population debate curse

The Population Debate: Curse or Opportunity?

By Dr Naveeda Katper

Different countries have different characteristics regarding population, geography, and natural resources that shape their economic growth. Economists use various indicators to measure development, and population is one of the most debated among them. A large population is often viewed as a hurdle to economic growth. However, every issue deserves to be examined from different angles. The question, “Is a large population a curse or a blessing?” cannot be answered with a simple yes or no. We need to move beyond the idea of population as a burden and understand the concept of the demographic dividend. What appears to be a curse can become a blessing when viewed through the right perspective and supported by the right policies. Research by the RAND Corporation and the World Bank has shown that countries with a growing working-age population can experience faster economic growth when supported by sound education, health, and employment policies.

Whether a large population becomes an economic asset depends on governance and public policy. A growing population is not necessarily a curse because every additional mind brings new ideas, different perspectives, and fresh solutions to existing problems. One mind can accomplish one task, two minds can accomplish two, and millions of minds can achieve far more. That is the value of teamwork and collective human potential. Every individual possesses different skills, abilities, and talents that can contribute to national development. What many consider a burden may actually become a country’s greatest strength if those human resources are properly developed. This is the essence of the demographic dividend—the economic advantage that emerges when the working-age population becomes larger than the dependent population. Development economists describe this period as a “window of opportunity” rather than a guaranteed outcome.

Highly populated countries can utilize their youthful population to strengthen their economies. After India, China, the United States, and Indonesia, Pakistan is the fifth most populous country in the world. This should be seen as an opportunity rather than a challenge because more than 65 percent of Pakistan’s population consists of young people. That gives the country a significant advantage. A demographic dividend can only be realized when the working-age population is educated, healthy, skilled, and productively employed. When more people are working and contributing to the economy, household savings increase, investment grows, government spending on dependents declines, and both economic output and per capita income improve. The World Bank has repeatedly emphasized that human capital—education, health, and skills—is one of the strongest drivers of long-term productivity and national income.

The real challenge is identifying the policies required to achieve this dividend. A country can benefit only if it creates sufficient employment opportunities, provides quality education and skill development, ensures access to healthcare, encourages women to participate in the workforce, and maintains stable economic and public policies. When these conditions exist, the country enjoys faster economic growth, greater productivity, increased investment and savings, improved living standards, and stronger entrepreneurship and innovation. Economic growth becomes inevitable when people are hardworking, equipped with multiple skills from an early age, and capable of adapting to changing economic demands. Skilled and self-reliant citizens become the driving force of national development. Evidence from South Korea, Singapore, and Ireland shows that investment in education and skills transformed youthful populations into globally competitive economies.

However, a demographic dividend can quickly become a demographic burden if employment opportunities and skills do not keep pace with population growth. The consequences may include rising unemployment, poverty, social unrest, and migration. Economists and demographers consistently argue that a demographic dividend is not automatic; it is an opportunity that must be earned through effective governance and strong institutions. Without adequate planning and investment, a large youth population can become a liability instead of an asset. The International Labour Organization has warned that persistent youth unemployment can reduce economic productivity and increase social instability.

A dynamic economy capable of creating millions of formal-sector jobs each year is essential for absorbing a growing workforce. Human capital development should remain at the center of national policy. Strong educational systems, Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET), science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM), digital literacy, coding, digital finance, and technology-based curricula should be introduced from the early years of education. Equal opportunities for girls and women in education and employment are equally important. Pakistan also needs job creation, labour market reforms, export-led manufacturing, labour flexibility, investment in high-value industries such as technology, electronics, and specialized services, support for youth entrepreneurship and microfinance, and stronger healthcare infrastructure. UNESCO has consistently highlighted that technical and vocational education equips young people with practical skills that improve employability and economic resilience.

Pakistan possesses one of the largest youth populations in the region, but this advantage can only be realized through greater investment in education, skills, and employment. In conclusion, population control alone is not a long-term solution to economic growth. Developing people’s abilities, expanding opportunities, and investing in human capital are far more effective. The experiences of countries such as Italy and Japan also demonstrate that declining populations and ageing societies create their own economic challenges. The real question is not how many people a country has, but how well it prepares its people to contribute to national development. Research across both developed and developing countries consistently concludes that people become an economic asset when governments invest in their education, health, productivity, and opportunities rather than viewing population solely as a number.

The writer holds a PhD from Malaysia and writes on economic development, public policy, and demographic issues. She can be reached at naveedakatper11@gmail.com

Similar Posts

  • Faculty development: beyond classrooms 

    By Prof. Engr. Dr. Khuram Pervez Amber The persistent weaker linkage between industries and universities in Pakistan requires strategic interventions from all stakeholders. Pakistan cannot expect systemic industrial growth while its higher education institutions and industrial sectors operate in silos. Number of universities in Pakistan has dramatically increased over the past two decades. At current, there are nearly 280 universities in Pakistan which are producing thousands of graduates every year. But the concerns of industries remain valid that the graduates lack the necessary technical knowledge and skills which are required in the industries. These concerns of industries are particularly reported in disciplines such as engineering, computer science and the applied sciences, where employers frequently report a mismatch between academic preparation and industrial requirements. Although there are some valuable initiatives by the HEC, PEC, and NTC which include mandatory industrial internships of six to eight weeks for the engineering and technology students, the impact of such initiatives is limited due to multiple factors. Another initiative of HEC to strengthen university academia linkage is the establishment of the Office of Research, Innovation, and Commercialization (ORICs) in universities. However, the effectiveness of this initiative has not been successful at the desired level as in many universities, ORICs operate with limited staff and resources, while directors of ORICs are usually on additional charges. Expecting a small office alone to build industrial linkages for an entire university is unrealistic. Currently, out of nearly 260 universities, only 95 universities have established ORICs. In the recent ORIC ranking of HEC, only seven of 95 universities achieved the top category, i.e. “W” category. One of the major unexplored reasons behind this fragile linkage between industry and academia is the limited or no industrial exposure of university teachers. Most university teachers move directly from their bachelor’s degrees into master’s and PhD programs. Through this route, such individuals may become academically qualified teachers, but this route does not make them professionals having knowledge of industrial practices, industrial standards, and industry-oriented innovations. In many cases, a teacher teaches an industrial system which he/she has never experienced. This approach may clear theoretical concepts of students, but such students will certainly struggle when they would face real- life industrial problems after their induction in industry. So why do our university teachers require industrial exposure in their field of research? The answer is simple. A teacher with industrial exposure brings his industrial experience into the classrooms, laboratories, projects, and discussions on daily basis. Industrial experience of such teachers would not only improve the technical understanding of students about various industrial systems but also enhance students’ problem-solving skills. It would further help students to understand industrial expectations. So how could universities help their faculty members to get industrial experience? This could be achieved through implementation of structured industrial placement/professional development programs under ORICs for university teachers particularly working in engineering, technology and applied sciences faculties. Under this program, university teachers can spend six months to twelve months in an industry related to their field of interest/research on a turn-by-turn basis. During this period, such faculty members will keep receiving their monthly salaries as usual. So, what will be the major benefits of this model? There will be significant improvement in the pedagogical skills of faculty members as they will be teaching with practical examples, industrial case studies and real-world problem-solving approaches. During their placement in the industry, faculty members would make connections with the industrial experts/managers/engineers which would help them in future to supervise industry-relevant research, secure collaborative projects and contribute to technology transfer. They would identify operational challenges requiring research-based solutions. Upon returning to universities, they can transform these challenges into student projects, postgraduate research topics and consultancy opportunities. This would help create a healthier research culture focused on solving local industrial problems. University graduates will have problem solving skills that are required by industry. Over time, this model would help bridge the trust deficit that exists between academia and industry. Admittedly, implementing such a policy would not be easy. Challenges such as shortage of faculty, and increased teaching workloads are genuine challenges. There are also cultural barriers within academia, where industrial experience is often valued less than traditional academic achievements. However, these barriers are manageable. HEC and professional bodies such as PEC, and universities can jointly develop and implement structured industrial placement programs for faculty members. The industrial experience can be recognized within promotion criteria of faculty members, accreditation frameworks and quality assurance standards. In the nutshell, to produce industry ready graduates, the industrial exposure of university faculty members is indispensable. Their industrial experience will result in a stronger academia-industry linkage which is essential for economic growth, innovation and technological progress. Until universities and industries begin working together more meaningfully, Pakistan will continue producing degrees faster than opportunities. Prof. Engr. Dr. Khuram Pervez Amber (CEng, MEI, PE, FHEA) The writer is serving as Director QEC at Mirpur University of Science and Technology, AJ&K.

  • SpaceX’s 4-ton rocket crashes into Moon at 5,400mph

    Elon Musk’s SpaceX rocket has crashed into the Moon’s surface while travelling at a speed of 5,400 miles per hour while a telescope in Chile captured evidence of the impact. The European Southern Observatory’s (ESO) Very Large Telescope observed the impact on August 5 and detected colorful spectral lines of sodium and lithium gas. These were produced by clouds of lunar dust that were thrown up by the impact. The ESO telescope recorded the “chemical fingerprints” of the gas cloud which remained visible for around 5 to 10 minutes. The cloud was estimated to extend across dozens of kilometers. Experts had previously said that the impact could provide valuable data for future space experiments and help scientists analyze the effects of collisions involving human-made space debris. As NASA plans to establish a permanent human base on the Moon in the future understanding what happens when space debris strikes the lunar surface will be important. Impact site The impact occurred at a location on the Moon that is considered to be near the boundary between the sunlit and dark regions. When the impact sent clouds of dust into the air, they briefly became illuminated by sunlight. However, observing them with the naked eye from Earth was almost impossible. Although several satellites are currently orbiting the Moon, none was positioned at the time of the impact to directly observe it. The rocket fragment was approximately as tall as a five-story building and weighed around 4 tons. NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter and South Korea’s Korea Pathfinder Lunar Orbiter are being considered for photographing the impact site. These images could help determine how much damage was caused by the rocket although it may take several days to collect and analyze the information. It is worth noting that the SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket was launched in January 2025 and carried two landers toward the Moon. Its boosters returned to Earth while the upper stage continued carrying the landers toward the Moon.

  • |

    America’s premier tourist destination

    During the early 1860s, an unexpected location ranked as the second most visited tourist spot in the United States: Green-Wood Cemetery in Brooklyn. Trailing only Niagara Falls in popularity, the vast burial ground welcomed roughly 500,000 visitors every year. Families routinely spent their afternoons strolling through the peaceful grounds. They took horse-drawn carriage rides and admiring the elaborate grand monuments across the landscape. When Green-Wood first opened its gates in 1838, New York City had virtually no public parks, as Central Park had not yet been conceived. By the time the early 1860s arrived, Central Park was only beginning to open its initial sections to the public. As a result, rural cemeteries like Green-Wood filled a massive void for city dwellers seeking fresh air, natural beauty, and a quiet escape from urban density. The unique charm and sweeping vistas of the cemetery caught the attention of Rudolf Cronau, a German-born illustrator and artist. Born in Solingen in 1855, Cronau trained at the prestigious Düsseldorf Art Academy under Andreas Müller before establishing his own studio. In 1881, he ventured across the Atlantic on an assignment for Die Gartenlaube, a popular German illustrated magazine. His mission was to document the landscapes, bustling cities, and diverse people of the United States, bringing the American experience to life for European readers through a mix of written reports and detailed artwork. While visiting Brooklyn in 1881, Cronau captured the cemetery’s famous skyline view in a artwork titled View from Greenwood Cemetery, Brooklyn. Rendered in delicate watercolor and black ink, the piece now resides in the permanent collection of the Brooklyn Museum. Cronau arranged his view in three distinct planes: an elaborate mausoleum anchored the foreground, Green-Wood’s iconic Gothic main entrance gates framed the middle ground, and the vast expanse of New York Harbor and the New Jersey coastline stretched out in the background. The mausoleum highlighted in the foreground of Cronau’s illustration belonged to John Anderson, a prominent NYC figure who amassed a massive fortune in the tobacco trade. Anderson, born in 1812, ran a well-known shop near Manhattan’s City Hall before eventually passing away in Paris in 1881.   Beyond serving as his final resting place, Anderson’s tomb was built as a bold political statement. Commissioned during the heights of the American Civil War, the Greek Revival-style structure was purposefully designed to symbolize a commitment to republican governance over monarchical rule, while serving as an unmistakable declaration of pro-Union support. Through art and architecture, a single cemetery hilltop managed to weave together personal wealth, national ideology, and one of the finest views of 19th-century New York.

  • Are protein supplements safe for teens?

    Fitness and bodybuilding are becoming increasingly popular among young people. Many gym goers and athletes use protein powders and other supplements to build stronger muscles and improve their physical performance. But are these products always safe? A medical study published in the Proceedings journal of Baylor University Medical Center examined the effects of protein supplements. The researchers described protein powder as a “double edged sword” because it can be useful in some situations but may also cause problems when used incorrectly or unnecessarily. Protein is important for growing bodies The teenage years are an important stage of physical growth.  Protein helps the body build and repair muscles strengthen bones produce hormones and enzymes support the immune system and maintain overall growth. Most young people can get enough protein from a balanced diet. Foods such as milk, yogurt eggs, lentils, beans soy, fish, chicken lean meat nuts and seeds are good sources of protein. When are supplements needed? Many young people start drinking protein shakes after joining a gym playing sports or watching fitness videos on social media. Experts advise against using protein powders simply because a friend gym trainer or social media influencer recommends them. However some young people may need extra protein because of intense training dietary restrictions or certain health conditions. In such cases supplements should be used only with advice from a doctor or qualified nutrition professional. More protein does not mean more muscle Taking large amounts of protein does not automatically lead to bigger or stronger muscles.  Muscle growth also depends on regular strength training, enough calories proper sleep, rest and individual factors such as genetics. Taking more protein than the body needs can also add extra calories to the diet and may contribute to weight gain especially when physical activity is low. Some protein powders may contain extra ingredients. Some protein powders available in the market may contain added sugar artificial sweeteners, herbal ingredients extra calories or stimulant substances. The quality of supplements can also vary. Some products may not be tested as carefully as medicines which can create a risk of unwanted or undeclared ingredients. Who should be more careful? Young people with kidney disease or certain metabolic conditions should not take high protein supplements without medical advice. Anyone who is replacing regular meals with several protein shakes every day following an extremely restrictive diet or experiencing stomach problems after using protein powder should stop and seek professional advice. Protein shakes are not a replacement for food. Protein shakes cannot replace a healthy and balanced diet. Regular foods provide much more than protein. They also supply fiber healthy fats, vitamins minerals calcium iron and other nutrients that are important for healthy growth and development. Healthy habits come first for most young people, a balanced diet, regular exercise proper sleep and enough rest are the foundation of good health and fitness. Protein supplements can be helpful in specific situations but they should not be used simply because they are popular. If extra protein is needed it is best to choose the right amount and product with guidance from a qualified health professional.

  • Health benefits of eating papaya during monsoon

    The monsoon season brings relief from the heat but it can also increase the risk of infections and digestive problems. Health experts say that eating nutritious foods can help the body stay strong. Papaya is one fruit that can be a healthy addition to the diet during rainy weather. Rich in vitamins fiber water and natural enzymes, papaya may support digestion immunity heart health and skin health. Supports immunity and digestion During the rainy season some people may become more likely to develop colds flu or other seasonal infections.  Papaya contains vitamins A and C which support the normal function of the immune system. Papaya also contains an enzyme called papain which helps break down proteins and may support digestion. Its fiber and water content can also help keep the digestive system working properly. May help with constipation Papaya is rich in fiber and water making it a useful fruit for people who struggle with constipation.  Eating enough fiber and drinking plenty of water can help support regular bowel movements. What about dengue? Dengue cases can increase during the monsoon because mosquitoes become more common. Papaya leaves are sometimes promoted as a way to increase platelet levels but there is not enough strong evidence to consider papaya or papaya leaves a treatment for dengue. People with dengue should follow their doctor’s advice and should not rely on papaya as a replacement for proper medical care. May support weight and heart health Papaya is relatively low in calories and contains fiber which can help you feel full for longer. This may make it a useful choice for people trying to maintain a healthy weight. It also provides nutrients such as potassium and fiber that can support overall heart health as part of a balanced diet. Good for skin and eyes Papaya contains antioxidants and nutrients such as vitamins A and C which can support healthy skin. Its antioxidants may also help protect cells from damage caused by free radicals. The fruit also contains carotenoids such as beta-carotene lutein and zeaxanthin which are linked to eye health. Eat It in Moderation Papaya is a nutritious fruit and can be part of a healthy monsoon diet.  However no single food can prevent diseases or replace medical treatment. It is best to eat papaya as part of a balanced diet and consult a doctor before making major dietary changes if you have a medical condition.

  • Can you solve this tricky fruit math puzzle? 

    At first glance this looks like a simple math question for children. However the way it is designed makes it surprisingly difficult and many people end up with the wrong answer. In the puzzle each type of fruit has a different value. Your challenge is to figure out the value of each fruit and then calculate the final equation. The last line asks you to add one cherry one apple and three bananas. To solve it correctly you need to carefully work out the value of each fruit from the previous equations. For example the first equation shows three apples adding up to 30, so each apple is worth 10. The other equations reveal that each banana is worth 4 and each cherry is worth 1. Using these values: Apple = 10 Banana = 4 Cherry = 1 Final calculation: 10 + (3 × 4) + 1 = 23 Correct Answer: 23 Note If the original puzzle counts each banana as 1 because it changes from a bunch to a single banana or uses a different image in the last row the answer may change. The answer depends on the exact picture shown. The text you provided says 14 but based only on the values stated in the text (apple = 10, banana = 4, cherry = 1) the total is 23.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *