triangle trust tension

The Triangle of Trust and Tension: Pakistan, Afghanistan, and India

ByJustpaste.in

By Engr. Saqlain Abid

Geography is destiny. A nation cannot choose its neighbours, but it can choose how to live with them. The strongest defence in any democracy is not perpetual conflict but sustained diplomacy, confidence-building measures, and peaceful negotiations. Pakistan and Afghanistan are two countries bound by centuries of shared history, religion, culture, and ethnic ties. Yet, what was once described as a brotherly relationship has gradually transformed into one defined by mistrust, accusations, and strategic competition. Today, India has emerged as the third player in this evolving regional triangle.

 

What exactly went wrong? How did decades of goodwill give way to blame games and border tensions? And why is India now finding greater strategic space in Afghanistan? These questions have become even more relevant following Amnesty International’s allegations regarding Pakistan’s reported airstrikes on the Omeed Rehabilitation Centre near Kabul on 14 March. The organisation questioned Pakistan’s justification for the operation, while Islamabad firmly rejected the allegations and maintained that its forces targeted legitimate security threats. The competing narratives deserve careful examination.

 

The first perspective is that of Afghanistan. Following the withdrawal of US forces in 2021, Pakistan welcomed the Taliban’s return to power. General Faiz Hameed, then ISI chief, was closely associated with the Doha process, while the government of Imran Khan projected Pakistan as a key mediator in Afghanistan’s political transition. Relations initially appeared warmer than they had been for years.

 

However, the atmosphere soon changed. One of the major turning points was the case of Sharifullah, an alleged ISIS-K commander. Pakistan argued that his arrest strengthened its claims regarding cross-border terrorism and militant networks operating from Afghan territory. The Taliban leadership rejected these accusations, insisting that Afghanistan should not be blamed for Pakistan’s internal security challenges.

 

Instead of responding through military escalation, Kabul gradually diversified its diplomatic and economic partnerships. Trade with India expanded while commerce with Pakistan declined. Afghanistan increasingly relied on Iran’s Chabahar Port and the India-built Zaranj–Delaram Highway to reduce dependence on Pakistani transit routes. Although these alternatives are longer and more expensive, Kabul appears willing to pay that price in pursuit of greater strategic autonomy. For the Taliban government, sovereignty has become closely linked with economic independence.

 

The controversy surrounding the reported strike on the Omeed Rehabilitation Centre further widened the trust deficit. Human rights organisations questioned Pakistan’s account of the operation, while Islamabad maintained that the target was linked to militant activity and defended its actions as part of its counterterrorism campaign. The differing claims remain disputed and continue to shape international perceptions.

 

Pakistan’s narrative is considerably different. Islamabad maintains that the resurgence of Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) attacks represents one of its greatest national security challenges. Successive governments have argued that militant groups continue to exploit Afghan territory to launch attacks inside Pakistan. From Islamabad’s perspective, stronger military action became unavoidable because diplomatic engagement failed to produce sufficient cooperation.

 

The arrest of Sharifullah also carried broader geopolitical significance. Pakistan’s intelligence cooperation with the United States strengthened Islamabad’s engagement with Washington. At the same time, the government accelerated the repatriation of undocumented Afghan migrants, arguing that national security required stricter border management. Critics viewed these measures as increasing pressure on the Taliban government, while Pakistan defended them as sovereign decisions taken in the national interest.

 

Perhaps the greatest strategic miscalculation, however, was underestimating how quickly a trusted partner could seek new alliances. History shows that when friends become rivals, they often understand each other’s vulnerabilities better than long-standing adversaries.

 

India forms the third side of this regional triangle. Over the past two decades, New Delhi has invested billions of dollars in Afghanistan through reconstruction projects, infrastructure, education, and trade. As relations between Islamabad and Kabul have deteriorated, India has found greater diplomatic space to strengthen its presence. Development assistance, expanding trade, and improved connectivity have gradually transformed India into an increasingly influential partner for Afghanistan.

 

The result is a new regional reality. Pakistan views Afghanistan primarily through the lens of security. Afghanistan seeks strategic independence and diversified economic partnerships. India has capitalised on the growing mistrust by expanding its diplomatic and commercial footprint.

 

Geography cannot be changed, but policies can. Pakistan and Afghanistan will remain neighbours regardless of political differences. Continued confrontation will benefit neither country, while diplomacy, intelligence cooperation, and mutual respect remain the only sustainable path forward. The future of South Asia will depend not on military victories but on whether Islamabad, Kabul, and New Delhi choose cooperation over confrontation.

Similar Posts

  • New image reveal Sun’s surface in amazing detail

    ByJustpaste.in

    Looking directly at the Sun is impossible and capturing a clear image of it is even more difficult. However, new images of the star at the center of our solar system have been released showing its surface in extraordinary detail. The images were captured by the Inouye Solar Telescope located in the US state of Hawaii. It is considered the world’s most powerful solar telescope and is capable of observing the Sun in unprecedented detail. The telescope has captured images of the Sun before but these new photographs provide the most detailed views yet of the surface of our solar system’s star. A unique wing-like pattern can be seen across the Sun’s surface in the images. According to scientists, this pattern is associated with the Sun’s magnetic field which is moving in a wave-like manner due to hot gases. Closer look at Sun’s surface The images reveal processes occurring on the Sun’s surface that may help explain a decades-old mystery: why the Sun’s outer atmosphere known as the corona is millions of times hotter than its visible surface. Experts say these are the highest-resolution images of the Sun’s surface ever captured. In earlier observations, the telescope detected sand-like structures on the Sun’s surface making it appear as though grains of sand were being viewed under a microscope. Each of these structures was roughly the size of France in terms of area but the new images reveal much greater detail. The new photographs show a distinctive pattern on the Sun’s surface associated with rapidly moving plasma. Scientists have identified this pattern as Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities (KHIs). Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities have been observed on Earth during the formation of patterns in lakes, oceans and clouds. They have also been detected on Jupiter and Saturn but their presence on the Sun had not previously been confirmed. Why Sun’s magnetic activity matters? Solar activity particularly changes in the Sun’s magnetic fields can affect power grids, satellites, GPS positioning and global communications on Earth. These magnetic fields are generated by the Sun’s extremely hot plasma but scientists have not yet fully understood how they work. Experts know that these magnetic fields can trigger sudden releases of enormous amounts of heat but exactly why this happens remains unclear. The new images, however, provide clues that could help explain why the Sun’s visible surface has a temperature of around 6,000°C while its outer atmosphere can reach temperatures of millions of degrees Celsius.

  • 3 Houseplants that may attract lizards

    ByJustpaste.in

    Lizards often appear in homes during the summer especially in kitchens bathrooms and near indoor plants. While they are usually harmless many people find them unpleasant. They can also become a hygiene concern if they come into contact with food. Experts say some houseplants may attract lizards because they provide cool damp and shaded places where the reptiles like to hide. One of the most common plants is the money plant. Its large leaves and moist soil create a cool environment making it a favorite hiding place for lizards. If the vine grows up a wall or support lizards may climb and rest among the leaves. Another plant that may attract lizards is jasmine. The plant offers a cool leafy space and some experts believe its dense growth makes it a comfortable shelter for lizards. Marigold plants may also attract them. Their thick leaves create shade giving lizards a safe place to hide during hot weather. The good news is that you do not need to remove these plants. There are a few simple home remedies that may help keep lizards away. Placing camphor tablets near plant pots is one popular method because lizards dislike their strong smell. You can also place half an onion or a few garlic cloves near the pots as their odor may help repel lizards. Another natural option is bay leaves whose strong scent is believed to discourage lizards from staying near plants. Experts also recommend keeping the area around plants clean. Dry leaves weeds and garden waste can attract insects which are the main food source for lizards. By reducing insects and maintaining good hygiene around your plants and home you can also reduce the chances of lizards appearing.

  • | |

    The rise of Alfred, Lord Tennyson

    ByJustpaste.in

    On August 6, 1809, one of the defining literary voices of the 19th century was born: Alfred, Lord Tennyson. Tennyson came to embody the doubts, solemnity, and romantic ideals of the Victorian era. He served as Britain’s Poet Laureate for more than four decades during the height of Queen Victoria’s reign. Early Brilliance and Sharp Criticism Tennyson’s journey to becoming a beloved national figure was anything but smooth. Raised in a large, tumultuous household by a clergyman father, young Alfred sought escape through verse. His talents surfaced early; while studying at Cambridge, he won the prestigious Chancellor’s Gold Medal in 1829 for his poem Timbuktu. Shortly thereafter, he published early collections containing works such as Mariana and Claribel. These early publications showcased his extraordinary musicality and eye for detail, yet contemporary critics were not entirely impressed. Severe reviews dismissed his work as overly melancholic, affected, and sentimental. The hostility of these early critiques shook Tennyson deeply, prompting a decade-long period of publishing silence. A phase scholars often refer to as his ten years’ silence. Crafting the Masterpieces Rather than abandoning his craft, Tennyson spent those quiet years refining his technique, studying philosophy, and confronting personal tragedy. The sudden death of his closest friend, Arthur Henry Hallam, plunged Tennyson into profound grief. This loss became the catalyst for his most famous masterpiece, In Memoriam A.H.H. Published in 1850, the massive elegy explored faith, mortality, and scientific progress, striking a deep chord with a Victorian public navigating rapid industrialization and societal change. The immense success of In Memoriam transformed his standing almost overnight. That same year, following the death of William Wordsworth, Queen Victoria appointed Tennyson as Poet Laureate. He went on to compose iconic works that defined the national consciousness, including The Charge of the Light Brigade, Ulysses, and his epic Arthurian cycle, Idylls of the King. A Lasting Literary Legacy While early critics painted him as a sentimentalist, history remembers Tennyson as a master craftsman of English rhythm and sound. Lines like; “To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield” (Ulysses) have woven themselves permanently into the modern lexicon. His ability to blend intimate personal emotion with grand societal themes elevated him from a criticized young poet to an enduring pillar of world literature. Key Milestones in Tennyson’s Career 1809: Born in Somersby, Lincolnshire on August 6. 1829: Wins the Chancellor’s Gold Medal at Cambridge for Timbuktu. 1830: Publishes Poems, Chiefly Lyrical, introducing works like Mariana and Claribel. 1850: Publishes In Memoriam A.H.H. and is appointed Poet Laureate by Queen Victoria. 1854: Pens The Charge of the Light Brigade, capturing national sentiment during the Crimean War. 1892: Passes away at age 83, buried in Poets’ Corner at Westminster Abbey.

  • |

    Does placing Wi-Fi router on floor weaken signals?

    ByJustpaste.in

    You may have heard that the location of a Wi-Fi router plays an important role in its performance. Placing a router in a poor location can negatively affect the strength and range of internet signals. But what happens if you place a Wi-Fi router on the floor? The answer is that a Wi-Fi router can be placed on the floor but generally, it is not an ideal location. One reason is that when a router is placed on the floor, a significant portion of its Wi-Fi signals may be directed toward the ground. In addition, placing the router on the floor increases the chances of its signals being blocked or weakened by furniture and other household objects. As you may know, most Wi-Fi routers have antennas that transmit signals at different angles. Therefore, when a Wi-Fi router is placed on the floor, many of its signals may travel directly toward the floor instead of spreading efficiently throughout the room. Walls along the path of Wi-Fi signals can also act as obstacles. That is why it is generally recommended to place your Wi-Fi router in an elevated location such as on a shelf. The higher the router is placed, the better the signal coverage is likely to be throughout the house. It is also better to place the router in an open area where there are fewer household objects around it. Although placing a Wi-Fi router on the floor is not ideal, it is not necessarily the worst possible location. In fact, placing a router close to electrical appliances can be even worse. Therefore, you should avoid placing your Wi-Fi router near devices such as televisions, microwave ovens, refrigerators, Bluetooth devices and other electronic appliances as they can significantly interfere with signal coverage.

  • AC mistake to avoid after heat

    ByJustpaste.in

    After spending time outside in extreme heat switching on the air conditioner as soon as you get home may feel refreshing. However health experts say this habit can sometimes be harmful. According to doctors the body works continuously to keep its temperature balanced. In hot weather it cools itself by producing sweat and widening blood vessels. If you suddenly move from intense heat into a very cold room your body experiences a rapid temperature change. This is known as thermal shock. Experts say this sudden change may cause headaches sore throat coughing dizziness tiredness breathing problems or a feeling of discomfort. People with asthma allergies or other breathing conditions may be affected more seriously. Health specialists recommend resting for a few minutes in a shaded or normally cooled area after coming home instead of sitting directly in front of the AC. This gives your body time to adjust gradually. They also advise drinking enough water before entering a very cold room. Hot weather can lead to dehydration and staying hydrated helps reduce stress on the body. Another concern is that air conditioners can dry out the air which may dry the nose and throat. This can lead to throat irritation dryness or coughing especially if the AC is set to a very low temperature or the cold air blows directly on the body. Doctors say there is no need to avoid using an air conditioner during summer. Instead keep the temperature at a comfortable level drink plenty of water and avoid moving straight from extreme heat into a very cold environment. These simple steps can help protect your health and reduce the risk of heat related problems.

  • | | |

    Parliament should focus on Pakistan’s real c…

    ByJustpaste.in

    Pakistan is an Islamic republic whose Constitution defines not only the structure of the state but also its ideological foundation. It explicitly states that the country should create an environment in which Muslims can live their lives in accordance with the teachings of the Quran and Sunnah. Against this constitutional backdrop, it is surprising that the issue of women wearing the abaya—or an Islamic financial institution including the abaya in its employee dress code—has become a matter of concern for a parliamentary committee. This naturally raises an important question: Who is setting the country’s priorities, and are these truly the issues that deserve Parliament’s attention? Pakistan continues to face pressing challenges, including rising inflation, unemployment, an unequal tax system, a struggling economy, and serious shortcomings in education and healthcare. These are the issues that directly affect the daily lives of millions of citizens. If a parliamentary standing committee, whose primary responsibility is financial oversight, chooses to focus instead on the dress code of Islamic banks, it is reasonable for the public to question whether legislative priorities are aligned with the country’s most urgent needs. The debate also raises questions about consistency. Critics have objected to the abaya as part of an institutional dress code, yet there is little discussion about uniforms in many government departments that follow Western styles of dress. Women serving in the police, the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), and several other public institutions are commonly required to wear trousers and shirts as part of their official uniforms. If clothing is to become a matter of parliamentary debate, then similar standards should apply across the board. Selective criticism can create the perception of bias. Supporters of Islamic dress codes argue that the issue extends beyond clothing itself and reflects broader concerns about cultural and religious identity. From this perspective, the concern is not simply about the abaya but about a mindset that views visible expressions of religious identity as obstacles to modernization. They question whether institutions with an Islamic identity should be expected to abandon their traditions in the name of progress. This leads to a broader debate: Who defines what it means to be modern? Does modernization necessarily require reducing the public expression of religious values or adopting Western cultural norms? For institutions operating within Pakistan’s Islamic banking framework, supporters argue that their identity is rooted not only in financial principles but also in ethical and religious values. If such institutions adopt internal policies that comply with Pakistani law and reflect constitutional and religious principles, they contend that those choices should be respected. The discussion also draws comparisons with international examples. In countries such as France, restrictions on religious clothing have generated significant criticism from human rights advocates. Supporters of religious freedom argue that Pakistan, which was established with a distinct religious and cultural identity, should carefully consider whether adopting similar approaches is consistent with its own constitutional framework and historical foundations. Ultimately, the central argument is that Parliament should devote its time and resources to addressing issues that directly affect governance, economic stability, and public welfare. Matters of personal attire, religious belief, and institutional identity, many argue, should not become subjects of unnecessary official intervention when the country faces far more pressing social and economic challenges.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *