population debate curse

The Population Debate: Curse or Opportunity?

By Dr Naveeda Katper

Different countries have different characteristics regarding population, geography, and natural resources that shape their economic growth. Economists use various indicators to measure development, and population is one of the most debated among them. A large population is often viewed as a hurdle to economic growth. However, every issue deserves to be examined from different angles. The question, “Is a large population a curse or a blessing?” cannot be answered with a simple yes or no. We need to move beyond the idea of population as a burden and understand the concept of the demographic dividend. What appears to be a curse can become a blessing when viewed through the right perspective and supported by the right policies. Research by the RAND Corporation and the World Bank has shown that countries with a growing working-age population can experience faster economic growth when supported by sound education, health, and employment policies.

Whether a large population becomes an economic asset depends on governance and public policy. A growing population is not necessarily a curse because every additional mind brings new ideas, different perspectives, and fresh solutions to existing problems. One mind can accomplish one task, two minds can accomplish two, and millions of minds can achieve far more. That is the value of teamwork and collective human potential. Every individual possesses different skills, abilities, and talents that can contribute to national development. What many consider a burden may actually become a country’s greatest strength if those human resources are properly developed. This is the essence of the demographic dividend—the economic advantage that emerges when the working-age population becomes larger than the dependent population. Development economists describe this period as a “window of opportunity” rather than a guaranteed outcome.

Highly populated countries can utilize their youthful population to strengthen their economies. After India, China, the United States, and Indonesia, Pakistan is the fifth most populous country in the world. This should be seen as an opportunity rather than a challenge because more than 65 percent of Pakistan’s population consists of young people. That gives the country a significant advantage. A demographic dividend can only be realized when the working-age population is educated, healthy, skilled, and productively employed. When more people are working and contributing to the economy, household savings increase, investment grows, government spending on dependents declines, and both economic output and per capita income improve. The World Bank has repeatedly emphasized that human capital—education, health, and skills—is one of the strongest drivers of long-term productivity and national income.

The real challenge is identifying the policies required to achieve this dividend. A country can benefit only if it creates sufficient employment opportunities, provides quality education and skill development, ensures access to healthcare, encourages women to participate in the workforce, and maintains stable economic and public policies. When these conditions exist, the country enjoys faster economic growth, greater productivity, increased investment and savings, improved living standards, and stronger entrepreneurship and innovation. Economic growth becomes inevitable when people are hardworking, equipped with multiple skills from an early age, and capable of adapting to changing economic demands. Skilled and self-reliant citizens become the driving force of national development. Evidence from South Korea, Singapore, and Ireland shows that investment in education and skills transformed youthful populations into globally competitive economies.

However, a demographic dividend can quickly become a demographic burden if employment opportunities and skills do not keep pace with population growth. The consequences may include rising unemployment, poverty, social unrest, and migration. Economists and demographers consistently argue that a demographic dividend is not automatic; it is an opportunity that must be earned through effective governance and strong institutions. Without adequate planning and investment, a large youth population can become a liability instead of an asset. The International Labour Organization has warned that persistent youth unemployment can reduce economic productivity and increase social instability.

A dynamic economy capable of creating millions of formal-sector jobs each year is essential for absorbing a growing workforce. Human capital development should remain at the center of national policy. Strong educational systems, Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET), science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM), digital literacy, coding, digital finance, and technology-based curricula should be introduced from the early years of education. Equal opportunities for girls and women in education and employment are equally important. Pakistan also needs job creation, labour market reforms, export-led manufacturing, labour flexibility, investment in high-value industries such as technology, electronics, and specialized services, support for youth entrepreneurship and microfinance, and stronger healthcare infrastructure. UNESCO has consistently highlighted that technical and vocational education equips young people with practical skills that improve employability and economic resilience.

Pakistan possesses one of the largest youth populations in the region, but this advantage can only be realized through greater investment in education, skills, and employment. In conclusion, population control alone is not a long-term solution to economic growth. Developing people’s abilities, expanding opportunities, and investing in human capital are far more effective. The experiences of countries such as Italy and Japan also demonstrate that declining populations and ageing societies create their own economic challenges. The real question is not how many people a country has, but how well it prepares its people to contribute to national development. Research across both developed and developing countries consistently concludes that people become an economic asset when governments invest in their education, health, productivity, and opportunities rather than viewing population solely as a number.

The writer holds a PhD from Malaysia and writes on economic development, public policy, and demographic issues. She can be reached at naveedakatper11@gmail.com

Similar Posts

  • |

    Echoes of 1971 in Pakistan’s Kashmir policy

    History rarely repeats itself in exact terms, but it frequently rhymes through patterns of power, dissent and state responses. In Pakistan, analysts and political observers are increasingly highlighting the parallels between historical missteps. It is specifically the events leading up to the loss of East Pakistan in 1971 and the contemporary public grievances in Pakistan-administered Kashmir. The Cost of Ignoring Electoral Mandates In 1970, General Yahya Khan permitted general elections across Pakistan. The Awami League in East Pakistan secured a decisive democratic victory by winning 162 out of 300 national seats. However, rather than facilitating a peaceful transfer of power, military leaders stalled negotiations in Dhaka through early 1971. This breakdown in dialogue culminated in Operation Searchlight, a military crackdown targeting intellectuals, students, and Bengali civilians. The resulting violence triggered a massive refugee crisis. Approximately ten million people were sent to India. A war that ultimately led to the creation of Bangladesh. Pakistan’s own Hamoodur Rahman Commission concluded that political failure and operational excess by military leadership were central to the catastrophe. Despite these official findings, the report remained suppressed for decades, leaving fundamental lessons about the dangers of military overreach largely unexamined within state institutions.  Unrest in Pakistan-Controlled Kashmir Today, army leadership under General Asim Munir continues to champion strong nationalistic rhetoric regarding Kashmir. He has been asserting it as the nation’s core and a willingness to fight further conflicts over Indian-administered territory. Yet, a  different internal dynamic has been evolving since 2025 within the territories Pakistan actually controls. Local populations have mobilized in widespread demonstrations driven by clear economic and political grievances. Unmanageable costs for basic essential goods. Disproportionately high pricing for local power distribution. Legislative structures that assign disproportionate authority to mainland administrators rather than local residents. State institutions responded with heavy-handed measures rather than operating for meaningful negotiation. The organizing groups were banned, communication blackouts were implemented and arrests occurred. Security forces deployed live fire against demonstrators  and caused dozens of civilian casualties. The Danger of Ignoring Unheard Grievances The concern raised by historians is not that history will reproduce the exact outcome of 1971, but that the state is relying on the same flawed logic. State is again attempting to suppress domestic economic and political grievances through state force. When state policy prioritizes coercion over political engagement, it risks alienating populations. The lingering question for Pakistan’s establishment is whether the lessons of past governance failures will finally be integrated, or whether suppressed grievances will once again lead to deep institutional crises.  

  • Simple style tips for men

    Looking stylish is not always about wearing expensive brands. Good fitting the right colors clean shoes and attention to small details can make a big difference. Fashion trends keep changing but some basic style rules can help men look smart confident and well dressed at any age. The key is to understand your body shape, personal taste and what makes you feel comfortable. Make fit your top priority Even an expensive outfit can look bad if it does not fit properly. When buying shirts or jackets pay close attention to the shoulders and chest. Pants and suits can often be improved with small adjustments from a good tailor. Choose quality over quantity Instead of filling your wardrobe with lots of cheap clothes invest in a few good quality pieces that can last for years. Quality clothing usually looks better feels more comfortable and stays in good condition for longer. Take care of your clothes Buying good clothes is only the first step. Iron your shirts keep your shoes clean clean suits properly and repair damaged clothes when needed. Taking care of your wardrobe can make even older clothes look fresh. Keep some classic pieces You do not need to follow every new fashion trend. Classic items such as button down shirts, straight cut jeans simple suits and smart shoes can remain stylish for many years. Small details matter Simple details can make an outfit look much more polished. Match your belt with your shoes choose suitable socks and select a tie that works well with your shirt collar. These small choices can take your overall look to the next level. Never ignore your shoes A great outfit can lose its appeal if you wear dirty or unsuitable shoes. Treat your footwear as an important part of your outfit rather than an afterthought. Try different colors and patterns Men’s fashion does not have to be limited to black white, grey and blue.  Try different colors and patterns that suit your skin tone and personality. The key is balance. Avoid wearing too many bold pieces at the same time. Use accessories wisely A good watch, belt sunglasses scarf or simple piece of jewelry can make a basic outfit look more stylish. Accessories are also a great way to show your personality without changing your entire wardrobe. Find your own style An outfit that looks great on someone else may not suit you in the same way. Consider your body shape skin tone and personal preferences when choosing clothes. The best style is one that makes you feel comfortable and confident. Get ideas from social media Platforms such as Instagram can provide plenty of fashion inspiration.  However you do not need to copy someone else’s entire look. Take ideas from different styles and create a look that feels personal and unique to you. Confidence completes the look The most important style rule is to feel comfortable and confident in what you wear. You do not have to follow every popular trend.

  • Smart uses for leftover cooking oil

    After frying puris pakoras, or other foods leftover oil is often thrown away. If the oil has been heated many times it may no longer be safe for cooking, especially if its color smell or taste has changed. Instead of wasting it you can use old cooking oil for some simple household tasks. Remove sticky stickers A few drops of oil can help loosen stubborn stickers and labels from plastic glass or steel items. Apply a little oil to the sticker leave it for a few minutes and then gently peel it off. Loosen rusty nuts and bolts If a rusty nut or bolt is stuck put a few drops of leftover oil around the joint. Wait for a while and then try to loosen it.  The oil can reduce friction and make the job easier. Add shine to wooden furniture You can use a small amount of oil to give old wooden furniture a fresh look. Put a little oil on a soft cloth gently rub the wood and then wipe it with a clean dry cloth. Always test the oil on a small hidden area first to make sure it does not damage the wood. Polish leather items Leftover oil can sometimes be used to add shine to leather shoes bags or decorative items.  Apply only a very small amount and wipe it gently. However, not all types of leather react well to oil, so test it on a hidden spot first. Stop squeaky doors and windows If a door or window makes a squeaky sound put a few drops of oil on its hinges.  This can reduce friction and help make the noise quieter. Store leftover oil safely Before using leftover oil for household tasks strain it to remove food particles. Store it in a clean dry airtight jar. Do not use the oil if it smells bad becomes very dark or shows any unusual changes. It is also better to avoid repeatedly using the same oil for cooking or frying.

  • High sugar diet may harm people with asthma

    Eating too much sugar is widely known to increase the risk of type 2 diabetes and high blood pressure.  Now new research suggests that it may also make asthma symptoms worse. A study published in the journal Nutrients found that a high sugar diet can increase inflammation in the lungs making asthma attacks more likely in people with the condition. The research was carried out on mice. Scientists gave the animals their normal food along with sweetened milk. Within just two weeks the mice showed higher levels of lung inflammation. According to the researchers this is one of the first studies to show how quickly excess sugar can worsen inflammation linked to asthma. Asthma is a long term disease that affects the airways and makes breathing difficult.  Although there is no cure the condition can be managed with proper treatment and healthy lifestyle choices. During an asthma attack the airways become swollen and the muscles around them tighten. This can cause coughing wheezing chest tightness and shortness of breath making everyday activities harder. The researchers said that when children eat too much sugar people usually worry about tooth decay or weight gain but rarely think about its possible effects on asthma. They added that the findings support the idea of limiting sugar intake especially for people living with asthma. According to the researchers too much sugar may affect the immune system and trigger inflammation which can make asthma symptoms more severe.

  • Vaping may be as harmful as smoking

    Smoking is well known to cause lung cancer heart disease and breathing problems.  However many people believe that vaping is a safer alternative. New scientific research suggests this belief may be misleading. Studies show that using e-cigarettes can also harm the body and may cause damage similar to that seen in cigarette smokers. Experts say switching from cigarettes to vaping should not be considered completely safe. Although e-cigarettes do not contain traditional tobacco they still expose the body to harmful substances. Research published in 2026 by the University of New South Wales along with findings from scientists at the University of Southern California found that vaping can damage the DNA in cells of the mouth and lungs. DNA is the body’s genetic blueprint. It controls how cells grow and function. When DNA is damaged the risk of serious diseases including cancer can increase. Researchers also found that sweet and fruit flavored vape products may contribute to DNA damage. People who use pod based vaping devices showed even higher levels of cell damage in the study. According to the scientists vaping may increase the risk of cancers of the mouth and lungs.  The research also found that DNA damage in people who vape was almost as severe as the damage seen in cigarette smokers. Although vaping and smoking work differently both can seriously affect health. Health experts advise people not to think of vaping as a harmless option. Every vaping session may damage important cells in the body. They recommend avoiding vaping altogether and raising awareness about its possible health risks.

  • Night shifts harm mental health

    A new study suggests that working night shifts may have a negative effect on mental health.  People who work at night may experience more stress anxiety and depression than those who work during the day. Researchers reviewed seven previous studies involving 28,438 people.  They looked at the participants working hours and mental health and found that night-shift workers were more likely to experience symptoms of depression and anxiety. According to the findings around 33% of people working night shifts showed signs of depression or anxiety compared with those working daytime shifts. Luciana Torquati from the University of Exeter who led the study explained that night work can disturb the body’s natural clock. Our bodies are designed to sleep at night and stay active during the day so working against this natural pattern can affect sleep and mood. Poor sleep and an irregular routine may also cause irritability and mood changes. Night shift workers may feel lonely or disconnected from others because their work schedule can make it harder to spend time with family and friends. The study also reported that night shift work may have a stronger negative effect on women’s mental health than on men’s. Overall the research suggests that working at night may affect not only sleep but also a person’s mood relationships and overall mental well being.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *