analysing pakistans system
| |

Analysing Pakistan’s system collapse through Orwell’s 1984

Pakistan’s Interior Minister, Mohsin Naqvi, publicly conceded that the nation’s existing governance structure has collapsed. The minister admitted that the administrative machinery can no longer resolve the country’s compounding socio-economic crises. The phrase strategically slipped through while addressing the Pakistan Economic Summit in Islamabad. He warned that adhering to the status quo would drag the nation into the same stagnant cycle  ten years from now. Amidst, he called upon political parties to set aside differences, decentralize power, and establish new administrative units to avert total destabilization.

Yet, this public declaration does not occur in a vacuum. It arrives amidst mounting public resentment, economic desperation, and an escalating crackdown on political dissent, particularly in regions like Azad Jammu & Kashmir and urban political centers where mass protests against state austerity and police overreach have intensified. On the surface, the minister’s statement sounds like a candid plea for political reform and democratic unity. Beneath it, lies a far more insidious dynamic. One that mirrors the political theology of George Orwell’s classic dystopian novel, 1984.

Big Brother and the Permanent State

In Orwell’s 1984, the state of Oceania is governed by a dual reality. On the visible surface sits the Outer Party and its administrative ministries: the Ministry of Peace (which wages war), the Ministry of Plenty (which manages scarcity), and the Ministry of Truth (which manufactures lies). But behind these facade institutions resides the true, unquestionable entity: the Party itself, epitomized by the omnipotent figure of Big Brother. The purpose of the ministers, bureaucrats, and politicians is not to serve the citizenry, but to safeguard the survival of the core entity at all costs.

When applied to the political landscape of Pakistan, the Interior Minister’s declaration functions as a quintessential display of Orwellian doublethink. The ability to hold two contradictory beliefs in one’s mind simultaneously and accept both of them. The visible civilians admit powerlessness, yet the hidden apparatus of establishment and the deep-state continues to wield absolute authority.

The state apparatus operates under an unwritten constitutional clause: individual rights, democratic mandates, and administrative cohesion may be sacrificed, so long as the core, permanent security apparatus remains untouched and supreme.

Echoes From 1971 to Kashmir

This pattern of preserving an unseen core entity while allowing civilian institutions to decay is not a novel phenomenon. Rather, it is the recurring motif of the region’s post-colonial history.

During the 1971 crisis in East Pakistan, the political leadership and the military high command operated under the illusion that they were protecting the sacred unity of the state. In reality, the democratic mandate of the majority population in Bengal was suppressed to protect the ideological and structural hegemony of the West Pakistani establishment—the ruling entity. The state prioritized the preservation of its central ruling elite over the actual people, ultimately leading to the violent birth of Bangladesh.

Similarly, in the context of Kashmir, both regional state apparatuses have historically treated the territory not as a community of citizens with self-determination, but as a hyper-militarized buffer zone. The rights of the local population are routinely suspended under emergency clauses, security regulations, and administrative crackdowns. Kashmir becomes a national security theater where the state justifies its authoritarian measures by pointing to a existential enemy, much like Oceania’s perpetual, shifting wars with Eurasia and Eastasia.

The System Has Collapsed

Minister Naqvi cautions that the system is broken and warns against civil unrest. The message carries an implicit subtext: the civilian government is simply the expendable skin of the state. The real state must be shielded from public wrath.

Public dissent erupts over inflation, human rights abuses, or rigged mandates. However, the state’s reaction is not to adapt to the popular will, but to enforce compliance through force. The plea for political parties to sit together is less about democratic reconciliation and more an invitation to absorb the blame for a crisis created by the underlying apparatus.

Ultimately, Orwell’s warning in 1984 was not merely about surveillance or censorship. Instead it was about the total erasure of individual agency in service of an unaccountable entity.  The region remains bound to protecting a shadowy establishment at the expense of its people.

 

Similar Posts

  • |

    Subjective aesthetics versus literary brilliance

    Litigation over artistic quality reveals more about the critic’s personal taste and ideological leanings than it does about the intrinsic value of the literature itself. A prominent Bangladeshi academic initiated a debate across literary circles when a short video clip went viral online. In this brief excerpt from a presentation delivered at a university literary festival, the scholar dismissed the acclaimed author Shahidul Zahir. He claimed that Zahir does not even qualify as a third-rate artist. He  labeled him instead as a third-class writer whose language is thoroughly uninteresting. He similarly critiqued another modern Bengali prose writer, Akhteruzzaman Elias. For this case, he dismissed his writing style as endlessly monotonous. This judgment raises critical questions about literary aesthetics and the metrics used to evaluate global literature. Does a critic’s subjective boredom justify reducing a writer’s work to a low rating? Analytically, the fiction of Shahidul Zahir demonstrates the exact qualities that define world-class literature. Shahidul Zahir was never a conventional storyteller who somehow aimed to comfort his audience. Rather than offering comfortable narratives, his work exposes uncomfortable truths beneath established historical accounts. His portrayal of wartime violence, political opportunism, and societal compromise during and after the 1971 Liberation War forces readers to confront disturbing realities. Zahir connects the grim details of local life with magical and surreal elements. He utilizes oral storytelling traditions. He also combined surreal metaphors with layered depictions of the human condition. His narratives have bizarre occurrences such as animals acting as caretakers or war collaborators feeding human flesh to animals appear surprisingly believable against the background of ordinary towns like Sirajganj or Old Dhaka. His surrealism reflects real-world atrocities that were often equally unimaginable far from being mere fantasy. The academic’s critique centered primarily on two claims. Firstly, Zahir’s writing is dull. Secondly, his portrayal of the 1971 war is historically inaccurate. However, a closer look at these claims exposes significant flaws in the critic’s premise. The critic in question strongly favors traditional, highly formal, Sanskritized prose (sadhu bhasha) and rejects everyday spoken dialect (cholito bhasha) for serious discourse. In contrast, Zahir’s prose relies on the living, informal, and at times raw language spoken by everyday people. Therefore, rejecting an author because their prose reflects the authentic cadence of public speech reveals an elitist preference rather than an objective literary standard. The scholar accused Zahir’s acclaimed novella Jibon O Rajnoitik Bastobota (Life and Political Reality) of presenting stereotypical representations. He further pointed the supposed depiction of war collaborators wearing skull caps. Yet, nowhere in the actual text does such a detail exist. The critic appeared to project his own assumptions onto the text rather than reading what was actually written. Zahir’s novella accurately captures the painful political reality of post-liberation Bangladesh, where former wartime collaborators were gradually integrated back into mainstream power structures. Literary scholars often define world literature as creative work that responds to the global dynamics of modern capitalism and political change. Zahir’s novels illustrate how global economic forces interact unevenly with local feudal structures. In his masterpiece Shei Raate Purnima Chhilo (It Was Full Moon That Night), Zahir explores the rise of a powerful rural leader under state-sponsored political reform. The narrative illustrates how modern capitalist development mixes with lingering feudal mentalities. This mentality then creates a system where local elites hold unchecked power. Zahir constructs a portrait of a society caught between tradition and modern governance. Furthermore, Zahir’s treatment of the 1971 war connects local experiences with international geopolitics. In his stories, wartime memories constantly surface like fresh grass breaking through soil. His words speak about how national liberation was simultaneously a local struggle for survival and an event influenced by global Cold War tensions. The argument that a nation must produce literature directly accessible or marketed to Western readers in order to be considered world-class relies on a flawed premise. Global literary status should not depend solely on English translation or commercial visibility. Countless profound authors around the globe write within their local contexts. Such marvelous authors produce works that match the thematic depth of international figures like Franz Kafka or Gabriel García Márquez. As a matter of fact, dismissing Shahidul Zahir as third-class overlooks the artistic, historical, and linguistic power of his work. His fiction stands as an extraordinary accomplishment in modern literature. He is the one that challenges, provokes, and immortalizes the complex human experience far beyond the boundaries of narrow critique.  

  • |

    Silence is the gateway to self-knowledge

    In a world governed by the constant impulse to broadcast every thought, quiet reflection has become a rare commodity. Modern culture often treats silence as an uncomfortable void. It is termed as a gap in conversation that must be immediately filled with idle chatter, opinions, or background noise. However, a insightful cultural piece by The Marginalian revisit Kahlil Gibran’s classic masterpiece, The Prophet. It reminds us that embracing silence is not an act of withdrawal, but a necessary passage toward understanding who we truly are. When Kahlil Gibran wrote The Prophet in 1923, he addressed human struggles that remain relevant today. In his discourse on speech, Gibran suggests that incessant talking often springs from a subtle internal distress. We speak most compulsively when we lose touch with the quiet rhythm of our own thoughts. When we can no longer sit comfortably with our internal world, language transforms from genuine connection into a mere distraction. Thus, rendering itself as verbal pastime designed to drown out silence. Gibran offers a vivid metaphor for this dynamic. He writes that thought is a bird of space that can spread its wings inside a cage of words. Yet, it remains incapable of real flight. By reducing complex feelings into rigid verbal formulas, we often constrain the depth of our experiences. Excessive talk can obscure deeper understanding rather than clarify it. It might replace genuine contemplation with superficial noise. Why do so many people flee from quiet moments? According to Gibran, chatter frequently serves as a shield against the intimidating clarity of solitude. In the stillness of being alone, external distractions vanish. This silence forces us to stand face-to-face with our unvarnished selves: our fears, insecurities, unresolved longings, and raw truths. When Gibran’s prophet-protagonist is asked to address the matter of talking, he responds: You talk when you cease to be at peace with your thoughts; And when you can no longer dwell in the solitude of your heart you live in your lips, and sound is a diversion and a pastime. And in much of your talking, thinking is half murdered. For thought is a bird of space, that in a cage of words may indeed unfold its wings but cannot fly.In a world governed by the constant impulse to broadcast every thought, quiet reflection has become a rare commodity. For many, this exposure feels uncomfortable, triggering an urgent desire to keep a conversation going. It takes genuine courage to endure the silence long enough to hear what our inner world is actually trying to tell us. Gibran’s perspective on self-knowledge carries a warning against over-categorizing human identity. He cautions against treating the human soul as a static math problem or a territory that can be fully mapped and measured. Rather than declaring, “I have found the absolute truth,” Gibran suggests a humbler, more open attitude: “I have found a truth” He describes the human spirit not as a straight line or a single rigid structure, but as a boundless sea unfolding like a lotus with countless petals. When we attempt to define our entire identity through fixed labels or rigid verbal definitions, we risk placing artificial boundaries around a psyche that is naturally vast and evolving. Real self-knowledge isn’t about arriving at a final conclusion about who we are… it is about maintaining a curiosity toward our own inner evolution. Reclaiming Quiet in a Hyper-Connected Age In an epoch characterized by constant connectivity, Gibran’s reflections serve as an urgent invitation to recalibrate our relationship with quietness. Silence is not the absence of sound. Rather, it is a space where creative intuition, emotional healing, and genuine self-awareness take root.  

  • Octopus clings to fisherman’s face

    A surprising video from the Philippines is going viral on social media after an octopus was seen clinging tightly to a fisherman’s face. In the video the octopus has wrapped several of its arms around the man’s face. https://www.instagram.com/reel/Db8hqV-jCoX/?igsh=MWFoNmNucmlzNW1ucQ== The fisherman can be seen struggling to remove it from his face. He tries several times to pull the octopus away but its strong suction cups make it difficult to free himself. After several attempts he slowly loosens the octopus’s grip and finally removes it. The fisherman then releases the octopus back into the water. Experts explain that an octopus has hundreds of suction cups on its eight arms. These help it hold onto different surfaces and objects firmly. The octopus may have reacted defensively because of the unusual situation and tried to protect itself by holding on tightly.

  • Kimchi may help remove microplastics

    Scientists are studying whether kimchi a popular Korean fermented food could help the body remove harmful microplastics. Early research suggests that certain beneficial bacteria found in kimchi may attach to tiny plastic particles during digestion making it easier for the body to remove them through waste. Microplastics are extremely small pieces of plastic that have already been found in human blood lungs and even the placenta. People can take them in through food drinking water and the air they breathe raising concerns about their possible health effects. In the study researchers examined a type of lactic acid bacteria taken from kimchi. They tested it in mice and found that animals given the probiotic passed nearly twice as many microplastic particles in their waste compared with those that did not receive it. Laboratory tests also showed that the bacteria attached to about 57% of the microplastic particles suggesting it may help remove them from the body. However researchers stressed that these findings are still preliminary.  The study does not prove that eating regular kimchi will have the same effect in humans. More clinical studies are needed before scientists can confirm whether kimchi or its beneficial bacteria can help reduce microplastics in the human body.

  • Survey finds divide over AI

    A new report from the Pew Research Center shows that artificial intelligence (AI) experts and the general public have very different opinions about the future of AI. While experts are mostly positive about its impact many people are worried that AI could replace jobs and create new challenges. According to the survey, 56% of AI experts believe the technology will have a positive effect on the United States over the next 20 years. In comparison, only 17% of the public share that view. Experts are more confident that AI will improve the way people work and help grow the economy. However many people are concerned that AI could reduce job opportunities especially in roles that depend on human workers. The report also highlights the jobs experts believe are most likely to be affected by AI. About 73% think cashier jobs could be replaced followed by truck drivers (62%) journalists (60%) factory workers (60%) and software engineers (50%). The public generally agrees with these predictions although only 33% believe truck drivers are at high risk. Both experts and the public agree that healthcare is one of the areas where AI can bring the greatest benefits. They believe AI could improve medical care and support better treatment. At the same time both groups are concerned that AI may not improve the accuracy of news or election coverage. The survey also found strong support for greater control over AI. Many respondents believe governments may struggle to regulate the technology effectively as it continues to develop. Another finding is the difference between male and female AI experts. Around 63% of male experts expect AI to have a positive impact on the United States compared with 36% of female experts. Women were generally more cautious saying the technology could have both benefits and risks. The report also notes that women remain underrepresented in the AI industry. Researchers suggest that increasing women’s participation in AI development could lead to more balanced technologies. They also point out that many jobs with a large number of female workers such as administrative and customer service roles are becoming more automated increasing the risk of job losses. Overall the report shows that understanding both expert opinions and public concerns is important. As AI continues to grow balancing its benefits with responsible rules and safeguards will be essential.

  • | |

    Azma Bukhari slams PPP over Kashmir election defea…

    Punjab Information Minister Azma Bukhari has criticised Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, saying voters in Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) had backed development and modernisation and that political parties should respect the public mandate. Speaking at a press conference in Lahore, Bukhari said the people of the Mirpur Division had made their choice through the ballot and supported the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N). She urged rival parties to accept the election results with an open heart, saying respect for the people’s decision was an essential part of democratic politics. Bukhari claimed that the election outcome had increased frustration within an unnamed political party. Referring to Bilawal’s recent remarks, she accused him of trying to mock the PML-N leadership while avoiding a discussion of his party’s performance in Sindh. She challenged the PPP chairman to present the achievements of his party’s 18-year rule in Sindh, particularly in Karachi. She questioned why the city still lacked an effective public transport system and why municipal authorities struggled to manage waste collection. Comparing the performance of the Punjab and Sindh governments, Bukhari highlighted several initiatives launched under Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz, including public transport projects, the provision of laptops and scholarships to students, air ambulance services, improved drainage equipment and development schemes across the province. She also pointed to projects in southern Punjab, including public transport initiatives and the Recep Tayyip Erdogan Hospital, arguing that the region had received greater attention under the PML-N government. Bukhari further criticised the PPP’s record on education, saying students in Sindh continued to raise concerns over access to educational opportunities, while the Punjab government had expanded scholarship and laptop programmes for young people. She also defended the Punjab government’s response to heavy rainfall, saying authorities had equipped the Water and Sanitation Agency (WASA) with modern machinery to deal with urban flooding and drainage challenges. Bukhari invited Bilawal to visit Punjab and see its development projects firsthand, saying he should compare the performance of the two provinces before criticising Punjab’s infrastructure. Turning to the AJK election results, she said the people had clearly expressed their preference through their votes and urged all political parties to accept the outcome rather than question the public’s choice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *