hec new weighted

HEC new weighted policy: putting weight on research credibility

By Ali Abbas

Pakistan’s Higher Education Commission (HEC) new weighted research policy has surely raised an eyebrow among a few academics nationwide. Before further dissecting the policy and its implications, it is pertinent to understand the role of HEC as a regulatory authority, which can help clear the air to a greater extent. As stated, “Regulatory”, it is important to accept that the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan is there to implement quality checks irrespective of the decision being popular or unpopular. So, with this lens, it is easy to understand why HEC is weighing this bold step of assigning weights to authorship and what must have been the shortcomings in the previous policy, despite the earlier policy’s apparent benefits.

The new policy values first authors and corresponding authors more, acknowledging a reward for the initiators and potential stakeholders in the event that there are more than 3 authors. While HEC is not stopping co-authorship, it aims to credit researchers who have genuine contributions and are adding value as a lead or major contributor. It is entirely up to contributors to choose the number of other co-authors and their desired contribution and commitment in the research article. In fact, this should rather be seen as a measure of transparency that researchers who are expecting to get fewer marks for co-authorship will be doing less work in contrast to the first author. That can actually act as a yardstick for them to allocate their time to multiple projects to get their respective share/ count. However, not to undermine the researchers whose genuine intent surrounds a higher number of publications in less time with real contribution, it is a welcoming sign for authors who stay away from relationship-based and aided research.

So, HEC, being a quality custodian of education and research practices for HEIs, has come up with a stance to curb research mills, fraudulent research, and fake authorship, where publications in friends’ journals and contributions following quid pro quo are compensated. And one never knows when these researchers who have worked as co-authors or fall last in the author list make it to the classes; their share of knowledge and impact may be a concern at times as well. The problem is even bigger, as not only papers with 20+ authors can be found, but researchers are co-authoring in different fields that may be beyond cross-domain collaboration. This is where HEC might have to respond and find this weighted policy as damage control.  Well, this research’s credibility is not Pakistan’s dilemma only, but something that is a world issue in a higher education setting. And when HEC addresses these concerns, it might act as a benchmark for other nations’ education systems, especially for the education and accreditation councils of similar demographics. Whether one favors or opposes it, HEC has devised something that raises major concerns, and that is to curb the need to distinguish between real and fake contributors.

Now comes the point of demotivating international contributions from this weighted system, as raised by the affected prospective contributors. Well, though not every policy can avoid its collateral, the overall gain may be exploited as well. It is to be remembered that international collaborators are not to be linked with those weights; they can continue to collaborate at any number in the author list as they used to be, i.e., first or second or third, etc. In this case, the logic for local authors will remain the same as stated above about their respective contributions and rewards. The time and effort can then help in identifying multiple avenues as well. Again, there are always two sides to a coin, and in the current dynamics, where co-authorship has appeared to be a business deal, the side with the assigned weights policy bears more weight. Also, on the other hand, the offset can be made by allocating funds and instructing HEIs to devote funding to Gold open access, thus accelerating the pace of the first-author research. All in all, the new policy hints at increasing competitiveness and research credibility while leaving it to the test of time to see if it turns out to be a value addition for researchers by choice or by chance.

About the author:

Ali Abbas, PhD, works at Beaconhouse National University.
He can be reached at aabbas724@gmail.com

Similar Posts

  • Survey of Käthe Kollwitz’s legacy

    The Museum of Modern Art in New York  exhibits the first major museum retrospective devoted to the German printmaker and sculptor Käthe Kollwitz (1867–1945).The exhibition serves as reassessment of an artist who chose raw human emotion over abstract aesthetics. The survey features roughly 120 works on paper and evocative bronze sculptures gathered from private and public collections across North America and Europe. Käthe Kollwitz originally trained as a painter before turning to printmaking, etching, and charcoal drawing. She quickly realized that black-and-white graphic arts provided a far more direct, accessible, and potent medium for addressing the social injustices around her. She lived through the tumultuous transition of late 19th-century industrialization. The revolution followed by the political instability and devastating carnage of two world wars in Berlin. However, Kollwitz dedicated her career to giving form to the silent suffering of society’s most vulnerable. When many of her contemporaries were exploring radical formal abstraction, Kollwitz stayed firmly rooted in figuration. She viewed her artistic talent not as a path toward personal prestige, but as a moral imperative. As Kollwitz famously noted in her journal, she felt a profound duty to give voice to humanity’s immense burdens. It was a motivation clearly reflected in her emotionally charged compositions. The retrospective marks several crucial series and individual masterpieces that define Kollwitz’s career. Early landmark series included A Weaver’s Revolt (1890s) and Peasant War (1902–1908). They showed her skill in capturing collective resistance, class struggle, and the violent fallout of peasant rebellions. Her works like Woman with Dead Child (1903) and her recurring depictions of mothers shielding their young. This theme is also dominant in her famous Mütter (Mothers) lithographs. These works demonstrate her ability to channel deep personal empathy into universal symbols of protective instinct. Kollwitz produced woodcuts and sculptural works that transformed personal bereavement into universal anti-war statements. She was distilling the excruciating grief of losing her younger son, Peter, during World War I. Kollwitz’s artistic contributions extend far beyond historical interest. Kollwitz established herself as a genius of Expressionist printmaking. As a result, she achieved widespread international acclaim during her lifetime. More importantly, she radically prioritized the female experience, framing motherhood, domestic hardship. She expressed grief not as passive domestic occurrences, but as central, powerful forces within history and politics. Above all, she achieved all that during an era when the international art world was almost exclusively governed by male perspectives, MoMA exhibition underscores the artist’s meticulous process through rare working proofs and preliminary studies. Such an event exposed how she repeatedly refined line, shade, and texture to maximize the emotional potency of each scene. It was Curated by Starr Figura. In a world still facing economic disparity, displacement, and armed conflict, Kollwitz’s unflinching commitment to human dignity continues to resonate with undeniable relevance. Her skills were bold woodcuts, deep etchings, and heavy bronzes. However, they serve as a reminder that art can act as both a mirror to societal trauma and a compassionate voice for justice.  

  • |

    Press play on nostalgia

    There is an absurdly satisfying drama to slipping a shiny compact disc into a silver portable CD player. Next up, click the lid shut and voila! Listen to that faint mechanical whir-click as the laser reads the track. We live in an era where a glass smartphone screen gives you instant access to 100 million songs. And when one chooses to carry around a plastic disc player, it feels less like a modern inconvenience and more like a heroic act of rebellion. Well! In order to figure out why Gen Z is suddenly obsessing over vintage music players that take up actual pocket space, we have to look at the wild journey of how we got here. From Giant Plastic Discs to Invisible Spotify Soundtracks The evolution of portable music is essentially a history of humans constantly trading physical soul for pure convenience. The Boombox & Tape Era Back in 1979, the original Sony Walkman fundamentally changed society by letting people walk down the street with their own personal soundtrack playing on magnetic cassette tape. It was revolutionary, even if you occasionally had to fix a tangled tape using a No. 2 pencil. The Silver Disc Reign By the late 80s and 90s, the CD player (affectionately nicknamed the Discman, though brands like Goodmans ruled the market too) took over. Suddenly, music was crisp, digital and skip-resistant. The condition that provided your player had a reliable 45-second anti-shock buffer and you didn’t jump off while walking! Albums came with jewel cases, actual artwork and fold-out lyric booklets you could read on the bus. The MP3 Tidal Wave The early 2000s crushed physical media into tiny digital files. The iPod and cheap MP3 players meant you could hoard thousands of low-bitrate songs in your pocket. They effectively killed off the concept of buying an album just to listen to it as a cohesive story. The Infinite Streaming Void Today, platforms like Spotify and Apple Music serve us endless music on demand.  Every track on Earth is accessible with a single tap. That’s why music easily morphs into background noise rather than a meaningful event. The Retro Revival You’d think the generation born into high-speed Wi-Fi would turn their noses up at retro tech. However, physical music sales among young listeners are skyrocketing. It turns out that living entirely online gets exhausting. The antique way of listening to music hits differently for a few fun reasons. Spotify’s algorithm loves to push you into a hyper-specific mood bubble. On the other hand, physical disc into a portable player forces you to listen to an entire album from track 1 to track 20 the way the artist intended. On top, there are no skips, no ads, no doomscrolling while listening. There is a joy in pressing actual spring-loaded plastic buttons instead of tapping a flat screen. The mechanical clicks, volume dials and tangled headphone wires bring a sensory connection. In my opinion, a digital app just can’t match. In the subscription economy, you don’t own anything. If a streaming platform loses licensing rights, your favorite album vanishes overnight. A physical CD on your shelf, however, is yours forever. Now, let’s be honest! Pulled-out wired earbuds connected to a metallic silver CD player looking like straight out of Y2K sci-fi is an undeniable aesthetic flex.

  • The royal bloodlines that forged a Balkan powerhouse

    In the heart of the 14th century, a monumental fresco was rendered upon the walls of the Lesnovo Monastery in modern-day North Macedonia. It captured a defining moment in Balkan history. Emperor Stefan Uroš IV Dušan alongside his wife, Empress Helena of Bulgaria, and their young heir, Stefan Uroš V. This wall painting serves as a enduring testament far more than a decorative piece of sacred art. A masterfully orchestrated political union that reshaped the geopolitical landscape of medieval Europe. At the center of this historical narrative is a strategic marriage forged in 1332. The newly crowned Serbian King Stefan Dušan entered into a pivotal treaty with Tsar Ivan Alexander of Bulgaria. He seems desperate to employ peace after years of regional conflict. The cornerstone of this agreement was the marriage of Dušan to Ivan Alexander’s sister, Princess Helena (Elena). This union was far more than a ceremonial gesture. Helena proved to be an immensely influential empress consort whose royal Bulgarian lineage carried significant political weight. Her marriage to Dušan directly altered his formal imperial standing, allowing him to claim authority not only over the Serbs and Greeks, but over the Bulgarians as well. The couple later gave birth to Stefan Uroš V, an heir who embodied the consolidated royal houses of the region. Yet, the Bulgarian connections within the Serbian royal court ran much deeper than Dušan’s marriage alone. Dušan himself was bound to Bulgaria by blood through his mother, Queen Theodora Smilets. As the daughter of Tsar Smilets, who ruled the Second Bulgarian Empire from 1292 to 1298 AD, Theodora brought rich dynastic heritage into the Nemanjić house. Thus, when Dušan rose to power and eventually established the grand Serbian Empire, he did so as a monarch who was inherently a product of both Serbian and Bulgarian elite lineages. The fresco preserved in Lesnovo illuminates this intertwined destiny. Depicting the imperial family dressed in rich, jewel-encrusted Byzantine-style robes, it reflects an era when diplomatic ties, shared heritage, and strategic royal marriages could unite rival realms under a single, dominant imperial banner. Today, these historical records and vibrant monastery paintings remind us that the borders of the medieval Balkans were constantly reshaped not just on the battlefield, but through the formidable power of dynastic unity.  

  • Starvation Wages in Times of Inflation

    Hani Rasheed I wish to draw attention to the worsening condition of daily wage labourers. Despite working from morning till evening under the scorching sun, many labourers receive only around Rs1,500 a day. In today’s high inflation, this amount is far from enough to cover basic necessities such as food, rent, transport, education, and medical expenses. The rising cost of living has made survival extremely difficult for low-income families. While prices continue to increase, the wages of many labourers remain unchanged. This imbalance is forcing hardworking people deeper into poverty despite their honest efforts. The government should revise the minimum wage in line with inflation and ensure that employers pay workers fairly and on time. Protecting the rights of labourers is essential for social justice and economic stability. I hope the concerned authorities will take immediate action to improve the lives of daily wage workers

  • |

    Creative expression as survival in times of crisis

    In times of severe military occupation, state violence, and political trauma, art and literature undergo a fundamental transformation. They shift from aesthetic expression to vital tools for survival, record-keeping, and resistance. When conventional channels of news, speech, and movement are heavily restricted or censored, art and literature fulfill critical functions within a society. Documenting Counter-Narratives and Resisting Erasure In occupied zones, official narratives often frame political conflict using terms like normalcy or integration. They sanitize structural violence and human suffering. Kashmiri writers, poets, and essayists use narrative to preserve collective memory against state-enforced amnesia. Through poetry, fiction, and memoirs, literature captures the psychological reality of curfews, enforced disappearances, communication blackouts. It reminds of the loss of autonomy, rendering the lived experience of civilians indelible. Fine arts, illustration, and graphic art record incidents and emotional states that photojournalism or state-approved media often cannot access or transmit.  Processing Collective and Intergenerational Trauma Art creates a necessary intellectual and emotional container for a traumatized populace. Concepts such as unheimlich (the uncanny, or feeling un-homed in one’s own land) or grief over exile and displacement find structural expression through creative metaphors. Poetic forms allow writers to articulate loss, mourning, and fear in ways that transcend direct prose. The work of iconic Kashmiri poets such as the late Agha Shahid Ali, whose poetry continues to resonate. It demonstrates how verse can turn localized grief into a universal cry for human dignity. Artists frequently turn to raw mediums like paint, installation, and physical textiles to project the interiority of living under siege, using symbolic motifs like barren land, barbed wire, cages, or domestic objects disrupted by violence. Evading Censorship Through Metaphor and Allegory When direct political discourse leads to state surveillance, detentions, or legal suppression, creative expression relies on metaphor, symbolism, and myth. Playwrights and novelists weave political critiques into historical, mythological, or surreal settings, allowing themes of oppression, tyranny, and liberation to be discussed safely. On the ground, quick visual mediums like graffiti, posters, and digital art become decentralized tools. The mediums act for mass communication and solidarity, circulating rapidly across networks even during communication rollbacks.  Transcending Boundaries and Building Global Solidarity Art and literature serve onnect the isolated region to the global diaspora and international human rights communities. On memorial dates like August 5 (observed as Youm-e-Istehsal or Black Day by Kashmiris and solidarity groups worldwide), exhibitions, literary readings, poster competitions, and performance art allow communities across the world to bear witness to the ongoing struggle. Art transforms passive sympathy into active political consciousness. It forces the global audiences to confront physical realities of occupation beyond distant headlines. In times of intense crisis, art does not exist as an escape from reality. Rather, it becomes the definitive site where human dignity, historical truth, and resistance are actively preserved.  

  • Stay safe from viral fever during monsoon

    When the rainy season begins after the hot summer cases of different illnesses often increase.  Viral fever is one of the common health problems people may experience during changing weather. Many people first develop a sore throat or runny nose followed by fever that may last several days.  It can leave the body feeling weak and may cause headaches body aches, chest discomfort or throat pain. Children older adults and people with weaker immune systems may be more likely to develop complications. A few simple habits can help reduce the risk of infections during the rainy season. Keep your hands clean Germs and viruses can stay on frequently touched surfaces such as door handles mobile phones railings and other objects. Wash your hands with soap and clean water for at least 20 seconds after returning home before eating and after using the bathroom.  If soap and water are not available use an alcohol based hand sanitizer. Try not to touch your eyes nose or mouth with unwashed hands. Eat a healthy diet A healthy diet supports the body’s immune system. During the rainy season include fresh fruits vegetables lentils, milk yogurt and eggs in your meals. Foods containing vitamin C and zinc can also be part of a balanced diet. Try to avoid unhygienic street food and foods that are heavily fried. Drink safe and clean water Rainy weather can increase the risk of infections caused by contaminated water.  Drink properly filtered or boiled water whenever possible. Avoid uncovered drinks and ice from places where water  quality is uncertain. Drinking enough clean water throughout the day also helps prevent dehydration. Take care after getting wet If you get caught in the rain change out of wet clothes as soon as possible and dry  your hair properly. Staying in wet clothes for a long time can make you uncomfortable and may contribute to illness. If needed take a warm shower and change into clean, dry clothes. Get enough sleep and rest Good sleep helps the body maintain a healthy immune system. Poor sleep and constant stress can affect overall health. Try to get around seven to eight hours of sleep each night. Light exercise walking or gentle yoga can also help keep the body active. Avoid close contact with sick people Some viral infections can spread through coughing sneezing and close contact.  Keep some distance from people who are sick and avoid crowded places when possible. Wear a mask when needed and do not share personal items such as towels drinking bottles or utensils with someone who is ill.  Cover your mouth and nose with a tissue or your elbow when coughing or sneezing. Pay attention to early symptoms Do not ignore symptoms such as fever sore throat headache runny nose or body aches. Get enough rest drink warm fluids and monitor your condition. Avoid taking antibiotics without medical advice because antibiotics do not treat most viral infections and unnecessary use can be harmful. Know when to see a doctor Seek medical care if your fever reaches 102°F (38.9°C) or higher lasts for more than three days or is accompanied by breathing difficulty repeated vomiting fainting, or severe weakness. The rainy season can be enjoyable but taking basic health precautions is important. Good hygiene safe food and water enough rest and early attention to symptoms can help reduce the risk of illness during changing weather.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *