vantage point solar
| | | | |

[Vantage Point] Solar Para sa Bayan: When public privilege meets accountability

The timing could hardly be worse: Loren Legarda and Leandro Leviste left the country just two days after the Ombudsman disclosed a plunder and graft investigation into their solar ventures. Their departure proves no wrongdoing, but combined with Lito Atienza’s willingness to testify under oath about an alleged P10-million government sweetener, it has turned a complicated solar controversy into an escalating test of credibility, accountability and political survival.

Sometimes the most damaging political statement is the one nobody intended to make. 

On July 31, Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla disclosed that plunder and graft complaints against Senator Loren Legarda, her son Batangas Representative Leandro Legarda Leviste, and former Energy secretary Alfonso Cusi had reached preliminary investigation, the final investigative stage before prosecutors decide whether to bring the accusations to court. 

Two days later, on August 2, mother and son left the Philippines on separate flights. The Bureau of Immigration says neither had a derogatory record preventing departure. Legarda has urged the public not to connect her travel with allegations she calls “false and baseless.” Legally, she is right that departure proves nothing. Politically, however, the optics could hardly be worse.

The chronology has since grown longer. Legarda went on medical leave from the Senate from August 3 to 5 and has now filed another medical leave covering August 11 and 12. 

Again, illness should neither be questioned nor converted into evidence of wrongdoing without proof. But politics does not operate inside a laboratory. Timing, conduct, and credibility inevitably shape public judgment. 

Legarda and Leviste were legally free to travel and should not be described as fugitives. Yet the public sees an Ombudsman announcement on July 31, departure on August 2, and continuing absence from the Senate thereafter. 

Each event has an innocent explanation. Together, they have created precisely the perception Legarda has asked the public not to draw.

First-hand witness

Then there is Lito Atienza. The former Manila mayor, congressman, and environment secretary says he is prepared to testify about something potentially more consequential than bad optics: a personal encounter. Atienza alleges that Legarda herself sought his support for the solar venture associated with her son and offered to help him obtain P10 million in government funding after he resisted. He says he refused because he had already developed serious reservations about the project. 

The allegation remains unproven. But if Atienza executes an affidavit and repeats his account under oath, investigators would have something qualitatively different from an inference based on a mother-son relationship—a purported first-hand witness describing an alleged conversation with Legarda herself.

Atienza’s testimony alone would not establish guilt. His credibility must be tested, his story corroborated where possible, and Legarda given every opportunity to rebut it. But his account could provide what complex corruption investigations often need: connective tissue.

Documents can show what government approved. Corporate records can show who owned what. Financial records can establish where money moved. A credible first-hand witness may help investigators determine why official actions occurred and whether political intervention played any role. That is why Atienza potentially presents a more difficult problem for the defense than another accusation from a political adversary.


[Vantage Point] Solar Para sa Bayan: When public privilege meets accountability

The numbers behind the solar controversy explain why the Ombudsman investigation matters. Department of Energy (DOE) records show that 33 renewable-energy service contracts held by Solar Philippines Power Project Holdings Inc. were terminated after projects failed to meet commitments, representing about 11,427.83 megawatts (MW) of prospective generating capacity. 

Solar Philippines alone accounted for roughly 64% of the total capacity covered by renewable-energy service contracts terminated or relinquished nationwide during 2024 and 2025. The DOE has estimated about P24 billion in performance bonds and other contractual and financial obligations associated with the failed commitments. 

These contracts belonged to Solar Philippines Power Project Holdings—not Solar Para sa Bayan or SP New Energy Corp., an important corporate distinction that should not be blurred.

That distinction, however, does not diminish the public-interest question. Renewable-energy service contracts are not ordinary commercial possessions. They are government-granted rights that reserve development opportunities while imposing obligations to turn those opportunities into generating capacity.

DOE Secretary Sharon Garin has said cancelled contracts will be opened to new developers, underscoring the opportunity cost involved when an awarded project does not proceed. Every undeveloped contract potentially represents electricity that was not generated, capital that was not deployed, and an opportunity another qualified developer might have pursued.

Leviste has argued that projects failed because permits could not be secured and has denied profiting from selling the Solar Para sa Bayan franchise. That defense deserves to be examined precisely rather than rhetorically. 

Saying one did not profit from selling a franchise does not necessarily answer whether economic value was created or monetized through shares, affiliated companies or project rights. (READ: Ombudsman Remulla says Leviste being probed for ‘selling’ solar franchise to Pangilinan)

In renewable-energy development, substantial corporate value can exist before a plant produces its first kilowatt-hour. The proper forensic inquiry therefore remains documentary: which companies held which contracts; when equity interests changed hands; at what valuations; what consideration was received; and who ultimately carried the liabilities when projects failed to materialize?

This is also why Legarda’s defense that “no public funds were involved” does not fully dispose of the controversy. Public resources are not confined to money released from the Treasury. 

A franchise, concession or exclusive development right is itself a privilege created by the State. If government action gives one private party an economic opportunity unavailable to others, the public is entitled to ask whether the corresponding obligations were fulfilled. That is not proof of plunder or graft. It is the fundamental accountability bargain underlying every government-granted privilege.

The case should now move away from slogans and toward documents, money trails and sworn testimony.

Legarda and Leviste remain presumed innocent. Their departure proves neither conspiracy nor an intention to evade justice, and Atienza’s allegation remains exactly that until tested. 

But mother and son face a political problem increasingly difficult to solve with denials alone. An Ombudsman investigation reaches its decisive stage. They leave the country two days later. Legarda’s absence from the Senate continues.

A veteran public official says he is prepared to testify that she personally offered him a P10-million government allocation to support her son’s solar venture. Behind all of this sit 33 terminated contracts, more than 11,400 MW of unrealized projects and roughly P24 billion in potential contractual and financial obligations.

None individually proves criminal guilt. Together, however, they create a formidable credibility problem—and one that can ultimately be resolved only by evidence, under oath. – Rappler.com

Below are Vantage Point articles related to the Leviste solar controversy:

Below are some Vantage Point pieces you might have missed:

Click here for other Vantage Point articles.

Similar Posts

  • |

    PSX rallies above 181,000 as investors return to key sectors

    KARACHI: Positive momentum returned to the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) on Monday as investors stepped up buying activity across major sectors, pushing the benchmark KSE-100 Index above the 181,000-point mark during the opening phase of trading. At around 9:40am, the benchmark index was trading at 181,066.59 points, showing an increase of 961.98 points, or 0.53%, compared with the previous close. The early-session recovery reflected renewed investor interest in large-cap and index-heavy companies. Buying was particularly visible across automobile assemblers, cement, commercial banking, fertiliser, oil and gas exploration, oil marketing companies (OMCs), power generation and refinery sectors. Among the major stocks supporting the upward movement were Mari Petroleum (MARI), Oil and Gas Development Company (OGDC), Pakistan Petroleum Limited (PPL), Pakistan Oilfields Limited (POL), Hub Power Company (HUBCO), Habib Bank Limited (HBL), MCB Bank, Meezan Bank Limited (MEBL) and United Bank Limited (UBL). Most of these index-heavy shares traded in positive territory during the initial hours. The recovery came after a difficult week for the domestic equity market. The KSE-100 Index had closed the previous week at 180,104.61 points, declining by 1,325.41 points, or 0.7% on a week-on-week basis. Market sentiment had been affected by heightened geopolitical uncertainty, particularly concerns over the future of the US-Iran ceasefire and the potential impact of regional tensions on international energy supplies. Investors also remained cautious over developments affecting shipping activity around the Strait of Hormuz and the Red Sea, both of which are critical routes for global energy and trade. Despite the pressure on equities, Pakistan’s domestic fiscal position and external-sector indicators had provided some support to investor confidence. However, geopolitical developments continued to dominate trading decisions, particularly because any prolonged disruption to oil supplies could raise import costs and increase inflationary pressures. Global markets remain cautious The cautious mood was also evident across international markets on Monday. Asian equities moved largely sideways as investors monitored developments in the Middle East and assessed the implications for energy prices and global inflation. Oil prices recorded significant gains during the previous week as uncertainty surrounding efforts to end the Iran conflict increased concerns about potential supply disruptions. Investors remained particularly focused on developments concerning the strategic Strait of Hormuz, where tanker traffic had remained disrupted amid the continuing tensions. Iran on Saturday called on the United States to acknowledge defeat, while US President Donald Trump warned Americans that higher gasoline prices could persist as long as the conflict continued. The situation in the wider region also remained volatile. In southern Lebanon, Israeli strikes on Saturday killed at least 11 people, according to the Lebanese health ministry. The casualties came amid renewed tensions following an earlier US-mediated framework aimed at easing hostilities between Lebanon and Israel. Oil prices remain elevated Crude oil prices remained at elevated levels on Monday after recording strong gains during the previous week. Brent crude was trading around $88.50 per barrel, little changed during the session after climbing approximately 6% last week. Meanwhile, US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude slipped around 0.3% to $82.12 per barrel, following a weekly gain of about 5.4%. Higher international oil prices remain a key concern for oil-importing economies such as Pakistan because a sustained increase can widen the import bill, put pressure on the current account and contribute to domestic inflation. For investors at the PSX, developments in global energy markets are particularly important because oil and gas companies have significant representation in the benchmark index, while higher fuel costs can also affect the profitability of other industries. Asian equities mixed In regional markets, MSCI’s broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan was broadly flat on Monday. Japan’s Nikkei 225, meanwhile, gained around 0.4%. The mixed performance reflected investor caution as markets continued to assess the potential economic consequences of prolonged geopolitical tensions. Concerns over energy prices, inflation and interest-rate expectations remained central to global market sentiment. At the PSX, however, the strong opening suggested that domestic investors were willing to look beyond short-term geopolitical concerns and accumulate fundamentally strong stocks. Whether the KSE-100 can sustain its early gains will depend on developments in global oil markets, regional tensions and trading activity in heavyweight sectors as the session progresses.

  • | | | | | | |

    Lea Salonga dedicates Hollywood Walk of Fame star to village that shaped her

    ‘There’s something funny about a star like this because there’s only room for one name: mine. But no career is ever the work of just one person. So if they made this star big enough, there would be a lot of other names on it,’ says Lea Salonga, the first Filipina to receive her own Hollywood Walk of Fame star

  • | | | | | | | | | | |

    [Vantage Point] Tubig Pilipinas’ backdoor listing move opens into another suspension

    A dormant coal shell refashions itself into a piped-water holding enterprise

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *