geography governance

The Geography of Governance

By Syed Tahir Rashdi 

The writer is a Shahdadpur-based contributing columnist, book reviewer, and climate change activist. He holds a BS degree in Pakistan Studies from University of Sindh

Pakistan’s debate over new provinces has returned with familiar demands: South Punjab, Bahawalpur, Hazara, Karachi and, periodically, proposals for a more extensive reorganisation of the federation. There are credible arguments behind some of these demands. Population growth, administrative distance, uneven development and the persistence of regional identities have altered the circumstances in which Pakistan’s present provincial arrangement was conceived.

Yet the debate tends to proceed from an assumption that deserves greater scrutiny: that creating smaller provinces will, in itself, improve governance.

It may. But it may also not.

The distinction is important because Pakistan’s principal difficulty has never been simply the size of its administrative units. It has been the weakness, discontinuity and politicisation of the institutions through which those units are governed.

This does not make the case for new provinces illegitimate. It does, however, suggest that provincial restructuring should be considered as one component of administrative reform rather than as a substitute for it.

Pakistan’s provincial boundaries have never been immutable. The One Unit scheme of 1955 consolidated the western wing into a single province, partly to establish parity between the two wings of the country. It was abolished in 1970, restoring the provinces.

The episode remains relevant because it demonstrated the limits of administrative engineering. A territorial arrangement can be imposed constitutionally, but its durability ultimately depends upon political legitimacy.

The present debate is considerably more complex.

The demand for a South Punjab province contains at least three distinct strands: the historical claim associated with Bahawalpur, the linguistic and cultural politics of Saraiki identity, and the administrative argument that the southern districts have remained distant from the provincial centre in Lahore. There is also the persistent claim of regional economic neglect.

These strands should not be conflated.

Similarly, the Hazara demand has a strong identity component, while the Karachi question is inseparable from the city’s unusual demographic, economic and political history and the longstanding contest over authority between urban local institutions and the provincial government.

The differences matter because different problems require different institutional responses.

The Constitution does not make the creation of a new province a matter of political declaration. Article 239 provides a demanding procedure for constitutional amendment, including the approval of the concerned provincial assembly where provincial boundaries are affected.

That requirement is not an accidental obstacle. It reflects the logic of federalism: a federation cannot permit the territorial boundaries of one constituent unit to be altered without giving that unit a decisive constitutional voice.

The experience of the parliamentary commission on new provinces in 2012 illustrated the complexity of the exercise. Questions of boundaries, resources, representation, administrative structures and constitutional amendments quickly became inseparable from the political question of who would gain or lose influence.

That is why the debate deserves to be insulated, as far as possible, from electoral expediency.

There is, however, a more fundamental issue that receives considerably less attention.

Article 140-A of the Constitution requires provincial governments to establish local government systems and devolve political, administrative and financial responsibility and authority to elected local representatives.

This provision goes to the heart of the governance question.

A citizen’s encounter with government is rarely with the federal government or even with a provincial assembly. It is with the school, hospital, police station, municipal authority, land office, sanitation service or local administration.

Yet local governments in Pakistan have rarely acquired the institutional continuity, fiscal autonomy and political authority envisaged by the Constitution.

The result is an unusual form of devolution. The 18th Amendment substantially strengthened the provinces by transferring functions and resources from the federation, but the transfer of authority has often stopped at the provincial level.

Islamabad became less dominant.

The provinces became stronger.

The citizen did not necessarily become more powerful.

This is perhaps the most important issue in the new-provinces debate. If a region is suffering because decisions are too distant from its population, the first question should be whether existing institutions can be decentralised before an entirely new tier of government is created.

Comparative experience does not provide a universal answer, but it does offer useful cautions.

Indonesia’s post-Suharto decentralisation transferred extensive responsibilities to subnational governments. The reform was necessary after decades of centralised rule, but decentralisation itself did not guarantee effective or accountable government. Subsequent reforms had to focus on institutional capacity, fiscal management and local accountability.

Nigeria provides another caution. The creation of additional states was partly intended to improve political representation and accommodate regional interests. Yet the country continues to face substantial governance and institutional-capacity problems across its states.

The lesson from both cases is not that administrative restructuring is futile. It is that territorial fragmentation and institutional development are different processes.

South Africa offers a somewhat different model. Its Constitution explicitly recognises local government as a sphere of government and assigns municipalities constitutional responsibilities relating to democratic participation and service delivery. The significance lies less in the number of provinces than in the distribution of authority among the different levels of government.

Switzerland’s federal tradition similarly rests on substantial cantonal and communal autonomy. Its relevance to Pakistan is not institutional imitation but a principle: government functions should be located at the level at which they can be performed most effectively, while higher levels retain responsibilities that require wider coordination.

There is therefore no universally correct number of provinces. The appropriate administrative scale depends upon geography, population, fiscal capacity, the nature of the public service and, above all, institutional competence.

Pakistan’s governance difficulties are familiar enough to require little elaboration: weak rule of law, politicisation of public institutions, patronage, corruption, uneven accountability, administrative discontinuity and the recurrent weakening of local government.

None of these problems disappears when a provincial boundary is moved.

A new province may shorten the administrative distance between a region and its provincial capital. It does not automatically make the police independent, the bureaucracy professional, the courts accessible or public expenditure transparent.

Nor does it guarantee merit.

This is why the distinction between decentralisation and multiplication matters.

Creating another provincial government multiplies institutions at one level. Devolution transfers authority to the level where decisions are actually implemented.

The two can complement each other. They should not be confused.

There is a reasonable case for examining Pakistan’s provincial structure afresh. The country of today is considerably more populous, urbanised and economically differentiated than it was in 1973. Administrative arrangements that were workable five decades ago need not remain optimal indefinitely.

But restructuring should follow evidence.

If a region can demonstrate that a separate province would improve representation, service delivery, fiscal management and administrative effectiveness, its case should be considered seriously.

The same standard should apply to all proposals.

What is the fiscal base of the proposed province? How will assets and liabilities be divided? What will happen to water and other shared resources? How will the civil service be reorganised? Where will the judiciary sit? How will parliamentary representation change? And, perhaps most importantly, what powers will be devolved to local governments within the new province?

These are less exciting questions than the announcement of a new province. They are also the questions on which its viability will depend.

The temptation in politics is to seek visible solutions to structural problems. A new province is visible. A new secretariat is visible. A new assembly is visible.

Institutional reform is not.

An impartial appointment is invisible. A competent municipal service is rarely newsworthy. A police officer able to act without political interference does not make for a dramatic political slogan. Nor does a court that quietly delivers timely justice.

Yet these are the foundations upon which effective government rests.

Pakistan therefore needs to resist the idea that every failure of governance is a failure of territorial design.

There may be a case for new provinces. There is certainly a case for stronger local government. There is an even stronger case for institutions that function according to law rather than political convenience.

The order matters.

Before redrawing provincial boundaries, Pakistan should ask whether it has fully used the constitutional possibilities already available to it: provincial autonomy, fiscal devolution and empowered local government.

If, after that examination, some provinces still prove too large, too distant or administratively incoherent, restructuring would have a stronger foundation.

The issue, ultimately, is not how many provinces Pakistan has.

It is whether the citizen can rely on the government that exists.

A federation can have four provinces or ten. It can have large units or small ones. What it cannot indefinitely afford is the assumption that changing the map is equivalent to changing the state.

Pakistan’s next debate on provinces should therefore be less about where to draw the line and more about what happens on the other side of it.

Similar Posts

  • Marriage can change couples personalities, study reveals

    Marriage is often described as a situation where “those who marry regret it and those who do not marry regret that too.” Now, scientists have revealed a surprising effect that marriage can have on couples. According to researchers, the first two years of marriage can bring significant changes to the personalities of newly married couples. A joint study by the University of Georgia and the University of California found that personality changes during the first two years of marriage can have important long-term effects on marital relationships. According to the study, newlyweds experience noticeable changes in their personalities and these changes can influence their satisfaction with their relationship with their spouse. The research found that during the first 18 months of marriage, husbands tend to become more dependent on their wives and increasingly focus their attention on their wives rather than the outside world. The study also found that wives experienced reductions in anxiety, depression, feelings of inferiority, restlessness and stress. These positive personality changes were observed among couples of different age groups. However, researchers also noted one negative development: compatibility between husbands and wives tended to decrease. The researchers said that, overall, the findings show that men and women undergo significant personality changes soon after marriage and these changes can be important for developing a healthy long-term relationship. The findings of the study were published in the journal Developmental Psychology. Spousal support and stress Earlier, a study conducted by Binghamton University in the United States in April 2024 found that feeling a lack of support from a spouse can increase physical stress. This feeling can raise levels of cortisol, a hormone associated with stress. Cortisol works with parts of the brain involved in regulating mood, motivation and behaviour. Researchers said that people’s perceptions of their spouse’s support become stronger over time allowing them to predict how their partner is likely to behave in different situations. They further noted that support from a spouse is more important than people may expect.

  • Team sets record after 10 T-Shirt folding attempts

    David Rush, who has achieved more than 200 Guinness World Records has added another record to his name. This time he teamed up with 10 co-workers and a mental skills expert from Las Vegas to set a new record for folding T-shirts. During a team building trip to Las Vegas the 12-member team attempted to fold 12 T-shirts in a relay race as quickly as possible. The previous record was 2 minutes and 24 seconds. After several failed attempts David and his team finally completed the challenge in just 2 minutes and 19.65 seconds. The challenge was not only about speed. Team members also had to follow the rules carefully. Folding a shirt incorrectly starting too early or making even a small mistake could cancel the entire attempt. The team needed 10 attempts to break the record. Several early attempts failed because of rule violations.  Some members folded the shirts incorrectly while others started their turn too soon. On their final successful attempt all 12 members followed the rules perfectly and finished the relay in 2 minutes and 19.65 seconds officially setting a new Guinness World Record for the fastest relay-style T-shirt folding challenge.

  • Fight Against Thalassemia

    By Baloch Khan Thalassemia is a serious inherited blood disorder that affects thousands of families in Pakistan. Many patients, especially children, depend on regular blood transfusions and expensive treatment to survive. Sadly, many families cannot afford these costs, and blood shortages make their struggle even harder. The government, hospitals, and welfare organizations should work together to improve awareness about thalassemia. Free screening before marriage, public education campaigns, and better access to treatment can help prevent new cases and save lives. Blood donation drives should also be organized regularly so that no patient suffers due to a lack of blood. It is time to treat thalassemia as a national health priority. With greater awareness, timely screening, and public support, we can reduce the burden of this disease and give patients hope for a healthier future.

  • Easy ways to reduce belly fat

    A large belly can affect your appearance but extra body fat can also increase the risk of several health problems. Health experts say that reducing belly fat requires healthy eating regular exercise enough sleep and limiting sugary foods and fast food. Making these habits part of your daily routine can support healthy weight management. Exercise regularly Getting at least 30 minutes of physical activity each day may help with weight control and reducing overall body fat. Walking cycling jogging and other forms of exercise can be included in your daily routine. Good quality sleep is also important. Poor or irregular sleep can make it harder to maintain a healthy weight. Why belly fat can be a concern Extra fat around the stomach is not only a cosmetic issue. Some of it can build up around internal organs.  Higher levels of abdominal fat have been linked with an increased risk of health problems such as heart disease and  type 2 diabetes. A traditional herbal mix Some people also try traditional home remedies when they want to lose weight.  One commonly used mixture contains several herbs and spices including: •Dry ginger •Mint •Black seed •Ajwain •Black cumin •Fennel seeds •Small cardamom How it prepared The ingredients are usually ground into a powder and stored in a clean dry jar.  A small amount is traditionally taken after meals sometimes with a warm herbal drink. However there is not enough scientific evidence to consider this mixture a proven treatment for belly fat or weight loss.  Herbal ingredients can also affect some people differently or interact with medicines. It is better to speak with a doctor or qualified health professional before using such remedies regularly. Healthy habits matter most There is no magic drink or home remedy that can specifically burn belly fat.  The most reliable approach is to maintain a healthy calorie balance eat nutritious foods stay physically active get enough sleep and follow these habits consistently. Remember reducing overall body fat takes time so focus on healthy and steady progress rather than quick results.

  • Punjab Clean Water Program

    By Saif Awan   Water is a tremendous blessing—a truth best understood by those for whom it remains a rare commodity even in this modern era. Across Pakistan, including several regions in Punjab, safe drinking water is still inaccessible to many. Local residents are often forced to travel miles just to fulfill their basic water needs. Even in Karachi, the country’s economic hub, clean drinking water remains scarce. Access to clean water is a fundamental necessity, fully appreciated only by those who yearn for it or those who truly grasp its importance. Among basic amenities, safe drinking water holds the utmost priority. Clean water directly impacts not only human health but also education, the economy, the environment, and the overall quality of life. In Punjab, several regions still lack access to safe drinking water. Settlement clusters in Southern Punjab, Cholistan, Thal, and the foothills of Koh-e-Suleman have historically faced a severe water crisis. For decades, millions of residents in these areas have been forced to consume groundwater that contains levels of salts, arsenic, fluoride, and other hazardous contaminants far exceeding international safety limits. Consequently, gastrointestinal, liver, kidney, skin, and bone diseases are widespread, while children’s physical development is severely compromised. To ensure the public has access to safe, high-quality drinking water, Chief Minister of Punjab Maryam Nawaz has launched the **”Chief Minister Clean Water Program.”** The Punjab government has allocated PKR 8 billion for this initiative in the current fiscal year’s budget. Under this program, 5,600 water filtration plants are being installed across various regions of Punjab. All these filtration plants will undergo digital geo-tagging to facilitate continuous performance evaluation and real-time monitoring. This project is far more than a routine development scheme; it is a vital public health, social welfare, and human dignity initiative aimed at bringing clean water to regions that have lacked this basic facility for years. In several districts of Punjab, poor groundwater quality has been a critical concern for decades. High levels of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), arsenic, fluoride, and nitrates not only affect the taste of water but also inflict long-term adverse health effects. In the first phase of the Chief Minister Clean Water Program, areas facing the most acute water shortages were selected, specifically in Khushab, Dera Ghazi Khan, Rahim Yar Khan, and Bahawalnagar. State-of-the-art water bottling plants have been established in these districts, where water undergoes multi-stage purification in accordance with international standards. This purified water is then filled into 19-liter bottles and distributed to citizens free of cost. This initiative is especially transformative for families who previously had to travel several kilometers daily to fetch water or were forced to consume contaminated water. The Punjab Saaf Pani Authority has deployed cutting-edge, internationally imported machinery for the project. Each plant features an advanced multi-stage purification system combined with rigorous laboratory testing to ensure that every drop delivered meets World Health Organization (WHO) standards. A single plant has the capacity to fill approximately 150 bottles per hour. Operating for just ten hours a day, one plant can cater to thousands of families daily. Alongside this, an advanced management system has been established to monitor plant efficiency, water quality, and the supply chain to ensure an uninterrupted supply of clean water to citizens. A standout feature of this program is that the water bottling plants are powered by **Solar Energy**. This initiative will significantly reduce electricity costs while contributing to environmental conservation, carbon footprint reduction, and the realization of global Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Consequently, experts regard this project not merely as a water delivery scheme, but as a comprehensive strategy integrating health, environmental protection, and sustainable development. Another key aspect of the initiative is its tailored design to accommodate elderly citizens, women, and persons with disabilities who cannot carry or fetch water from distant sources. Large water bottles will be delivered to designated distribution points, allowing residents to collect clean water easily. Additional distribution centers will be established in proportion to population density in each district to maximize public benefit. The selection of the four initial districts—Dera Ghazi Khan, Khushab, Rahim Yar Khan, and Bahawalnagar—was not coincidental, but based on scientific and technical assessments. Groundwater in these regions has long been deemed unfit for human consumption. In many areas, TDS levels far exceed global standards, while the presence of hazardous elements such as arsenic, fluoride, and nitrates remains a constant concern. The Chief Minister Clean Water Program is projected to benefit over 29 million citizens in the coming years. Initial results have been highly encouraging, and the government plans to phase this model into other districts, ensuring every citizen across the province gains access to safe, quality drinking water. If the project maintains its current momentum and standard, it will evolve from a government scheme into a benchmark model for public health, social welfare, and sustainable development in Punjab. Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz’s “Chief Minister Clean Water Program” is a direct effort to translate this vision into reality. By delivering quality drinking water to millions in remote and underdeveloped areas, its impact will extend well beyond healthcare to encompass education, the economy, the environment, and overall living standards. The true success of any public project lies not in its announcement, but in its long-term outcomes. If the program continues to maintain transparency, quality, and steady expansion, it holds the potential to become a role model for safe water delivery across Punjab and all of Pakistan. If every drop of clean water protects a family from illness, enables a child to pursue an education in good health, relieves a mother from the grueling task of fetching water from afar, and affords an elderly person a dignified life—then this is not merely a development project, but the beginning of a genuine transformation in human lives.

  • |

    China introduces brain-controlled robot technology

    Several countries are actively developing Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) technology which enables people to interact with devices using only their thoughts without the need for physical movement. Now, a Chinese company is working to integrate this technology into robots. According to BrainCo, the company has developed the world’s first brain-to-robot interface system allowing robots to be controlled directly through human thought. The company said the system works using EEG headsets which are worn by human operators. These headsets monitor brain activity and translate it into commands that are sent to the robot. Like other BCI technologies, the system relies on extensive training data that maps specific patterns of brain activity to corresponding actions. Artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms are then used to accurately interpret a person’s intended action and convert it into the correct robotic response. The technology called the Brain-Controlled Robot AI Platform was unveiled at the World Artificial Intelligence Conference in Shanghai. BrainCo said the system can be used not only to control robots but also to operate robotic arms and other connected devices. The platform continuously collects data which is used to further improve its AI algorithms and enhance performance over time. According to the company, rapid advances in AI have enabled robots to perform many tasks independently. However, it believes the next major challenge is ensuring that robots can effectively understand and collaborate with the humans working alongside them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *