather than individual exception.

Without such leadership, colleges risk becoming examination centres instead of centres of higher learning.

The consequences extend well beyond campuses. Every year thousands of graduates leave public colleges and enter classrooms, civil services, journalism, business, law, industry and public administration. The intellectual habits they acquire during undergraduate education accompany them throughout their professional lives. If their education encourages curiosity, they become innovators. If it rewards conformity alone, they become efficient administrators of inherited ideas rather than creators of new ones.

The Roman philosopher Seneca observed that while we are learning, we are also teaching. The converse is equally true. Teachers who cease learning gradually lose the capacity to teach in the fullest sense. Their lectures may continue, their attendance registers may remain complete and examinations may proceed as scheduled, but education quietly gives way to routine.

Routine has never built a civilisation. Scholarship has.

If academic qualifications and research define intellectual competence, they do not by themselves define suitability for academic leadership. Universities and colleges are not factories producing identical products; they are communities of learning shaped as much by the character of their teachers as by the content of their lectures. A professor may possess an impressive list of publications, yet still fail as a mentor if arrogance replaces humility, intolerance suppresses debate or personal prejudice enters the classroom. Higher education, therefore, demands not only scholarship but also emotional maturity and professional integrity.

This brings us to a reform that is likely to invite debate but deserves serious consideration.

Before appointment to the highest academic ranks—particularly Associate Professor and Professor—faculty members should undergo a comprehensive professional assessment that includes an independently administered psychological evaluation. Such a proposal should not be misunderstood as questioning the mental health of teachers or treating them differently from other public servants. Rather, it recognises the unique responsibility entrusted to those who influence thousands of young minds over the course of a career.

The purpose of such an assessment would not be to diagnose illness or stigmatise individuals. It would be to evaluate qualities directly relevant to academic leadership, emotional stability, ethical judgement, openness to new ideas, communication skills, conflict resolution, mentoring capacity, professional conduct and the ability to work collaboratively. These are qualities that determine whether a senior academic becomes a source of inspiration or a source of institutional stagnation.

Many professions already recognise that technical competence alone is insufficient. Judges are expected to display unimpeachable integrity. Military commanders are evaluated for leadership under pressure. Senior civil servants undergo rigorous performance assessments before assuming greater responsibility. Corporate executives are increasingly assessed for emotional intelligence alongside managerial ability. It is difficult to argue that those responsible for educating future generations should be exempt from comparable scrutiny.

A teacher does not merely complete a syllabus. Consciously or unconsciously, he or she shapes attitudes towards knowledge, authority, disagreement and citizenship. Students often remember a teacher’s temperament long after they have forgotten the details of a lecture. A professor who encourages questioning leaves behind confident graduates. One who rewards silence produces obedience rather than understanding.

The ancient Greeks narrated the story of Narcissus, who became so captivated by his own reflection that he lost sight of the world around him. Institutions can suffer from a similar affliction. When they become excessively absorbed in preserving existing hierarchies, they gradually lose the ability to examine themselves critically. Educational systems, like individuals, require the courage of self-reflection if they are to remain alive.

Pakistan’s college education system stands in need of precisely such introspection.

None of these reforms should be implemented punitively. Thousands of college teachers have served the country with distinction under rules they did not create. Many have taught in remote districts with limited facilities, inadequate libraries and heavy workloads. They deserve appreciation rather than condemnation. Reform should therefore be accompanied by opportunity.

Faculty already in service should be given realistic transition periods to upgrade their qualifications through fully funded MPhil and PhD programmes, research fellowships, study leave, online access to internationally indexed journals, writing workshops and collaborative research grants. Colleges should establish research centres linked with universities so that experienced teachers and young scholars can work together rather than in isolation. Government cannot reasonably expect world-class scholarship while providing only

Similar Posts

  • Navigating the Global Consequences of US-China Tec…

    For three decades, the prevailing narrative of the global economy was one of seamless integration. From the design studios of California to the high-tech assembly lines of Shenzhen, the world operated on the assumption that technology was a bridge, not a barrier. However, that era of “borderless innovation” is rapidly giving way to a more fragmented reality. As the United States and China engage in an intensifying rivalry over the foundational technologies of the 21st century artificial intelligence (AI), semiconductors, and 5G a “Silicon Curtain” is descending, reshaping global supply chains and forcing a difficult reckoning for developing nations. The shift marks a transition from a world defined by economic efficiency to one governed by national security. In Washington, the consensus has hardened around the idea that “de-risking” from China is essential to protect intellectual property and maintain a military edge. In Beijing, the drive for “technological self-reliance” has become a central pillar of national survival. What began as a series of trade disputes in 2018 has evolved into a comprehensive decoupling that threatens to bifurcate the global digital ecosystem. The Semiconductor Siege and the AI Arms Race At the heart of this decoupling is the semiconductor the “oil” of the digital age. Advanced microchips are the brains behind everything from smartphones to hypersonic missiles. In 2022, the U.S. Department of Commerce introduced sweeping export controls designed to prevent China from acquiring the high end chips necessary for training generative AI models. The “CHIPS and Science Act” further signaled Washington’s intent to reshore manufacturing, offering billions in subsidies to bring fabrication back to American soil. China has responded with its own set of defensive and offensive measures. Beijing has invested hundreds of billions of dollars into its domestic chip industry via the “Big Fund” and has imposed export restrictions on critical minerals like gallium and germanium materials essential for high-tech manufacturing. This tit-for-tat dynamic has profound implications for AI development. While the U.S. currently leads in algorithmic innovation and hardware design, China possesses a vast reservoir of data and a highly integrated industrial base. As the two powers diverge, the world faces the prospect of two distinct AI “stacks” each with its own standards, ethical frameworks, and hardware requirements. For global corporations, the cost of maintaining two separate supply chains is staggering, with some estimates suggesting a permanent 1 to 5 percent drag on global GDP. The 5G Dilemma: Infrastructure as an Ideology The rivalry is equally visible in the rollout of 5G telecommunications. As the backbone of the “Internet of Things,” 5G infrastructure is more than just a faster cellular network; it is the nervous system of modern cities. The U.S. campaign to exclude Chinese providers like Huawei and ZTE from Western networks, citing security vulnerabilities, has effectively split the world into two camps. Many European and “Five Eyes” nations have aligned with Washington, citing the risks of state-sponsored espionage. Conversely, many nations across Southeast Asia, Africa, and the Middle East have continued to embrace Chinese infrastructure, which is often more affordable and comes with flexible financing. This infrastructure divide creates a “path dependency”: once a country adopts a specific 5G standard, the subsequent software, security protocols, and hardware upgrades are likely to follow the same technical lineage. The “Digital Non-Aligned Movement” Perhaps the most complex fallout of this decoupling is felt in the Global South. Developing nations, many of which are in the midst of their own digital transformations, now find themselves in an uncomfortable position. They are being pressured to choose between the two technological poles, a choice that carries significant economic and diplomatic risks. For a developing economy in Africa or Latin America, U.S. technology offers high security and integration with Western financial markets. However, Chinese technology often provides a lower barrier to entry and a focus on state-led development goals. The danger, according to many economists, is that this “tech-polarization” will lead to a lack of interoperability. If a startup in Nairobi develops an app on a Chinese cloud platform, will it function seamlessly for a user in a market dominated by American standards? Furthermore, the “friend-shoring” of supply chains where production is moved to politically allied nations is creating new winners and losers. Countries like Vietnam, India, and Mexico have seen an influx of investment as manufacturers seek to diversify away from China. However, other developing nations that lack the infrastructure or political alignment to join these new “trusted” supply chains risk being further marginalized. A World of Redundancy and Risk Critics of decoupling argue that the process is not only expensive but potentially futile. The global tech industry is so deeply intertwined that total separation may be impossible without catastrophic economic damage. Apple, for instance, still relies heavily on Chinese assembly, while Chinese tech firms still utilize American software architectures. Moreover, the environmental cost of decoupling is often overlooked. As both superpowers race to build redundant factories and secure mineral supplies, the efficiency gains of globalized production are lost, leading to increased carbon footprints and resource competition. The “Green Transition” itself is at risk, as solar panels and electric vehicle batteries are caught in the crosshairs of trade restrictions. The US-China tech rivalry is no longer a peripheral trade dispute; it is the defining feature of modern geopolitics. The shift from a globalized market to a fractured one represents a fundamental change in how the world innovates and communicates. While “strategic autonomy” may offer a sense of security for the superpowers, it introduces a new layer of volatility for the rest of the world. As we move forward, the challenge for the international community will be to establish a “digital floor” a set of minimum standards and protocols that allow the world to remain connected even as political systems diverge. Without such a framework, the “Fractured Circuit” may not only slow the pace of global innovation but also deepen the divide between the connected and the disconnected, leaving the most vulnerable nations to navigate a world of incompatible systems and dwindling choices.

  • When Negligence Becomes an Epidemic, a Wake-Up Cal…

    Health is the foundation upon which every nation builds its future. More specifically in Pakistan which is underdeveloped. No country can claim sustainable progress while its citizens continue to suffer from preventable diseases, unsafe medical practices, and a healthcare system weakened by negligence and poor governance. Unfortunately, Pakistan finds itself confronting these very challenges, where public awareness remains limited, people prefer malpractice upon the real HCPs, healthcare standards are inconsistently enforced, and accountability is often absent, (absence of accountability is the major issue in my opinion).   The recent reports of children allegedly contracting HIV following treatment at a healthcare facility in Karachi have deeply disturbed the nation. Whole Karachi is feeling a fear to go to any hospital, especially in public sector. Regardless of the outcome of ongoing investigations, the incident has exposed an uncomfortable reality, patient safety cannot be left to chance. A single lapse in infection control, sterilization, blood screening, or injection practices can permanently alter the lives of innocent patients and destroy public confidence in the healthcare system.   Healthcare is not merely about prescribing medicines or performing procedures. It is a responsibility that demands competence, discipline, ethical conduct, and strict adherence to internationally accepted standards. Every hospital, whether public or private, must operate under robust quality assurance systems. Sterilization protocols, infection prevention measures, waste disposal, blood safety, medication management, and continuous staff training are not optional, they are the minimum requirements for safe patient care. Equally concerning is the widespread public attitude toward health. Many people ignore symptoms until illnesses become severe. Self-medication, unqualified practitioners, unnecessary injections, and delayed medical consultation continue to place countless lives at risk. Public health awareness must become a national priority. Prevention is always less costly and more effective than treatment.   However, responsibility does not rest with the public alone. Healthcare institutions must also examine their own shortcomings. In many facilities across Sindh and other parts of Pakistan, shortages of trained professionals, inadequate supervision, poor infection control practices, and weak administrative oversight compromise patient safety. Quality healthcare cannot be delivered where merit is overlooked, competent professionals are undervalued, and management positions are assigned without the necessary expertise and accountability.   Healthcare administration should be treated as a specialized profession. Hospitals are complex organizations that require qualified leaders capable of managing clinical governance, quality improvement, patient safety, risk management, and human resources. Administrative decisions directly affect patient outcomes. Therefore, appointments to key management positions must be based on competence, experience, and professional qualifications rather than favoritism or administrative convenience. Another neglected area is the implementation of quality management systems. Every healthcare facility should maintain active infection control committees, medication safety programs, pharmacovigilance systems, incident reporting mechanisms, and regular internal audits. Compliance with national standards should not be limited to inspection days but should become part of everyday practice.   The role of pharmacists, nurses, laboratory professionals, infection control specialists, and other allied health professionals must also be strengthened. Modern healthcare depends upon multidisciplinary collaboration. Patient safety improves when every healthcare professional performs within clearly defined responsibilities and works together under an effective governance framework. Regulatory authorities also bear a significant responsibility. Licensing alone is insufficient. Regular inspections, transparent investigations, prompt corrective actions, and meaningful penalties for serious negligence are essential to restore public confidence. Accountability should never be selective. Whether the institution is public or private, patient safety must remain the highest priority.   Furthermore, Pakistan must invest substantially in continuous professional education. Medical knowledge evolves rapidly, and healthcare workers require regular training in infection prevention, patient safety, antimicrobial stewardship, emergency preparedness, and quality improvement. Competence is not achieved through qualification alone; it must be maintained throughout one’s professional career. The tragedy involving innocent children should not become another forgotten headline. It must serve as a turning point for meaningful healthcare reform. Every adverse event should encourage learning, strengthen systems, and prevent future harm rather than becoming another statistic buried in official reports.   A nation’s healthcare system reflects its collective values. If we tolerate negligence, ignore standards, and compromise merit, we inevitably place every patient at risk. But if we prioritize competence, accountability, transparency, and patient safety, Pakistan can build a healthcare system worthy of public trust.   The health of our people is not merely a medical issue; it is a national responsibility. Every citizen deserves safe treatment, every child deserves protection from preventable harm, and every healthcare institution must be held to the highest standards of professional excellence. The time for complacency has passed. The time for reform is now.

  • Stoning in the City of Letters: The Tragic Death o…

    ​Where the nine-hundred-year legacy of the University of Cambridge has long claimed to stand guard over truth, intellect, and reason, a profoundly agonizing incident has laid bare the deep intellectual, political, and social fault lines of the modern West. Professor Jason Arday—who made history as the youngest Black academic appointed to a professorship at Cambridge—was found dead at his home in South West London on August 14, 2026. To dismiss his sudden passing as a mere bodily collapse or a quiet, solitary cardiac arrest would be a profound act of self-deception. This tragedy is, in truth, the direct consequence of a systemic crisis eroding Western academia—a space where the fragile boundary separating legitimate academic rigor from ruthless political and racial factionalism has dissolved, and where institutional accountability has steadily devolved into a spectacle of public humiliation. ​Jason Arday’s ascent was a rare testament to human endurance and unyielding resolve. Raised in a low-income neighborhood in South London, he was diagnosed in early childhood with a severe form of autism. He remained non-verbal until the age of eleven and was unable to read or write until he was eighteen. Yet, defying both societal expectations and medical prognoses, he mastered the written and spoken word, pursued higher education, and navigated his way through the faculties of Roehampton, Durham, and Liverpool, ultimately securing a chair in sociology at Cambridge in March 2023. ​However, Arday’s arrival at the pinnacle of British academia coincided with an intense ideological war engulfing universities and the press. Over the preceding decade, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives had been elevated to core institutional imperatives across British higher education. Universities leaned into these metrics to rebrand themselves, and scholars of Arday’s caliber frequently became the public face of this transformation. ​This is precisely where the deeper ideological friction of contemporary British society erupted into what is widely characterized as a culture war. On one side stood a progressive consensus viewing DEI policies as a overdue corrective to historical inequities; on the other stood a relentless right-wing press and traditionalist academic factions that framed such appointments as a dilution of meritocracy and an embrace of ideological tokenism. ​When questions were subsequently raised regarding technical details within Arday’s PhD thesis and past curriculum vitae, the matter did not remain confined to quiet internal review. Right-leaning media outlets swiftly weaponized these allegations to mount a broader assault on Cambridge’s DEI framework. The tragedy of this partisan crossfire was that Arday’s humanity was entirely erased; he was reduced from a living, breathing scholar into a battlefield for competing political narratives. ​Academic integrity is undeniably the bedrock of any serious higher education system. When allegations of plagiarism are leveled against a scholar, a university is legally and ethically bound to conduct a thorough, impartial, and confidential inquiry. Yet, when such proceedings leak beyond institutional walls into the arena of tabloid journalism and political point-scoring, the genuine purpose of oversight is lost. ​Liverpool John Moores University had previously conducted a comprehensive investigation into the allegations against Arday, fully exonerating him and reaffirming the validity of his doctorate. However, the toxicity of commercialized media and political polarization ran too deep for that clearance to settle the matter. When Cambridge University, bowing to intense media pressure, announced a secondary independent review, it revealed just how vulnerable modern elite institutions have become to the demands of public relations. ​The most damning dimension of this ordeal was the existential and psychological toll exacted upon a scholar watching a lifetime of discipline destabilized in an instant. In his resignation statement on August 5, Arday explicitly clarified that stepping down was not an admission of guilt, but the final recourse of a human being pushed beyond the limits of endurance by a relentless media trial. Just nine days later, on August 14, 2026, he was dead. Neuroscience and clinical psychology have long documented how sustained public humiliation, character assassination, and the erasure of one’s professional identity can inflict severe somatic stress, culminating in fatal systemic collapse. ​This event casts a severe shadow over liberal democracies that pride themselves on individual dignity and the presumption of innocence. In a hyper-digitized media ecosystem, accusations function as instant convictions in the court of public opinion, long before an individual has a meaningful opportunity to offer a defense. Academia, which ought to serve as a sanctuary for measured deliberation, has proven just as susceptible to sensationalism as the rest of society. Arday’s death leaves scholars worldwide asking whether the academic vocation has shifted from the quiet pursuit of truth to a harrowing exercise in surviving public vilification. ​Jason Arday’s death compels an overdue reckoning: institutional accountability must be structured so that it neither shields genuine intellectual dishonesty nor surrenders an individual scholar to the crossfire of racial and culture wars. If elite universities fail to insulate their investigative processes from media trials and political agendas, the most sensitive and brilliant minds will inevitably retreat from the academic life altogether. Arday’s silence now stands as a profound question mark hanging over the international scholarly community. ​The ultimate lesson of this tragedy is that the dignity of those who dedicate their lives to learning cannot be sacrificed on the altar of political or journalistic expediency. If the institutions entrusted with seeking truth cannot protect their own, society loses its moral compass. Standing before the red-brick facade of Cambridge, one is left asking how a scholar of such promise could crumble on its doorstep. This was not merely the loss of a single life; it was an institutional failure that demands the grief and critical reflection of the global intellectual community. ​The extraordinary resilience with which Arday conquered his early disabilities demonstrated the scale of his ambition and character. Yet, faced with the cold machinery of institutional cowardice and media hostility, that strength was ultimately overwhelmed. This moment offers a final, urgent opportunity for self-examination within higher education. If we remain silent, the fires of ideological intolerance will continue to consume the very minds meant to illuminate

  • 79 Years of Independence and What Went Wrong with …

    On 14 August 1947, Pakistan emerged as a new country with enormous challenges but also extraordinary potential. Seventy-nine years later, the question is not whether Pakistan has achieved anything, it certainly has, but why a country that began with comparable hopes to many newly independent nations has struggled to convert its human and natural potential into sustained prosperity, strong institutions and a secure future. The comparison becomes uncomfortable when we look at countries that began their modern journeys around the same period. Singapore became self-governing in 1959 and independent in 1965. Bangladesh became independent in 1971 after emerging from the same Pakistan that had been created in 1947. Taiwan’s post-war transformation accelerated from the 1950s onward. South Korea, independent since 1948, also started from extraordinary hardship. Their histories are very different from Pakistan’s, so simplistic comparisons would be unfair. Yet they demonstrate one important principle, institutions, continuity, human capital and economic strategy can transform countries even when starting conditions are difficult. Bangladesh is perhaps the most striking comparison because it began as the poorer and more politically disadvantaged wing of Pakistan. In 1971, its future looked extremely uncertain. Today, Bangladesh’s nominal GDP per capita is substantially higher than Pakistan’s, the World Bank reports about $2,593 for Bangladesh compared with about $1,479 for Pakistan in 2024. Bangladesh’s total GDP has also grown larger than Pakistan’s despite having a much smaller land area according to world bank open data. Singapore represents an entirely different model. A small island with few natural resources, it concentrated on competent administration, education, trade, infrastructure, investment and institutional discipline. Its 2024 GDP per capita was approximately $90,674, compared with Pakistan’s approximately $1,479. World bank open data says. Taiwan and South Korea followed another path, export-oriented industrialisation, investment in education and technology, strong state capacity and, eventually, increasingly democratic institutions. These countries did not become successful because their people were inherently more capable than Pakistanis. They created systems that allowed capability to produce results. So what happened to Pakistan? The first failure was institutional continuity. Pakistan spent much of its history moving between civilian governments, military rule, political confrontation and constitutional crises. Instead of allowing institutions to mature, every political transition often became a struggle over who controlled the state. The second failure was the weak rule of law. A country cannot become prosperous when laws are applied selectively, institutions are politicised and citizens do not have equal confidence in justice. Democracy is not merely the holding of elections, it requires constitutional supremacy, independent institutions, accountable government and protection of fundamental rights. The third failure was education and human capital. Pakistan has a huge young population, yet education has too often remained underfunded, unequal and disconnected from the needs of a modern economy. Countries that transformed themselves invested heavily in the quality of their people. Pakistan has frequently treated education as expenditure rather than as the country’s most important investment. The fourth failure was economic inconsistency. Pakistan repeatedly moved between economic models without developing a stable, long-term national strategy. Political governments changed priorities, economic crises produced short-term fixes, dependence on external financing repeatedly returned. Meanwhile, countries such as Bangladesh built globally competitive export sectors, particularly garments, while East Asian economies moved aggressively into manufacturing, technology and high-value exports. The fifth failure was population planning and social development. Pakistan’s population has grown enormously, while economic growth has not consistently kept pace with the needs of its people. The World Bank’s latest figures show Pakistan with a life expectancy of around 68 years, compared with 75 years in Bangladesh and 83 years in Singapore. The sixth failure has been our inability to build a culture of accountability without political revenge. Accountability is essential, but when it becomes a weapon used selectively against political opponents, it destroys trust rather than strengthening the state. The seventh and perhaps deepest failure is that Pakistan repeatedly confused national security with national development. Security is essential, but a nation’s ultimate security comes from educated citizens, a productive economy, social cohesion, constitutional government and opportunities for its young people. Pakistan’s people, however, did not fail Pakistan. Pakistanis have demonstrated remarkable resilience. They built businesses, universities, industries, hospitals, technology companies and a vast overseas community. Millions of Pakistanis work abroad and send billions of dollars home. In 2024, remittances were equivalent to about 9.4% of Pakistan’s GDP, according to the World Bank. The real tragedy is that the capacity of the Pakistani people has repeatedly been greater than the capacity of the systems governing them. Independence was supposed to mean more than freedom from colonial rule. It was supposed to mean dignity, justice, representation and opportunity. After 79 years, Pakistan therefore needs a different question. Not who is responsible for our problems? but what kind of state do we want to become? The answer cannot be another political slogan or another temporary economic package or presidential system of government . Pakistan needs constitutional supremacy, civilian and institutional stability, independent justice, free media, serious investment in education and health, economic continuity, women’s participation in the workforce, export-led growth, technological development and genuine local governance. The comparison with Bangladesh, Singapore, Taiwan and South Korea should not produce humiliation. It should produce reflection. We began with a dream. The unfinished task of Pakistan’s next generation is to turn that dream into functioning institutions, human development and dignity for every citizen. Seventy-nine years after independence, perhaps the most patriotic thing Pakistanis can do is not merely celebrate the birth of the country, but honestly ask why the promise of 1947 has still not reached every Pakistani.

  • Concrete Jungle in the Hills: Is Unchecked High-Ri…

    For decades, Galiyat has been celebrated as one of Pakistan’s most picturesque mountain regions, renowned for its dense pine forests, breathtaking valleys, pleasant climate and rich biodiversity. Stretching across Nathia Gali, Ayubia, Dunga Gali and neighbouring hill stations, the region has long served as a sanctuary for nature lovers and a cornerstone of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s tourism industry. Today, however, its iconic landscape is undergoing a dramatic transformation. Multi-storey hotels, apartment complexes and commercial buildings are rapidly replacing forests and open green spaces, raising growing concerns among environmentalists, urban planners and local residents that unregulated development is threatening the ecological balance and natural heritage that have defined Galiyat for generations. Over the past decade, multi-storey hotels, apartment complexes and commercial buildings have spread across the region at an unprecedented pace. Hillsides that were once covered with forests and open green spaces are increasingly dominated by reinforced concrete structures. Critics argue that the changing skyline is gradually eroding the natural character that made Galiyat a unique tourist destination. The concerns extend beyond aesthetics. Environmental experts have long warned that excessive construction on steep mountain slopes can increase pressure on fragile ecosystems, reduce forest cover, disrupt natural drainage systems and heighten the risk of soil erosion and landslides. As climate change continues to intensify extreme weather events across northern Pakistan, many believe that poor land-use planning could further increase the vulnerability of mountain communities. These concerns have recently moved beyond public debate and into the corridors of government. A dispute has emerged between the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Adviser on Tourism and senior officials of the Galiyat Development Authority (GDA), bringing renewed attention to the regulation of construction in one of Pakistan’s most environmentally sensitive tourism regions. During a recent visit to Galiyat, the Adviser on Tourism questioned GDA Director General Fawad Khan regarding the allotment of more than five kanals of government land at the Changla Gali Rest Area and the subsequent construction of a hotel on the site. According to officials familiar with the matter, the adviser sought clarification on the legal basis for the allotment and whether all applicable rules and procedures had been followed. The issue gained further attention later the same day when GDA Director General Fawad Khan, Director Administration Noor-ul-Haq and Director Building Control Farukh Jadun submitted requests to the Chief Secretary of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa seeking transfers on what they described as “personal grounds.” The provincial government did not approve the requests, and the officers have continued to serve in their respective positions. The developments have intensified public discussion about how construction projects are approved in Galiyat and whether existing regulatory mechanisms are adequately protecting the region’s environmental heritage. They have also revived broader questions about institutional oversight, enforcement of building regulations and the balance between tourism development and environmental conservation. For many residents, the debate is not simply about individual buildings. It is about the long-term future of a mountain region whose economy depends on preserving the very landscape that continues to attract visitors from across Pakistan and abroad. The controversy surrounding high-rise construction has exposed deeper concerns about governance and regulatory oversight in the Galiyat region. At the centre of the debate are questions over which institution bears primary responsibility for approving construction projects and whether existing laws have been consistently enforced. Speaking in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Provincial Assembly, Tourism Adviser Adil Iqbal announced that he intended to recommend a high-level inquiry to Chief Minister Muhammad Sohail Khan Afridi. According to the adviser, the proposed inquiry would examine how permissions were granted for the construction of high-rise hotels, apartment buildings and other commercial structures that, according to his assessment, may not fully comply with the applicable building regulations. The adviser has argued that preserving Galiyat’s ecological balance is essential not only for environmental reasons but also for the long-term sustainability of the province’s tourism industry. He has maintained that development should proceed within the framework of environmental laws and approved planning regulations. Officials of the Galiyat Development Authority, however, reject suggestions that the authority alone should be held responsible for the current situation. GDA officials maintain that construction approvals in the region are not issued exclusively by their institution. According to the authority, the Tehsil Municipal Administration (TMA), operating under the provincial Local Government Department, also possesses legal authority to approve certain categories of building plans. This overlapping administrative structure has become one of the central issues in the ongoing debate. Critics argue that multiple approval authorities operating under different regulatory frameworks have created uncertainty over accountability. Supporters of regulatory reform believe that overlapping jurisdictions make enforcement difficult and allow developers to exploit differences between separate sets of building rules. The local civil society organisation, Galiyat Tahaffuz Movement, has been among the most vocal critics of the existing regulatory system. Representatives of the movement argue that both the GDA and the TMA have failed to effectively enforce planning regulations designed to protect the region’s fragile mountain environment. According to the organisation, building permits have, in some cases, been issued under political influence or administrative pressure. It further alleges that inconsistencies between separate building regulations have enabled developers to obtain approvals that might not have been possible under a single, uniformly enforced regulatory framework. The movement has repeatedly called for a comprehensive review of construction approvals, greater transparency in land-use decisions and the adoption of uniform building regulations across the Galiyat region. It also advocates stronger environmental impact assessments before permission is granted for major commercial developments. According to government sources, the disagreement between the Tourism Adviser and senior GDA officials has reached the office of Chief Minister Muhammad Sohail Khan Afridi. While the provincial government has not publicly commented on the reported differences, officials familiar with the matter say the administration is attempting to carefully assess the issues before deciding whether to order a formal inquiry. Sources suggest that the government faces a delicate administrative challenge. On one hand, it must respond to concerns regarding environmental protection and regulatory compliance. On the other, it must avoid

  • Beyond Public Finance: Towards Constitutional Poli…

    Taxation, constitutional legitimacy & fiscal justice The previous Part VII of this series traced the contributions of Abu Yusuf, Al-Ghazali, Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Maqrizi and Ibn Khaldun to public finance and political economy. Their works differed in purpose and historical setting, but a common normative framework emerged: justice in public burdens, accountability of authority, consultation in collective decisions, protection against arbitrary appropriation, honest exchange, responsible administration of public resources, wider circulation of wealth and protection of vulnerable citizens. These principles do not provide a ready-made tax code for a modern federation. They offer something more fundamental: standards by which taxation, expenditure and public authority may be judged. The same standards find expression in the constitutional order of Pakistan. Taxation is not legitimate merely because money is required by the state or because a provision has been inserted into a Finance Act. Parliament possesses wide legislative authority, but it is a creature of the Constitution and not its master. It cannot validly enact what the Constitution prohibits, invade a field constitutionally assigned elsewhere or destroy rights and limitations that bind every organ of the state. The proposition appears elementary. Pakistan’s fiscal practice repeatedly ignores it. Article 77 of the Constitution provides that no federal tax shall be levied except by or under the authority of an Act of Parliament. This embodies the historic principle of no taxation without representation. Revenue cannot be extracted through executive preference, administrative instruction or unstructured discretion. Legislative authority must exist. Article 77 is a necessary condition for lawful taxation, not a complete test of constitutional legitimacy. A tax enacted by Parliament must also conform to the distribution of legislative powers, equality before law, due process, protection of property and other constitutional guarantees. Parliamentary form cannot cure substantive constitutional defect. Otherwise, the requirement of constitutional supremacy would be reduced to the proposition that Parliament may do anything so long as it records the command in statutory language. Pakistan is not governed under parliamentary sovereignty in the British sense. It is governed under a written and supreme Constitution. Legislative authority is not unlimited authority The Constitution divides taxing powers between the Federation and provinces. Parliament cannot convert a provincial subject into a federal one merely by changing its label. A levy upon capital value cannot automatically become income tax because it is placed in the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001. A tax upon services cannot be extended to transactions lacking the character of a service merely because additional revenue is desired. The true nature, subject matter and effect of the levy remain decisive. This is particularly important because fiscal pressures create incentives to stretch legislative entries beyond their constitutional purpose. Governments confronting debt servicing, defence expenditure and programme targets naturally seek accessible revenue. Constitutional limitations exist precisely because necessity, convenience and expediency cannot be allowed to determine the boundaries of public power. A Constitution does not become less binding when the treasury is empty. The Supreme Court’s jurisprudence has recognised that Parliament’s taxing competence, though broad, is not without constitutional limits. In Elahi Cotton Mills, the Court accepted substantial legislative latitude in taxation, including the use of legal fictions, classifications and presumptive methods. It also made clear that the legislature cannot tax as “income” something that cannot rationally possess the character of income. The breadth of a legislative entry does not eliminate its essential subject matter.  The same discipline must govern every fiscal enactment. Equality is not arithmetical uniformity Article 25 guarantees equality before law and equal protection of law. Equality does not require every person, transaction or source of income to be taxed identically. Legislatures may classify taxpayers and activities where a real distinction exists and the classification bears a rational relationship to the purpose of the law. The power to classify cannot become a licence to privilege. Pakistan’s tax system contains numerous distinctions based upon source, status, sector, documentation and bargaining power. Salary, dividends, profit on debt, business income, contracts, imports, property income and capital gains are frequently subjected to different rates and regimes. Some differentiation may be justified by collection realities or constitutional allocation. Much of it has emerged through political accommodation rather than coherent principle. A constitutional analysis must therefore ask whether similarly situated persons are treated alike, whether distinctions correspond to genuine economic differences, and whether the burden imposed is reasonably connected with the stated objective. Higher transactional taxes upon “non-filers”, for example, are presented as instruments of documentation. Their constitutional and economic legitimacy becomes doubtful when they operate indefinitely as revenue measures without determining actual income, establishing liability or bringing the person into a genuine assessment system. A temporary incentive to file cannot become a permanent substitute for income taxation. Due process in fiscal administration Article 4 protects the right of every person to be dealt with in accordance with law. Tax administration must consequently involve more than statutory authority to demand money. Liability must be determined through fair procedures, relevant evidence, a meaningful opportunity to respond and access to independent adjudication. Automated notices, coercive recovery, attachment of accounts, blocked refunds and repeated demands without proper examination undermine this constitutional relationship. Technology does not suspend due process. Digital systems can improve matching, risk identification and transparency. They cannot transform an algorithmic suspicion into established liability. The taxpayer must know the basis of the demand, confront the material relied upon and obtain a reasoned determination from a legally competent authority. A revenue system that collects first and examines legality later converts constitutional administration into fiscal compulsion. The Supreme Court’s judgment in Mustafa Impex also reinforced the constitutional identity of executive authority. Statutory powers assigned to the Federal Government cannot automatically be exercised by an individual minister, division or official unless the constitutional and statutory framework permits it. Fiscal measures made through notifications and delegated authority must remain within the limits imposed by the parent legislation and the constitutional structure of government.  Delegation may supply machinery. It cannot create a new taxable event, enlarge the charge or transfer essential legislative choices to the executive. Property,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *