Immature Minds Need Nourishment, Not Punishment

By Tuba Khan

A nation’s commitment to justice is not judged by the way it treats its powerful citizens, but the way it treats its vulnerable members of society. One of the most fragile creations of God are the children who need love and care, but when they are punished for their mistakes, abused or exploited for their mischievous acts and left unheard in their hour of need, they tend to become juvenile delinquents. They require guidance and encouragement to learn from their mistakes, so that they can grow into responsible and confident individuals. But unfortunately, in Pakistan, children are the most neglected group in terms of justice. Though Pakistan has juvenile justice laws and is a signatory to several international commitments. However, it fails to honor these obligations. According to the KidsRights Index 2020, Pakistan ranks 147th out of 182 nations in access to justice for children.

Juvenile delinquency is not inherent; rather, it is often fueled by social, familial, psychological and environmental conditions. Children being observant and curious by nature are highly adaptable to their surroundings. Family, mentors and the community instill values in a child, shaping children’s behavior. However, factors that lead to juvenile delinquency include parental conflicts or separation, peer pressure, exposure to negative, aggressive and violent environments, deprivation of education, financial resources, affection and other basic necessities, impaired cognitive development, poor reasoning skills and psychological issues, such as impulsiveness, antisocial traits and mental disorders. Moreover, drug addiction, access to harmful content on social media, the dark web and illegal means also exacerbate the growing evil of youth delinquency. Together, these factors shape a child’s social and moral development and provoke delinquent behavior.

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) defines a child as one under the age of eighteen. Below this age, children should not be treated with brutality or strict laws. Critics often argue that crime is crime whether it is committed by a child or an adult. However, the philosophy of juvenile justice acknowledges that cognitive development is not yet mature and children have an immense capacity for rehabilitation. A study indicates that the children between 16 and 18 years of age are more likely to commit offences as compared to the younger ones There is always hope for and from every child.

Recognizing these realities, the global community embraced a child-centered approach to juvenile justice and adopted basic principles to deal with young offenders. First, it must be made clear that when a child comes into conflict with the law, alternatives should be offered instead of processing him/her through the formal justice system. Second, there needs to be an exclusive juvenile justice system. Third, during the investigation, a juvenile should not be kept in a regular police station and the judicial process needs to be quick. Lastly, it must be ensured that the state gives a message to juveniles that it believes in their potential for reform.

International laws promote the reintegration of children into society, but sadly, this approach is missing in the juvenile justice system of Pakistan. Punjab has only two Borstal Institutes & Juvenile Jails at Bahawalpur and Faisalabad, while Sindh has five Youthful Offenders Industrial Schools in Karachi, Hyderabad, Sukkur, Larkana and Dadu, although the facility in Dadu is non-operational. The KPK has one Borstal in Bannu, whereas Balochistan does not have even a single functional Borstal Institute or juvenile jail. This lack of physical infrastructure causes a considerable number of juveniles to be imprisoned in regular prisons. Placing children in such an overcrowded environment exposes them in proximity to criminals and causes psychological distress, which undermines the rehabilitation capacity of prisoners. No less troubling is the lack of juvenile courts across the country. As a result, most children have continued to go through regular courts that cannot cater to their developmental needs.

A joint report by UNICEF and the Commissioner for Children’s Complaint Office of Pakistan has found that as of November 2023, 81% of the total juvenile offenders in Punjab were detained in ordinary jails, and only 144 prisoners were housed in Borstal Institutes. In January 2026, Punjab Prison Department released a report, according to which there are 718 juvenile prisoners in Punjab, while the total capacity is 658 prisoners. The shortage of juvenile institutions further highlights the flaws in the juvenile justice system of Pakistan.

It is the state’s responsibility to transform vulnerable children into responsible citizens. Therefore, the Government of Pakistan must move beyond merely passing laws that remain largely unimplemented and instead take concrete and pragmatic steps. The country should develop an implementation plan for the juvenile justice system, allocate adequate financial resources, strengthen the diversion mechanism to resolve minor juvenile cases outside the formal justice system, establish child-friendly rehabilitation centers that promote a sense of responsibility towards society, develop specialized juvenile police units to replace the use of police lock-ups for children, protect juveniles from torture and capital punishment while in detention, recruit trained staff, address the root causes of juvenile delinquency, such as poverty, illiteracy, unemployment, unsafe neighborhoods and the growing number of street children through social welfare programs and introduce a real-time Prison Management Information System (PMIS) to monitor juvenile offenders and support evidence-based decision-making.

Every child lost to crime symbolizes not merely an individual failure but a social breakdown and failure of state governance. Invest in the rehabilitation of juvenile offenders to build a safer and stable Pakistan tomorrow. Immature minds need nourishment, not punishment.

Similar Posts

  • Stay safe from viral fever during monsoon

    When the rainy season begins after the hot summer cases of different illnesses often increase.  Viral fever is one of the common health problems people may experience during changing weather. Many people first develop a sore throat or runny nose followed by fever that may last several days.  It can leave the body feeling weak and may cause headaches body aches, chest discomfort or throat pain. Children older adults and people with weaker immune systems may be more likely to develop complications. A few simple habits can help reduce the risk of infections during the rainy season. Keep your hands clean Germs and viruses can stay on frequently touched surfaces such as door handles mobile phones railings and other objects. Wash your hands with soap and clean water for at least 20 seconds after returning home before eating and after using the bathroom.  If soap and water are not available use an alcohol based hand sanitizer. Try not to touch your eyes nose or mouth with unwashed hands. Eat a healthy diet A healthy diet supports the body’s immune system. During the rainy season include fresh fruits vegetables lentils, milk yogurt and eggs in your meals. Foods containing vitamin C and zinc can also be part of a balanced diet. Try to avoid unhygienic street food and foods that are heavily fried. Drink safe and clean water Rainy weather can increase the risk of infections caused by contaminated water.  Drink properly filtered or boiled water whenever possible. Avoid uncovered drinks and ice from places where water  quality is uncertain. Drinking enough clean water throughout the day also helps prevent dehydration. Take care after getting wet If you get caught in the rain change out of wet clothes as soon as possible and dry  your hair properly. Staying in wet clothes for a long time can make you uncomfortable and may contribute to illness. If needed take a warm shower and change into clean, dry clothes. Get enough sleep and rest Good sleep helps the body maintain a healthy immune system. Poor sleep and constant stress can affect overall health. Try to get around seven to eight hours of sleep each night. Light exercise walking or gentle yoga can also help keep the body active. Avoid close contact with sick people Some viral infections can spread through coughing sneezing and close contact.  Keep some distance from people who are sick and avoid crowded places when possible. Wear a mask when needed and do not share personal items such as towels drinking bottles or utensils with someone who is ill.  Cover your mouth and nose with a tissue or your elbow when coughing or sneezing. Pay attention to early symptoms Do not ignore symptoms such as fever sore throat headache runny nose or body aches. Get enough rest drink warm fluids and monitor your condition. Avoid taking antibiotics without medical advice because antibiotics do not treat most viral infections and unnecessary use can be harmful. Know when to see a doctor Seek medical care if your fever reaches 102°F (38.9°C) or higher lasts for more than three days or is accompanied by breathing difficulty repeated vomiting fainting, or severe weakness. The rainy season can be enjoyable but taking basic health precautions is important. Good hygiene safe food and water enough rest and early attention to symptoms can help reduce the risk of illness during changing weather.

  • Too much gaming may harm children

    Online and video games are a popular source of entertainment for children.  However experts warn that spending too much time playing games can affect a child’s mental physical and social development. Playing games in moderation can be enjoyable but excessive gaming may lead to several problems. Experts say the growing popularity of video games among children is becoming a concern around the world. Spending long hours in front of a screen can reduce time for schoolwork exercise and other healthy activities. Research also suggests that too much gaming may make some children more irritable angry or aggressive. According to experts excessive gaming may also affect brain function and the nervous system. Children who spend too much time playing games may lose interest in their studies perform poorly at school and become more likely to develop an unhealthy dependence on video games. Too much screen time can also reduce social interaction. Instead of spending time with family and friends children may prefer staying alone with their games which can affect their communication and relationship skills. Pediatric experts advise parents to set clear limits on screen time and encourage children to take part in other activities. Outdoor games painting arts and crafts reading and other creative hobbies can support healthy physical and mental development. These activities are even more beneficial when parents are involved. Experts also say that spending time with siblings and family members helps children build stronger relationships confidence, and social skills.  If video games become a child’s main focus family life and personal development may suffer. Experts do not recommend banning video games completely as learning to use technology is important today. Instead parents should set reasonable gaming limits monitor what their children play and encourage a balanced lifestyle that includes learning physical activity and family time.

  • Survey finds divide over AI

    A new report from the Pew Research Center shows that artificial intelligence (AI) experts and the general public have very different opinions about the future of AI. While experts are mostly positive about its impact many people are worried that AI could replace jobs and create new challenges. According to the survey, 56% of AI experts believe the technology will have a positive effect on the United States over the next 20 years. In comparison, only 17% of the public share that view. Experts are more confident that AI will improve the way people work and help grow the economy. However many people are concerned that AI could reduce job opportunities especially in roles that depend on human workers. The report also highlights the jobs experts believe are most likely to be affected by AI. About 73% think cashier jobs could be replaced followed by truck drivers (62%) journalists (60%) factory workers (60%) and software engineers (50%). The public generally agrees with these predictions although only 33% believe truck drivers are at high risk. Both experts and the public agree that healthcare is one of the areas where AI can bring the greatest benefits. They believe AI could improve medical care and support better treatment. At the same time both groups are concerned that AI may not improve the accuracy of news or election coverage. The survey also found strong support for greater control over AI. Many respondents believe governments may struggle to regulate the technology effectively as it continues to develop. Another finding is the difference between male and female AI experts. Around 63% of male experts expect AI to have a positive impact on the United States compared with 36% of female experts. Women were generally more cautious saying the technology could have both benefits and risks. The report also notes that women remain underrepresented in the AI industry. Researchers suggest that increasing women’s participation in AI development could lead to more balanced technologies. They also point out that many jobs with a large number of female workers such as administrative and customer service roles are becoming more automated increasing the risk of job losses. Overall the report shows that understanding both expert opinions and public concerns is important. As AI continues to grow balancing its benefits with responsible rules and safeguards will be essential.

  • |

    Writers are embracing flaws to fight AI prose

    In an era where generative artificial intelligence can generate essays in seconds, the digital world is quietly witnessing a linguistic backlash. Readers are increasingly attuned to the invisible fingerprint of large language models. Perfectly balanced sentences, predictable three-item lists, flawless grammar and fondness for the em dash. In response, a movement of novelists, journalists, essayists, and even corporate creators are opting an anti-AI literary counterculture. These writers are actively reintroducing human idiosyncrasies ranging from unorthodox metaphors to intentional typos to declare that a human is behind the keyboard. The hallmark of standard AI-generated text is not necessarily bad grammar. In fact, it is often too clean. Text-generation algorithms default to statistically probable phrasing. It’s resulting in a distinctively smooth, neutral tone that rarely takes stylistic risks. Over the past few years, certain visual and structural patterns have become clear red flags for readers. Excessive dependence on em dashes. Relying on clinical or dramatic transitions like “In conclusion,” “Delve,” or “Navigating the landscape of…” Prose that seems lacking the natural rhythm, pauses, and unpredictable detours of spontaneous speech. To break free from these algorithmic habits, authors are adopting techniques anchored in absolute negation. Novelist Laura Brooke Robson, author of Love Is an Algorithm, noted that she actively altered her sentence structures to avoid robotic cadence. Instead of relying on conventional metaphors, she intentionally sought out unexpected punctuation. For creators, avoiding the default traps of language models has surprisingly made their writing more original and lively. This counterculture goes beyond simply avoiding specific punctuation marks. Writers are cultivating a distinct aesthetic centered on authenticity, vulnerability, and friction. After years of detached or objective styles, creators are leaning back into intimate first-person storytelling. Specific personal experiences, odd sensory details, and messy real-life observations serve as proof of lived experience. They prove to be something synthetic text generators cannot genuinely claim. Minor human flaws, casual slang and even subtle typos are being viewed as authentic signatures. Some digital platforms and creators have even experimented with tools that preserve raw keystrokes to signal genuine human origin. Instead of smoothing out every transition, writers are introducing erratic pacing, quirky similes, and inventive vocabulary. Authors create an experience that keeps the reader engaged. Deliberately reassuring them that the text wasn’t produced by an automated model. Can Artificial Intelligence Just Copy It? Skeptics of this trend point out an obvious paradox! If large language models are capable of processing complex prompts, they can just as easily be instructed to “write with typos,” “use casual grammar,” or “tell a quirky story in the first person.” From a purely technical perspective, intentional mistakes does not make prose impossible for a machine to imitate. However, proponents of the movement emphasize that outsmarting algorithms was never the primary goal. Instead, the anti-AI counterculture is an artistic statement about human craft and intention. Writing is fundamentally an act of personal communication between two minds. When readers engage with text, they are seeking the author’s unique perspective, effort, and creative voice. Ultimately, this movement signals how society values written communication. As machine-generated text becomes ubiquitous, hyper-polished prose is losing its premium status. What readers increasingly crave is not frictionless perfection, but the warmth and oddity of a human voice.  

  • The unforgettable legacy of Raja Mehdi Ali Khan

    Twentieth-century Urdu literature and Indian cinema was shaped by figures whose creativity crossed literary traditions and popular entertainment. Among these luminaries, Raja Mehdi Ali Khan stands out as a unique persona connecting high-art literary satire and immortal Bollywood melodies. This legend was born in 1915 in the historical town of Wazirabad. Khan was an observer of culture. He inherited a formidable poetic pedigree that caused him to be one of the most celebrated humorists and lyricists of his era. Raja Mehdi Ali Khan’s literary inclinations were virtually coded into his lineage. He was related to the renowned journalist and political figure Maulana Zafar Ali Khan. He was raised in an environment saturated with verse and socio-political commentary. Moreover, his mother was a recognized poetess in her own right. She taught him a deep reverence for language and rhythmic expression from an early age. This environment nurtured his inherent talent, allowing him to absorb classical Urdu poetic conventions while developing an understated wit that would define his future work. Before making a name for himself in the cinema, Khan began his journey in print journalism. He contributed prolifically to prominent periodicals and literary magazines of the era. The names included Monthly Alamgir, Weekly Khayyam, Tehzeeb-e-Niswan and Do Phool. His early journalistic writings allowed him to polish his observational skills. Whether analyzing social norms or painting witty portraits of everyday life, his prose stood out for its accessibility and warmth. Later, he transitioned into radio broadcasting. It’s considered a medium that further refined his sense of auditory storytelling and lyrical timing. He was driven by creative ambition. Later, Khan relocated to Bombay (now Mumbai) during a transformative era for Indian cinema. His entry into the film industry marked the beginning of a golden age for Hindi film music. He partnered with legendary music composers such as Madan Mohan. Khan penned lyrics that transcended simple movie themes, capturing profound emotional truths. His songs have proved to be timeless masterpieces, continuing to resonate across generations. Among his most iconic works are: hai isi mein pyaar ki aabru wo jafa karen main wafa karun jo wafa bhi kaam na aa sake to wahi kahen ki main kya karun Raja Mehdi Ali Khan, Anpadh (1962) His celebrated catalog includes evergreen classics. Lag Jaa Gale (Woh Kaun Thi?): Widely regarded as one of the greatest romantic ballads in Hindi cinema. Aapki Nazron Ne Samjha (Anpadh): A masterpiece of subtle expression and devotion. Jhumka Gira Re (Mera Saaya): A vibrant classic in popular culture. Tu Jahan Jahan Chalega (Mera Saaya): A hauntingly beautiful exploration of love and devotion. Agar Mujh Se Mohabbat Hai (Aap Ki Khaatir): A poignant reflection on romantic commitment. What set Raja Mehdi Ali Khan apart from many of his contemporaries was his dual identity.  Film audiences revered him for his deeply romantic and melancholic lyrics. On contrary, the literary world celebrated him as an exceptionally gifted humorist and satirist. Even amidst his demanding schedule in Bombay’s competitive cinematic landscape, Khan never abandoned his literary roots. His satirical essays and humorous poems were regularly featured in leading newspapers and journals across both India and Pakistan. His humor was rarely cynical. Instead, it offered a gentle, witty critique of human flaws, societal absurdities, and the complexities of modern living. Khan proved that high literary craft could flourish alongside popular music. Raja Mehdi Ali Khan passed away leaving behind a rich archive of literary contributions and cinematic songs that continue to be sung, reimagined, and loved today. His life journey from the quiet streets of Wazirabad to the recording studios of Bombay embodies the shared cultural heritage of the Indian subcontinent. His art remains vibrant and melodious whether delivered in a literary journal or sung by iconic playback singers.  

  • |

    Kashmir is beyond a geographic location

    For centuries, Kashmir has occupied a singular space in the poetic imagination. It is a region defined by a paradox. On one hand, earthly paradise of pristine lakes, towering snow-capped peaks and crimson autumn chinars. On the opposite, centuries of political upheaval, exile and grief. In literature, Kashmir is beyond a geographic location. It is a metaphor for divine beauty, and a testament to human endurance. The poetic tradition of Kashmir took root in spiritual mysticism and poignant lyricism during the medieval period. In the 14th century, the mystic poet Lal Ded pioneered the Vakh: four-line spiritual verse couplets in the Kashmiri vernacular. Her poetry bridged Hinduism and Sufism. It’s essence was inner purity, liberation, and the transcendence of physical suffering. I searched for my Self until I grew weary, No one, I thought, could reach this hidden knowledge. I plunged into it, and there found the jar of nectar. Habba Khatoon was known as the Nightingale of Kashmir. The 16th-century peasant-turned-queen introduced the Lol: a short, melodic form of love lyric. Her husband, King Yousuf Shah Chak, was exiled by the Mughal Emperor Akbar. Then, her poetry transformed into immortal songs of separation and longing. The spring has come, but you have not returned; My heart bleeds like the red bloom of the pomegranate. During the Mughal and Persian era, Kashmir became synonymous with heavenly superiority. The iconic Persian couplet often attributed to Amir Khusrow or Mughal Emperor Jahangir summarized this adoration: Agar firdaus bar roo-e zameen ast, Hamin ast-o hamin ast-o hamin ast. (If there is a paradise on the face of the earth, it is this, it is this, it is this.) In the 20th century, Allama Iqbal, whose ancestors hailed from Kashmir, brought a nuanced perspective to this paradise. In works like Javid Nama, he celebrated Kashmir’s breath-taking landscape while lamenting the subjugation and suffering of its people. He reflected on the region’s immense dormant potential in Payam-e-Mashriq: ​Pani tere chashmon ka hai aab-e-hayat, Aur tere kohsar hain qasran-e-kibriya. ​The water of your natural springs is the elixir of life, And your mountain ranges are towering palaces of divine grandeur. Iqbal’s verse moved beyond aesthetic wonder, using poetry as a call to dignity, resilience, and self-realization for the Kashmiris. In modern poetry, Kashmir’s narrative shifted dramatically toward exile, memory, and war. No poet captured this transition more powerfully than Agha Shahid Ali (1949–2001). He wrote primarily in English while employing traditional Urdu ghazal forms. Ali gave voice to the tragedy of late 20th-century Kashmir. In his seminal collection, The Country Without a Post Office (1997), Kashmir becomes a landscape of ghost letters, curfews, and faded memories. I write on fallen leaves and floating petals, I write to you from a country without a post office. Ali’s verse knits together global literary influences from Mahmoud Darwish to James Merrill. His poetry creates a poignant eulogy for a lost homeland. Their memory is anything but green, an white-hot fire. They burn down Kashmir in my veins. From the ascetic reflections of Lal Ded to the haunting elegies of Agha Shahid Ali, poetry has served as Kashmir’s truest archive. A disputed land of changing maps, borders, and historical conflicts. It’s the poetry that preserves the living soul of the land. The verses anchor its beauty, its heartbreaks, and its unyielding hope. Kashmir remains forever intact. It is an eternal paradise written in ink, surviving through the memory and voices of its poets.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *