vantage point hidden
| | | | | | | | |

[Vantage Point] The hidden losses inside Philippine banks

For decades, investors judged Philippine banks using a familiar checklist: loan growth, non-performing loans, quarterly earnings, and dividend payouts.

By those metrics, the industry’s largest institutions appear to be in excellent health. Profits remain robust, credit quality has steadily improved since the pandemic, and capital ratios comfortably exceed regulatory minimums.

Yet, Vantage Point’s own reconstruction of the country’s largest banks suggests investors have been watching only half the balance sheet. 

The next important measure of banking strength is not hiding in bad loans. It is hiding in government bonds.

Rising interest rates have quietly erased billions of pesos from shareholder equity as the market value of government securities declined.

Security Bank, for one, disclosed cumulative unrealized losses equivalent to 7.5% of its Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital, more than double the 3.5% reported at the end of 2025.

Banco De Oro (BDO) reported approximately P16.2 billion in unrealized losses during the first quarter of 2026. 

Preliminary disclosures likewise point to measurable capital impacts at the Bank of the Philippine Islands (BPI) and Metrobank. None of these figures suggests financial distress.

Philippine banks remain among the strongest in Southeast Asia. 

Collectively, however, they reveal an industry-wide exposure that has attracted remarkably little attention despite becoming one of the most significant changes in bank balance sheets over the past two years.

The question is no longer whether banks have unrealized bond losses. Almost all of them do after one of the most aggressive interest-rate tightening cycles in recent history.

The more meaningful question is: which institutions assumed the greatest interest-rate risk relative to the capital available to absorb it? 

That capital is measured by CET1—the bank’s highest-quality financial cushion, consisting largely of shareholders’ equity and retained earnings.

It is the first line of defense against unexpected losses and the benchmark regulators use to assess a bank’s financial strength. A paper loss that barely dents a large CET1 base may be insignificant, while the same loss could materially weaken a bank operating with a thinner capital cushion.

Answering our previous question requires looking beyond earnings releases and rebuilding the balance sheets of every major Philippine bank from the ground up.

Our forensic database tracks each institution’s Fair Value Through Other Comprehensive Income (FVOCI) portfolio, amortized-cost investments, accumulated Other Comprehensive Income (OCI), unrealized gains and losses, CET1 capital, capital adequacy ratios, securities as a percentage of total assets, and portfolio maturity profile.

Every figure already exists somewhere in annual reports, quarterly financial statements, and regulatory disclosures. What has never existed is a single framework allowing investors to compare the interest-rate exposure of Philippine banks on a like-for-like basis.

FORENSIC DATABASE: Hidden interest-rate risk in Philippine banks

This table is generated by Vantage Point based on our own computation, drafted on Excel, with the final image using Photoshop. The numbers are preliminary figures subject to verification against audited financial statements and regulatory disclosures.

The database immediately changes the way investors should compare banks. Looking only at the peso value of unrealized losses is misleading because larger institutions naturally hold larger investment portfolios.

The more meaningful measure is loss intensity—the unrealized loss relative to CET1 capital. A P10-billion paper loss means something very different for a bank with P500 billion of high-quality capital than for one with only a fraction of that amount.

The objective is therefore not to identify the bank with the largest paper loss, but to determine which institutions have assumed the greatest interest-rate risk relative to their financial capacity to absorb it.

Understanding how those losses arise is equally important. When the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) raised policy rates to combat inflation, yields on government securities climbed while bond prices moved in the opposite direction.

Accounting standards require many securities classified as FVOCI to be revalued at prevailing market prices every reporting period. Those valuation losses generally bypass the income statement and flow instead through Other Comprehensive Income, quietly reducing shareholder equity while leaving headline earnings largely intact. A bank can therefore report record profits even as movements in the bond market steadily erode its book value.

That accounting treatment should not be mistaken for evidence of impending trouble. Government securities remain among the safest assets banks can own, and institutions with strong liquidity can usually hold them until maturity, allowing temporary valuation losses to reverse over time.

The more important questions should focus on whether a bank accumulated unusually long-duration securities; how much of the resulting paper loss has already reduced high-quality capital, and whether sufficient liquidity exists to avoid selling those securities before maturity if market conditions become more challenging.

Another layer of complexity comes from the BSP’s temporary regulatory relief for certain unrealized losses on qualifying government securities. Although the accounting losses remain real and continue to appear in financial statements, regulatory capital may receive more favorable treatment when capital adequacy ratios are calculated.

The policy aims to prevent temporary market volatility from unnecessarily constraining bank lending or forcing institutions to liquidate government bonds at depressed prices. It is a legitimate prudential tool, but it also means investors should distinguish between accounting capital and regulatory capital. The two no longer always tell exactly the same story.

For years, investors evaluated Philippine banks primarily through earnings growth and credit quality. Higher interest rates suggest that another scorecard is now needed. 

The industry’s next important risk measure may not be found in non-performing loans or quarterly profits but in the unrealized bond losses quietly accumulating in shareholder equity.

Reconstructing those figures bank by bank will not predict the next banking crisis, and it isn’t supposed to. It will simply give investors a more complete picture of how resilient Philippine banks really are once the entire balance sheet — not just the income statement — is brought into view.

I welcome your views on these and other issues where decisions made in power shape the country’s economic future.

Below are some Vantage Point pieces you might have missed:

Click here for other Vantage Point articles.

Similar Posts

  • | |

    Google slapped with $1bn EU fine, holds talks to dodge further penalties

    The European Union has fined Google about €890 million, or $1 billion. The fine punishes Google for breaking EU rules meant to control the power of big tech companies. But regulators also hinted that no more fines are coming soon, because Google is making good progress toward following the rules. The fine has two parts. The first part, €460 million, is for Google favoring its own products. When people search for things like shopping, hotels, flights, or sports scores, Google often showed its own results first instead of treating competitors fairly. The second part, €430 million, is about the Google Play app store. Google had stopped app makers from telling users about cheaper deals outside the app store. This is the first time Google has been fined under this specific EU law, called the Digital Markets Act. But counting older cases, Google has now paid six fines for unfair business practices. In total, the company has paid more than €10 billion in EU fines over about twenty years. EU officials said they are just enforcing the law. “Our job is to make sure the rules are followed,” said Teresa Ribera, the EU’s top antitrust official. Another official, Henna Virkkunen, said the goal is fair competition. Google now has 60 days to fix its practices. Google is not happy. A company spokesperson said the changes will hurt features people like, such as quick pricing for hotels and flights. He said the ruling is not really about fair competition, it is making Google’s products worse to please a small number of complainers. Even so, there is good news for Google too. The EU said Google has already started testing new ways of showing search results more fairly. It called this real progress. The EU may also apply the same rules to Google’s AI tools, like AI Overviews. Talks about this are still ongoing. Google’s changes to its app store rules were also seen as a step in the right direction. This fight is happening while tensions rise between the US and EU. The Trump administration says Europe is unfairly targeting American companies and has threatened tariffs in response. Some US lawmakers agree. Google’s fine comes after the EU already fined Apple and Meta last year under the same law. It shows the EU is serious about controlling big tech, even as pressure grows from the US side.

  • | |

    Another Reko Diq-Sized mining project in Pakistan,…

    ISLAMABAD: The United States has expressed strong confidence in Pakistan’s mineral sector, with a senior US Embassy official revealing that the Trump administration is prepared to support another mega mining project on the scale of  to invest in Pakistan despite security concerns, viewing the country’s vast mineral wealth as strategically important for future global industries. During a background briefing with journalists on Wednesday, the embassy official said Washington considers Pakistan a key partner in the global race for critical minerals that are essential for advanced technologies, clean energy, artificial intelligence, semiconductors and defence manufacturing. According to the official, the US government is encouraging American investors to explore Pakistan’s untapped mineral resources, ranging from large-scale copper and gold projects to smaller mining ventures worth only a few million dollars. US Prepared to Finance Another Mega Project The official said the US administration is ready to support another project comparable to the multibillion-dollar Reko Diq development if geological surveys and feasibility studies demonstrate strong commercial potential. He added that financing support could be extended through US institutions such as the Export-Import (Exim) Bank and the Development Finance Corporation, both of which are playing a growing role in securing global supply chains for critical minerals. The official noted that American companies are not only interested in major mining investments but are also examining opportunities to acquire, develop and expand smaller mining operations across Pakistan. Reko Diq Progress Continues Despite Delays Discussing the Reko Diq copper and gold project, the official acknowledged that work is progressing, although at a slower pace than initially anticipated. He explained that project costs are currently being reassessed, after which developers will return to financiers to finalize the remaining funding package. The first phase of the Reko Diq project is estimated to cost around $7.7 billion, while the US Exim Bank has already offered $1.25 billion in financing. However, the overall financial structure remains under discussion. The project has experienced delays due to rising construction costs and security concerns in Balochistan, prompting project stakeholders to revise cost estimates more than once. Earlier this year, Barrick Gold, which owns a 50 percent stake in the project, also reviewed development timelines because of increasing costs and security-related challenges. Major Economic Benefits Expected The embassy official said Reko Diq has the potential to transform Pakistan’s economy once it becomes fully operational. According to the estimates shared during the briefing, the project could generate nearly $2 billion in annual free cash flow. Of this amount, around $500 million would go directly to the Government of Balochistan, while another $500 million would benefit Pakistan’s state-owned enterprises. The official further stated that Pakistan’s mining sector currently contributes roughly 3 percent to the country’s economy, while Reko Diq alone could increase national GDP by approximately 0.5 percentage points, highlighting its significance for long-term economic growth. Critical Minerals Becoming Strategic Priority The US official emphasized that critical minerals have become a top strategic priority for Washington as demand continues to rise across technology, renewable energy and defence sectors. Pakistan possesses commercially attractive reserves of copper, antimony, tungsten and several other minerals considered essential for future industries. He said American companies believe Pakistan has enormous untapped potential, particularly as global demand for copper is expected to rise sharply over the coming decades. The official added that US firms are actively seeking long-term supply agreements for minerals extracted from Pakistani mines, while some investors are interested in purchasing and developing smaller mining assets. Investment Opportunities Across Pakistan Besides Balochistan, American investors are also exploring mineral opportunities in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, particularly for copper deposits, while rare earth mineral prospects in Gilgit-Baltistan have also attracted attention. The official said the United States is searching globally for around 60 critical minerals needed for emerging technologies, many of which are found in Pakistan. He noted that several companies have already begun exploration and extraction activities in different regions of the country. Security Remains the Biggest Challenge Despite strong investment interest, the official acknowledged that security remains one of the most significant obstacles facing mining projects in Pakistan. He said US companies fully understand the risks associated with operating in regions such as Balochistan and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa but remain willing to invest if appropriate security arrangements are provided. The official stressed that the Pakistani government should continue strengthening security measures and facilitating investors to ensure long-term success of mining projects. He added that American companies are encouraged to partner with local firms, which possess valuable experience in navigating operational and security challenges in remote mining areas. US Calls for Transparent Investment Environment The embassy official also urged Pakistan to maintain a transparent, predictable and competitive investment climate to attract greater foreign investment into the mineral sector. He noted that Pakistan’s participation in the US Critical Minerals Initiative earlier this year reflects growing cooperation between the two countries in securing future mineral supply chains. According to the official, if exploration and investment continue at the current pace, Pakistan’s mining industry could emerge as one of the country’s strongest economic sectors over the next 10 to 20 years, creating employment, increasing exports and significantly boosting national revenues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *