| | |

Supreme Court bars fresh claims after final contra…

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court of Pakistan has ruled that contractors cannot pursue additional financial claims or seek arbitration after voluntarily accepting a final settlement, reinforcing the binding nature of contractual agreements.

A three-member bench headed by Chief Justice Yahya Afridi, alongside Justice Irfan Saadat Khan and Justice Aqeel Ahmed Abbasi, dismissed a petition seeking permission to appeal against an earlier ruling of the Peshawar High Court. Justice Irfan Saadat Khan authored the judgment.

The dispute originated from a construction contract awarded in December 1993 for the Hayatabad Medical Complex in Peshawar. During the project, the contractor sought additional payments, citing delays and funding shortages.

According to the judgment, the company later accepted Rs88.555 million as final payment and signed a No Demand Certificate, formally giving up its right to pursue further financial claims under the contract.

Despite the settlement, the contractor subsequently approached the courts seeking arbitration over additional demands. The trial court and the Peshawar High Court rejected the request, and the Supreme Court has now upheld those decisions.

The apex court clarified that once a party willingly accepts final payment and signs a No Demand Certificate, it cannot reopen financial claims or invoke arbitration unless it can establish that the settlement was secured through fraud, coercion or undue influence.

The court stressed that voluntarily concluded agreements must remain enforceable, particularly in public-sector development projects where contractual certainty is essential. It warned that allowing settled disputes to be reopened without evidence of wrongdoing could weaken confidence in contracts and create uncertainty in commercial dealings.

Similar Posts

  • |

    Historic floods leave at least six dead in Indiana

    At least six people have died in the US state of Indiana after severe storms brought record-breaking rainfall and triggered widespread flooding. Authorities said several areas received more than 11 inches of rain over two days. The heavy rainfall caused the White River to rise rapidly, flooding communities and forcing large-scale rescue operations. More than 90 people and 45 pets were rescued from flooded areas, according to local authorities. The worst flooding was reported along the White River, stretching from Hamilton County towards the northern suburbs of Indianapolis. Several neighbourhoods were left under water. In Indianapolis, floodwaters submerged vehicles and reached residential properties. Some residents used kayaks and small boats to move through streets that had turned into waterways. The White River rose above 24 feet in Anderson and Noblesville. The level exceeded records set during the major flooding of 1913, highlighting the severity of the disaster. Indianapolis Mayor Joe Hogsett declared a local emergency and urged people living near the river to leave their homes if authorities advised evacuation. Emergency officials described the flooding as an unprecedented event. Marion County Emergency Management director Jacob Spence said the scale of the disaster was unlike anything recently experienced in the area. Several counties reported storm-related deaths. One woman, aged 58, was found dead in Delaware County after apparently attempting to drive through floodwaters. Authorities also confirmed fatalities in Jennings, White, Porter and La Porte counties. Indiana Governor Mike Braun said he had spoken with US President Donald Trump about the disaster. He said a request for a federal emergency declaration was being processed to speed up assistance for affected communities. Braun expressed sympathy for the families who lost loved ones and urged residents to remain cautious. He warned people to stay away from flooded roads and fast-moving water. The National Weather Service continued to issue flood warnings across parts of central Indiana. Officials warned that water levels were still rising in some locations. More severe weather was also expected. Emergency authorities urged residents to monitor official warnings and avoid unnecessary travel. The storms were not limited to Indiana. Tornadoes, intense rainfall and flash flooding affected several parts of the US Midwest. Damage was reported across a broad area stretching from the Chicago region towards western Pennsylvania.

  • | |

    Shan baig, Roma Michael tie the knot in sweet social media reveal

    Shan Baig and model Roma Michael have officially tied the knot, delighting fans across the entertainment industry with a heartwarming marriage announcement shared online. The newlyweds made their union public through a cheerful photo update, instantly drawing widespread love and congratulations from followers, colleagues, and showbiz portals alike. ​The joyous announcement gained traction after popular entertainment page Galaxy Lollywood highlighted the couple’s milestone, sharing a cozy picture of the duo celebrating their new beginning together. In the picture, a radiant Shan Baig is seen smiling beside Roma Michael, wearing a casual shirt and cap, while Roma looks effortless in a graceful white embroidered outfit. Adding an extra touch of sweetness to the post, Baig tagged his bride on social media with a simple yet affectionate label: “Wifey.” ​The subtle, sweet confirmation quickly sent waves through social media, with fans flooding the comments section to express their surprise and joy for the couple. Many showered the post with red hearts and warm prayers, wishing them a lifetime of love, happiness, and peace in this new phase of life. Fellow fraternity members and media personalities also joined in to extend their best wishes to the newly married couple. ​Both Shan Baig and Roma Michael have built well-recognized profiles in Pakistan’s media landscape through their respective work in acting and modeling. While the couple kept their relationship relatively quiet prior to the big news, their charming reveal offered fans a glimpse into their close bond. As they step into married life together, well-wishers continue to celebrate the pair and wish them endless happiness on their new journey as husband and wife.

  • | |

    Evergrande founder handed life sentence as court s…

    The founder of Evergrande, the Chinese property giant whose collapse triggered a nationwide housing market crisis, has been sentenced to life in prison and stripped of all personal property. Hui Ka Yan pleaded guilty in April to multiple charges, including embezzling assets and corporate bribery. The Shenzhen Intermediate People’s Court also imposed fines totaling 15.82 billion yuan, roughly £1.73 billion or $2.35 billion, on his former companies over a range of offenses that included falsifying financial records and concealing debt. The sentencing marks a major turning point in the fallout from Evergrande’s collapse, which shook China’s property sector and inflicted heavy losses on investors and domestic banks alike. The court said Hui and his businesses seriously disrupted the Chinese property market, causing significant economic damage. Other former Evergrande executives, including Hui’s two sons Xu Zhijian and Xu Tenghe, received jail terms ranging from 22 months to 18 years, according to Chinese state media. Once ranked as Asia’s richest man, Hui has watched his fortune and influence collapse alongside his company. Also known as Xu Jiayin, he grew up in rural China raised by his grandmother before entering the property industry and founding Evergrande in 1996. He guided the company through a period of rapid expansion fueled by heavy borrowing, eventually building Evergrande into China’s largest real estate developer with a stock market valuation exceeding $50 billion, roughly £36.7 billion. At his peak, Hui held the distinction of being Asia’s wealthiest individual. The company suffered a major setback when Beijing introduced new measures in 2020 aimed at curbing debt across the property sector. As Evergrande struggled to keep up with interest payments, it began selling properties at steep discounts to stay afloat before ultimately collapsing in 2021. Court proceedings in April revealed that the company had taken in millions of dollars in pre sale funds from prospective homebuyers that were never used for the construction they were intended to finance. Instead, that money was redirected toward new development projects, leaving hundreds of housing projects unfinished. In March 2024, Hui was separately fined $6.5 million and banned for life from China’s capital markets after regulators found the company had overstated its revenue by $78 billion. Evergrande’s stock market value shrank by 99 percent before the company’s shares were delisted from the Hong Kong exchange in August 2025, ending more than fifteen years of trading. The company’s implosion is widely seen as a key trigger for the broader downturn in China’s property market that continues to weigh on the country’s economy. At its peak, Evergrande stood as the largest firm in an industry that accounted for roughly a third of China’s gross domestic product, serving as both a major driver of economic growth and a critical revenue source for local governments. The sector’s ongoing troubles have continued to pressure the world’s second largest economy, with several other major developers facing their own financial distress in the years since Evergrande’s fall.

  • | |

    PPP, PML-N hold unity talks over AJK polls

    Senior leaders of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) and the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) held a high-level meeting in Muzaffarabad on Thursday to defuse growing political tensions over the ongoing Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) elections. The meeting came after days of heated exchanges between the two coalition partners following the Mirpur election. The PPP had accused the electoral process of being marred by widespread irregularities and raised concerns over the credibility of the results. According to sources, the talks were aimed at preventing the election dispute from affecting the working relationship between the two parties in the federal coalition government. The meeting was reportedly arranged after consultations at the federal level. Some sources claimed that the initiative received support from both the Presidency and the Prime Minister’s Office. However, this could not be independently verified. The PPP delegation included Qamar Zaman Kaira, Nadeem Afzal Chan, AJK Prime Minister Faisal Rathore and Nayyar Bukhari. They met with senior PML-N leaders Rana Sanaullah and Amir Muqam. During the meeting, both sides openly discussed their concerns over statements made during the election campaign and after the announcement of the Mirpur results. PML-N leaders asked the PPP to present evidence supporting its allegations of organised election rigging. In response, PPP leaders said their objections were limited to four constituencies — LA-5, LA-9, LA-11 and LA-12 — where they believe serious irregularities took place. PML-N leaders argued that by restricting its objections to only four constituencies, the PPP had effectively accepted the results of the remaining nine seats. They noted that PML-N won five of those seats, while the PPP secured four. After detailed discussions, both parties agreed that political tensions should not be allowed to escalate further. They also agreed that the dispute should not affect the remaining phases of the AJK elections. The meeting also reviewed security arrangements for polling in the remaining constituencies, particularly in Muzaffarabad. Both parties agreed that no individual should be allowed to carry weapons inside or around polling stations. They stressed that strict security measures were necessary to ensure peaceful, transparent and orderly polling. Political observers view the meeting as the first major reconciliation effort by the two coalition partners to contain the election dispute

  • | | |

    PM to decide fate of refinery upgrade policy

    Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif is expected to address key issues facing Pakistan’s refinery sector today. The Cabinet Committee on Energy (CCoE) will review proposed changes to the Brownfield Refinery Policy.The policy was approved in 2023. It aims to encourage investment in the modernisation of existing refineries. The proposed changes could affect billions of dollars in planned refinery investments.The main dispute is over deemed duty protection. The government has proposed reducing it from 7.5 per cent to 5 per cent. Refinery companies have opposed the proposed cut. They say it could weaken the financial benefits offered under the policy.The industry also disputes the government’s position on delays in signing Upgrade Agreements. Officials say refineries failed to sign the agreements within the required period.Refinery representatives reject the claim. They say they had already accepted the draft agreements in 2024. According to industry officials, the companies were waiting for the government to arrange the formal signing process.They say the industry repeatedly contacted the Petroleum Division and other authorities to complete the process. The companies argue that the delay was caused by administrative issues on the government side.They therefore believe the incentives should not be reduced because of delays beyond their control. Deemed duty protection is a key part of the refinery upgrade package.The incentive is designed to encourage companies to invest in modernisation. The planned upgrades are aimed at increasing production of Euro-V compliant fuels.They are also expected to reduce furnace oil production. The projects could help improve Pakistan’s overall fuel mix.The refining sector has also faced additional financial pressure from changes in the tax system. The Finance Act 2024 moved several petroleum products from the zero-rated sales tax regime to the exempt category.The change affected the ability of refineries to adjust input sales tax. It also increased their unrecoverable tax costs.The Petroleum Division has acknowledged that the tax changes affected the financial viability of refinery upgrade projects. Officials said the prime minister is expected to review the major issues that have delayed the implementation of the policy since August 2023.The Petroleum Division has proposed limited amendments to make the policy operational. It has also recommended a committee to finalise the Upgrade Agreement.The committee would include senior officials from the Petroleum Division, Law Division and OGRA. A representative of the Special Investment Facilitation Council would also be included.OGRA, however, has reservations about signing the agreements. OGRA Chairman Masroor Khan has argued that the regulator should focus on its regulatory role.He believes OGRA should not become a party to commercial agreements. The refinery industry is now hoping for a decision that removes the remaining hurdles.Companies want the government to maintain the existing incentive structure. They say policy consistency is important for attracting investment.They also warn that changes to agreed incentives could discourage investors. A clear decision by the CCoE could help restart delayed refinery upgrade projects.The decision could also influence Pakistan’s fuel supply and long-term energy security.

  • | | |

    Iran declares CDF Asim Munir’s visit highly prod…

    The Iranian government has described Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir’s recent visit to Iran as highly productive, saying the trip resulted in important diplomatic progress and strengthened engagement between the two countries. According to a statement from the Iranian Presidential Office, the visit produced beneficial outcomes and provided an opportunity for detailed discussions on matters of mutual interest. The Iranian side said several important issues were discussed during the visit. The talks also focused on strengthening bilateral engagement and maintaining close communication between Pakistan and Iran. Iranian presidential official Syed Mehdi Tabatabai described the visit as a diplomatic success. He said the discussions had produced valuable results and could contribute to further progress in relations between the two neighbouring countries. The Iranian Presidential Office said the outcomes of the visit would begin to emerge in the coming days. It indicated that follow-up measures would be important in translating the understandings reached during the visit into practical steps. The visit took place at a time of heightened tensions in the region. Pakistan and Iran have maintained close consultations on regional security and political developments, while seeking to strengthen bilateral coordination. The Iranian assessment of Field Marshal Asim Munir’s visit reflects Tehran’s positive view of the discussions and their potential impact on bilateral relations. The visit is also expected to contribute to continued diplomatic engagement between Islamabad and Tehran on regional issues and areas of common interest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *